Variation in teenage mothers' experiences of child care and other components of welfare reform: Selection processes and developmental consequences

Hirokazu Yoshikawa, Elisa Altman Rosman, JoAnn Hsueh

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Developmental evaluations of the current wave of welfare reform programs present challenges with regard to (1) assessing child outcomes; (2) accounting for heterogeneity among low-income families in both baseline characteristics and involvement in self-sufficiency activities and supports, and (3) development of alternatives to experimental approaches to causal inference. This study (N = 1,079) addresses these challenges by examining effects on 4- to 6-year-old children of different patterns of child care, self-sufficiency activities, and other service utilization indicators among experimental-group mothers in a 16-site welfare reform program. Outcomes in areas of cognitive ability and behavior problems were investigated. The study identified seven subgroups of participants engaging in different patterns of service utilization and activity involvement. A two-stage simultaneous equation methodology was used to account for selection, and effects on child cognitive ability of participation in specific patterns of services and activities were found. For example, children of mothers characterized by high levels of involvement in center-based child care, education, and job training showed higher levels of cognitive ability than children of mothers in groups characterized by high involvement in center-based care and education, or center-based care and job training. In addition, children of mothers in groups with high levels of involvement in any of these activities showed higher levels of cognitive ability than those with low levels of involvement. The bulk of selection effects occurred through site-level differences, rather than family-level socioeconomic status or maternal depression indicators. Implications for welfare reform program and policy concerns are discussed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)299-317
Number of pages19
JournalChild Development
Volume72
Issue number1
StatePublished - Jan 2001

Fingerprint

Child Care
child care
Aptitude
welfare
Mothers
cognitive ability
reform
reform program
experience
self-sufficiency
utilization
Education
Group
reform policy
Social Class
social status
cognition
education
low income
Depression

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychology(all)
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

Variation in teenage mothers' experiences of child care and other components of welfare reform : Selection processes and developmental consequences. / Yoshikawa, Hirokazu; Rosman, Elisa Altman; Hsueh, JoAnn.

In: Child Development, Vol. 72, No. 1, 01.2001, p. 299-317.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{094f653727084dca9a2d8b90c2f18584,
title = "Variation in teenage mothers' experiences of child care and other components of welfare reform: Selection processes and developmental consequences",
abstract = "Developmental evaluations of the current wave of welfare reform programs present challenges with regard to (1) assessing child outcomes; (2) accounting for heterogeneity among low-income families in both baseline characteristics and involvement in self-sufficiency activities and supports, and (3) development of alternatives to experimental approaches to causal inference. This study (N = 1,079) addresses these challenges by examining effects on 4- to 6-year-old children of different patterns of child care, self-sufficiency activities, and other service utilization indicators among experimental-group mothers in a 16-site welfare reform program. Outcomes in areas of cognitive ability and behavior problems were investigated. The study identified seven subgroups of participants engaging in different patterns of service utilization and activity involvement. A two-stage simultaneous equation methodology was used to account for selection, and effects on child cognitive ability of participation in specific patterns of services and activities were found. For example, children of mothers characterized by high levels of involvement in center-based child care, education, and job training showed higher levels of cognitive ability than children of mothers in groups characterized by high involvement in center-based care and education, or center-based care and job training. In addition, children of mothers in groups with high levels of involvement in any of these activities showed higher levels of cognitive ability than those with low levels of involvement. The bulk of selection effects occurred through site-level differences, rather than family-level socioeconomic status or maternal depression indicators. Implications for welfare reform program and policy concerns are discussed.",
author = "Hirokazu Yoshikawa and Rosman, {Elisa Altman} and JoAnn Hsueh",
year = "2001",
month = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "72",
pages = "299--317",
journal = "Child Development",
issn = "0009-3920",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Variation in teenage mothers' experiences of child care and other components of welfare reform

T2 - Selection processes and developmental consequences

AU - Yoshikawa, Hirokazu

AU - Rosman, Elisa Altman

AU - Hsueh, JoAnn

PY - 2001/1

Y1 - 2001/1

N2 - Developmental evaluations of the current wave of welfare reform programs present challenges with regard to (1) assessing child outcomes; (2) accounting for heterogeneity among low-income families in both baseline characteristics and involvement in self-sufficiency activities and supports, and (3) development of alternatives to experimental approaches to causal inference. This study (N = 1,079) addresses these challenges by examining effects on 4- to 6-year-old children of different patterns of child care, self-sufficiency activities, and other service utilization indicators among experimental-group mothers in a 16-site welfare reform program. Outcomes in areas of cognitive ability and behavior problems were investigated. The study identified seven subgroups of participants engaging in different patterns of service utilization and activity involvement. A two-stage simultaneous equation methodology was used to account for selection, and effects on child cognitive ability of participation in specific patterns of services and activities were found. For example, children of mothers characterized by high levels of involvement in center-based child care, education, and job training showed higher levels of cognitive ability than children of mothers in groups characterized by high involvement in center-based care and education, or center-based care and job training. In addition, children of mothers in groups with high levels of involvement in any of these activities showed higher levels of cognitive ability than those with low levels of involvement. The bulk of selection effects occurred through site-level differences, rather than family-level socioeconomic status or maternal depression indicators. Implications for welfare reform program and policy concerns are discussed.

AB - Developmental evaluations of the current wave of welfare reform programs present challenges with regard to (1) assessing child outcomes; (2) accounting for heterogeneity among low-income families in both baseline characteristics and involvement in self-sufficiency activities and supports, and (3) development of alternatives to experimental approaches to causal inference. This study (N = 1,079) addresses these challenges by examining effects on 4- to 6-year-old children of different patterns of child care, self-sufficiency activities, and other service utilization indicators among experimental-group mothers in a 16-site welfare reform program. Outcomes in areas of cognitive ability and behavior problems were investigated. The study identified seven subgroups of participants engaging in different patterns of service utilization and activity involvement. A two-stage simultaneous equation methodology was used to account for selection, and effects on child cognitive ability of participation in specific patterns of services and activities were found. For example, children of mothers characterized by high levels of involvement in center-based child care, education, and job training showed higher levels of cognitive ability than children of mothers in groups characterized by high involvement in center-based care and education, or center-based care and job training. In addition, children of mothers in groups with high levels of involvement in any of these activities showed higher levels of cognitive ability than those with low levels of involvement. The bulk of selection effects occurred through site-level differences, rather than family-level socioeconomic status or maternal depression indicators. Implications for welfare reform program and policy concerns are discussed.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035234445&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0035234445&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 11280486

AN - SCOPUS:0035234445

VL - 72

SP - 299

EP - 317

JO - Child Development

JF - Child Development

SN - 0009-3920

IS - 1

ER -