Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs

Holly Hagan, James P. McGough, Hanne Thiede, Sharon G. Hopkins, Noel S. Weiss, E. Russell Alexander

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective. Nonrandomized comparisons of the incidence of HIV and hepatitis B and C between injection drug users (IDUs) who do and do not attend voluntary needle-exchange programs may be subject to bias. To explore possible sources of bias, we examined characteristics associated with voluntarily beginning or ceasing to participate in the Seattle needle exchange. Methods. In a cohort of 2,879 IDUs, a standardized questionnaire measured characteristics present at enrollment. We examined the relation of these characteristics to the proportion of IDUs who began to use the program during the ensuing 12-month follow-up period and to the proportion of current exchangers who dropped out during that period of time. Results. Of the 494 never-exchangers at baseline, 32% attended the exchange program during follow-up; those who reported sharing syringes or who were homeless at enrollment were more likely to become new exchange users (adjusted risk ratio [ARR] for becoming an exchange user = 1.8 for those who shared syringes, and ARR = 2.2 for those who were homeless). Of 1,274 current exchangers, 16% stopped using the exchange during follow-up, with daily injectors (ARR = 0.6) and those who reported backloading (APR = 0.6) being relatively less likely to drop out of the exchange. Conclusions. The analysis suggests that IDUs participating in needle-exchange programs at a given point in time may include a particularly high proportion of those injectors whose pattern of drug use puts them at elevated risk of blood-borne vital infections.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)103-112
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Urban Health
Volume77
Issue number1
StatePublished - Mar 2000

Fingerprint

Needle-Exchange Programs
Drug Users
Volunteers
Injections
Odds Ratio
trend
evaluation
drug
Needle Sharing
Syringes
Hepatitis C
Hepatitis B
Needles
HIV
drop-out
contagious disease
drug use
Incidence
incidence
Infection

Keywords

  • HBV
  • HCV
  • HIV
  • Injection Drug Use
  • Needle-Exchange Program
  • Prevention
  • Study Bias
  • Substance Abuse
  • Syringe-Exchange Program

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

Hagan, H., McGough, J. P., Thiede, H., Hopkins, S. G., Weiss, N. S., & Alexander, E. R. (2000). Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs. Journal of Urban Health, 77(1), 103-112.

Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs. / Hagan, Holly; McGough, James P.; Thiede, Hanne; Hopkins, Sharon G.; Weiss, Noel S.; Alexander, E. Russell.

In: Journal of Urban Health, Vol. 77, No. 1, 03.2000, p. 103-112.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hagan, H, McGough, JP, Thiede, H, Hopkins, SG, Weiss, NS & Alexander, ER 2000, 'Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs', Journal of Urban Health, vol. 77, no. 1, pp. 103-112.
Hagan H, McGough JP, Thiede H, Hopkins SG, Weiss NS, Alexander ER. Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs. Journal of Urban Health. 2000 Mar;77(1):103-112.
Hagan, Holly ; McGough, James P. ; Thiede, Hanne ; Hopkins, Sharon G. ; Weiss, Noel S. ; Alexander, E. Russell. / Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs. In: Journal of Urban Health. 2000 ; Vol. 77, No. 1. pp. 103-112.
@article{b30f335d7a3c4a80ae0e2f33fb2e628b,
title = "Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs",
abstract = "Objective. Nonrandomized comparisons of the incidence of HIV and hepatitis B and C between injection drug users (IDUs) who do and do not attend voluntary needle-exchange programs may be subject to bias. To explore possible sources of bias, we examined characteristics associated with voluntarily beginning or ceasing to participate in the Seattle needle exchange. Methods. In a cohort of 2,879 IDUs, a standardized questionnaire measured characteristics present at enrollment. We examined the relation of these characteristics to the proportion of IDUs who began to use the program during the ensuing 12-month follow-up period and to the proportion of current exchangers who dropped out during that period of time. Results. Of the 494 never-exchangers at baseline, 32{\%} attended the exchange program during follow-up; those who reported sharing syringes or who were homeless at enrollment were more likely to become new exchange users (adjusted risk ratio [ARR] for becoming an exchange user = 1.8 for those who shared syringes, and ARR = 2.2 for those who were homeless). Of 1,274 current exchangers, 16{\%} stopped using the exchange during follow-up, with daily injectors (ARR = 0.6) and those who reported backloading (APR = 0.6) being relatively less likely to drop out of the exchange. Conclusions. The analysis suggests that IDUs participating in needle-exchange programs at a given point in time may include a particularly high proportion of those injectors whose pattern of drug use puts them at elevated risk of blood-borne vital infections.",
keywords = "HBV, HCV, HIV, Injection Drug Use, Needle-Exchange Program, Prevention, Study Bias, Substance Abuse, Syringe-Exchange Program",
author = "Holly Hagan and McGough, {James P.} and Hanne Thiede and Hopkins, {Sharon G.} and Weiss, {Noel S.} and Alexander, {E. Russell}",
year = "2000",
month = "3",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "77",
pages = "103--112",
journal = "Journal of Urban Health",
issn = "1099-3460",
publisher = "Springer Science and Business Media Deutschland GmbH",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Volunteer bias in nonrandomized evaluations of the efficacy of needle- exchange programs

