Using visual noise to characterize amblyopic letter identification

Denis Pelli, Dennis M. Levin, Susana T L Chung

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Amblyopia is a much-studied but poorly understood developmental visual disorder that reduces acuity, profoundly reducing contrast sensitivity for small targets. Here we use visual noise to probe the letter identification process and characterize its impairment by amblyopia. We apply five levels of analysis - threshold, threshold in noise, equivalent noise, optical MTF, and noise modeling - to obtain a two-factor model of the amblyopic deficit: substantially reduced efficiency for small letters and negligibly increased cortical noise. Cortical noise, expressed as an equivalent input noise, varies among amblyopes but is roughly 1.4× normal, as though only 1/1.4 the normal number of cortical spikes are devoted to the amblyopic eye. This raises threshold contrast for large letters by a factor of √1.4 = 1.2×, a negligible effect. All 16 amblyopic observers showed near-normal efficiency for large letters (> 4× acuity) and greatly reduced efficiency for small letters: 1/4 normal at 2× acuity and approaching 1/16 normal at acuity. Finding that the acuity loss represents a loss of efficiency rules out all models of amblyopia except those that predict the same sensitivity loss on blank and noisy backgrounds. One such model is the last-channel hypothesis, which supposes that the highest-spatial-frequency channels are missing, leaving the remaining highest-frequency channel struggling to identify the smallest letters. However, this hypothesis is rejected by critical band masking of letter identification, which shows that the channels used by the amblyopic eye have normal tuning for even the smallest letters. Finally, based on these results, we introduce a new "Dual Acuity" chart that promises to be a quick diagnostic test for amblyopia.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number6
Pages (from-to)904-920
Number of pages17
JournalJournal of vision
Volume4
Issue number10
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 29 2004

Fingerprint

Amblyopia
Noise
Contrast Sensitivity
Vision Disorders
Prothrombin Time
Routine Diagnostic Tests

Keywords

  • Amblyopia
  • Cortical noise
  • Efficiency
  • Noise
  • Pelli-Levi Dual Acuity Chart

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ophthalmology

Cite this

Using visual noise to characterize amblyopic letter identification. / Pelli, Denis; Levin, Dennis M.; Chung, Susana T L.

In: Journal of vision, Vol. 4, No. 10, 6, 29.10.2004, p. 904-920.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Pelli, Denis ; Levin, Dennis M. ; Chung, Susana T L. / Using visual noise to characterize amblyopic letter identification. In: Journal of vision. 2004 ; Vol. 4, No. 10. pp. 904-920.
@article{d090c97a816e4e96af1bdf2d83ec37ef,
title = "Using visual noise to characterize amblyopic letter identification",
abstract = "Amblyopia is a much-studied but poorly understood developmental visual disorder that reduces acuity, profoundly reducing contrast sensitivity for small targets. Here we use visual noise to probe the letter identification process and characterize its impairment by amblyopia. We apply five levels of analysis - threshold, threshold in noise, equivalent noise, optical MTF, and noise modeling - to obtain a two-factor model of the amblyopic deficit: substantially reduced efficiency for small letters and negligibly increased cortical noise. Cortical noise, expressed as an equivalent input noise, varies among amblyopes but is roughly 1.4× normal, as though only 1/1.4 the normal number of cortical spikes are devoted to the amblyopic eye. This raises threshold contrast for large letters by a factor of √1.4 = 1.2×, a negligible effect. All 16 amblyopic observers showed near-normal efficiency for large letters (> 4× acuity) and greatly reduced efficiency for small letters: 1/4 normal at 2× acuity and approaching 1/16 normal at acuity. Finding that the acuity loss represents a loss of efficiency rules out all models of amblyopia except those that predict the same sensitivity loss on blank and noisy backgrounds. One such model is the last-channel hypothesis, which supposes that the highest-spatial-frequency channels are missing, leaving the remaining highest-frequency channel struggling to identify the smallest letters. However, this hypothesis is rejected by critical band masking of letter identification, which shows that the channels used by the amblyopic eye have normal tuning for even the smallest letters. Finally, based on these results, we introduce a new {"}Dual Acuity{"} chart that promises to be a quick diagnostic test for amblyopia.",
keywords = "Amblyopia, Cortical noise, Efficiency, Noise, Pelli-Levi Dual Acuity Chart",
author = "Denis Pelli and Levin, {Dennis M.} and Chung, {Susana T L}",
year = "2004",
month = "10",
day = "29",
doi = "10.1167/4.10.6",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "4",
pages = "904--920",
journal = "Journal of vision",
issn = "1534-7362",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using visual noise to characterize amblyopic letter identification

AU - Pelli, Denis

AU - Levin, Dennis M.