AU - Hagan, Holly

AU - McGough, James P.

AU - Thiede, Hanne

AU - Hopkins, Sharon G.

AU - Weiss, Noel S.

AU - Alexander, E. Russell

PY - 2000/3

Y1 - 2000/3

N2 - Objective. Nonrandomized comparisons of the incidence of HIV and hepatitis B and C between injection drug users (IDUs) who do and do not attend voluntary needle-exchange programs may be subject to bias. To explore possible sources of bias, we examined characteristics associated with voluntarily beginning or ceasing to participate in the Seattle needle exchange. Methods. In a cohort of 2,879 IDUs, a standardized questionnaire measured characteristics present at enrollment. We examined the relation of these characteristics to the proportion of IDUs who began to use the program during the ensuing 12-month follow-up period and to the proportion of current exchangers who dropped out during that period of time. Results. Of the 494 never-exchangers at baseline, 32% attended the exchange program during follow-up; those who reported sharing syringes or who were homeless at enrollment were more likely to become new exchange users (adjusted risk ratio [ARR] for becoming an exchange user = 1.8 for those who shared syringes, and ARR = 2.2 for those who were homeless). Of 1,274 current exchangers, 16% stopped using the exchange during follow-up, with daily injectors (ARR = 0.6) and those who reported backloading (APR = 0.6) being relatively less likely to drop out of the exchange. Conclusions. The analysis suggests that IDUs participating in needle-exchange programs at a given point in time may include a particularly high proportion of those injectors whose pattern of drug use puts them at elevated risk of blood-borne vital infections.

AB - Objective. Nonrandomized comparisons of the incidence of HIV and hepatitis B and C between injection drug users (IDUs) who do and do not attend voluntary needle-exchange programs may be subject to bias. To explore possible sources of bias, we examined characteristics associated with voluntarily beginning or ceasing to participate in the Seattle needle exchange. Methods. In a cohort of 2,879 IDUs, a standardized questionnaire measured characteristics present at enrollment. We examined the relation of these characteristics to the proportion of IDUs who began to use the program during the ensuing 12-month follow-up period and to the proportion of current exchangers who dropped out during that period of time. Results. Of the 494 never-exchangers at baseline, 32% attended the exchange program during follow-up; those who reported sharing syringes or who were homeless at enrollment were more likely to become new exchange users (adjusted risk ratio [ARR] for becoming an exchange user = 1.8 for those who shared syringes, and ARR = 2.2 for those who were homeless). Of 1,274 current exchangers, 16% stopped using the exchange during follow-up, with daily injectors (ARR = 0.6) and those who reported backloading (APR = 0.6) being relatively less likely to drop out of the exchange. Conclusions. The analysis suggests that IDUs participating in needle-exchange programs at a given point in time may include a particularly high proportion of those injectors whose pattern of drug use puts them at elevated risk of blood-borne vital infections.

KW - HBV

KW - HCV

KW - HIV

KW - Injection Drug Use

KW - Needle-Exchange Program

KW - Prevention

KW - Study Bias

KW - Substance Abuse

KW - Syringe-Exchange Program

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034003796&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034003796&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 10741846

AN - SCOPUS:0034003796

VL - 77

SP - 103

EP - 112

JO - Journal of Urban Health

JF - Journal of Urban Health

SN - 1099-3460

IS - 1

ER -