AU - Chung, Susana T L

PY - 2004/10/29

Y1 - 2004/10/29

N2 - Amblyopia is a much-studied but poorly understood developmental visual disorder that reduces acuity, profoundly reducing contrast sensitivity for small targets. Here we use visual noise to probe the letter identification process and characterize its impairment by amblyopia. We apply five levels of analysis - threshold, threshold in noise, equivalent noise, optical MTF, and noise modeling - to obtain a two-factor model of the amblyopic deficit: substantially reduced efficiency for small letters and negligibly increased cortical noise. Cortical noise, expressed as an equivalent input noise, varies among amblyopes but is roughly 1.4× normal, as though only 1/1.4 the normal number of cortical spikes are devoted to the amblyopic eye. This raises threshold contrast for large letters by a factor of √1.4 = 1.2×, a negligible effect. All 16 amblyopic observers showed near-normal efficiency for large letters (> 4× acuity) and greatly reduced efficiency for small letters: 1/4 normal at 2× acuity and approaching 1/16 normal at acuity. Finding that the acuity loss represents a loss of efficiency rules out all models of amblyopia except those that predict the same sensitivity loss on blank and noisy backgrounds. One such model is the last-channel hypothesis, which supposes that the highest-spatial-frequency channels are missing, leaving the remaining highest-frequency channel struggling to identify the smallest letters. However, this hypothesis is rejected by critical band masking of letter identification, which shows that the channels used by the amblyopic eye have normal tuning for even the smallest letters. Finally, based on these results, we introduce a new "Dual Acuity" chart that promises to be a quick diagnostic test for amblyopia.

AB - Amblyopia is a much-studied but poorly understood developmental visual disorder that reduces acuity, profoundly reducing contrast sensitivity for small targets. Here we use visual noise to probe the letter identification process and characterize its impairment by amblyopia. We apply five levels of analysis - threshold, threshold in noise, equivalent noise, optical MTF, and noise modeling - to obtain a two-factor model of the amblyopic deficit: substantially reduced efficiency for small letters and negligibly increased cortical noise. Cortical noise, expressed as an equivalent input noise, varies among amblyopes but is roughly 1.4× normal, as though only 1/1.4 the normal number of cortical spikes are devoted to the amblyopic eye. This raises threshold contrast for large letters by a factor of √1.4 = 1.2×, a negligible effect. All 16 amblyopic observers showed near-normal efficiency for large letters (> 4× acuity) and greatly reduced efficiency for small letters: 1/4 normal at 2× acuity and approaching 1/16 normal at acuity. Finding that the acuity loss represents a loss of efficiency rules out all models of amblyopia except those that predict the same sensitivity loss on blank and noisy backgrounds. One such model is the last-channel hypothesis, which supposes that the highest-spatial-frequency channels are missing, leaving the remaining highest-frequency channel struggling to identify the smallest letters. However, this hypothesis is rejected by critical band masking of letter identification, which shows that the channels used by the amblyopic eye have normal tuning for even the smallest letters. Finally, based on these results, we introduce a new "Dual Acuity" chart that promises to be a quick diagnostic test for amblyopia.

KW - Amblyopia

KW - Cortical noise

KW - Efficiency

KW - Noise

KW - Pelli-Levi Dual Acuity Chart

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=17844379308&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=17844379308&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1167/4.10.6

DO - 10.1167/4.10.6

M3 - Article

VL - 4

SP - 904

EP - 920

JO - Journal of vision

JF - Journal of vision

SN - 1534-7362

IS - 10

M1 - 6

ER -