Topographically directed nucleation of organic crystals on molecular single-crystal substrates

Phillip W. Carter, Michael Ward

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The role of specific crystal planes of single crystals of β-succinic acid (sa) and L-valine (val) as substrates for the nucleation and growth of organic crystals has been examined. Freshly cleaved crystals of these substrates provide flat terraces and ledge sites corresponding to planes whose molecular structures are well-defined by the crystallographic structure of the substrate. Nucleation of benzoic acid on these substrates occurs at low driving force at [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites formed from pairs of planes identified by atomic force microscopy as (01̄0)sa ∩ (11̄1)sa and (001)val ∩ (2̄01)val, respectively. Growth from these ledge sites is attributed to lowering of the prenucleation aggregate free energy via "ledge directed epitaxy" that involves a lattice match between the substrate and growing phase along the ledge direction, and equivalent dihedral angles of the substrate ledge sites and a pair of aggregate planes whose identity is assigned on the basis of the structure of the mature crystal. For example, the [101̄]sa ledge has a 1.0% lattice mismatch with the [110] direction of benzoic acid and a difference of only 0.6° between the ledge dihedral angle and the dihedral angle of the (001)ba ∩ (11̄2)ba planes. On the basis of the crystal structures, these interfaces consist of "molecularly smooth" low-energy planes, consistent with stabilization of the prenucleation aggregates by dispersive interactions. As a consequence of these epitaxial effects and the crystallographic symmetry of the monoclinic space groups of the substrates and benzoic acid, benzoic acid growth is highly oriented. Oriented growth of 4-nitroaniline (pna) crystals is also observed on [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites, with [101̄]pna, the direction containing hydrogen-bonded 4-nitroaniline chains, aligned along the ledge directions. In each case, the lattice mismatch along the ledge direction is small and stabilization of the prenucleation aggregate by interaction with both planes of the ledge is evident from the absence of nucleation on ledge-free areas of the substrates. Experimental observations and calculations suggest that topographically directed growth orientation is observed when aggregate adsorption at the ledge is dominated by dispersive forces. Smaller contributions from dipolar and hydrogen bonding interactions may also play a role in nucleation of 4-nitroaniline on L-valine, in which 4-nitroaniline chains align with the polar [010]val axis of the substrate ledge. These studies indicate that generally accepted epitaxy concepts involving principal lattice directions of the substrate and growing phase may be an oversimplified explanation of crystal growth on crystalline substrates. Rather, nucleation of crystalline phases on molecular crystal substrates is controlled by topographic structure, lattice parameters of ledge nucleation sites, symmetry constraints, and molecular composition of aggregate and substrate crystal planes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)11521-11535
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of the American Chemical Society
Volume115
Issue number24
StatePublished - 1993

Fingerprint

Molecular crystals
Succinic Acid
Benzoic Acid
Nucleation
Single crystals
Crystals
Substrates
Valine
Benzoic acid
Growth
Crystallization
Acids
Dihedral angle
Atomic Force Microscopy
Lattice mismatch
Hydrogen Bonding
Molecular Structure
Adsorption
Epitaxial growth
Crystal lattices

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemistry(all)

Cite this

Topographically directed nucleation of organic crystals on molecular single-crystal substrates. / Carter, Phillip W.; Ward, Michael.

In: Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 115, No. 24, 1993, p. 11521-11535.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9a59eaf4759443b59221353911d4f994,
title = "Topographically directed nucleation of organic crystals on molecular single-crystal substrates",
abstract = "The role of specific crystal planes of single crystals of β-succinic acid (sa) and L-valine (val) as substrates for the nucleation and growth of organic crystals has been examined. Freshly cleaved crystals of these substrates provide flat terraces and ledge sites corresponding to planes whose molecular structures are well-defined by the crystallographic structure of the substrate. Nucleation of benzoic acid on these substrates occurs at low driving force at [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites formed from pairs of planes identified by atomic force microscopy as (01̄0)sa ∩ (11̄1)sa and (001)val ∩ (2̄01)val, respectively. Growth from these ledge sites is attributed to lowering of the prenucleation aggregate free energy via {"}ledge directed epitaxy{"} that involves a lattice match between the substrate and growing phase along the ledge direction, and equivalent dihedral angles of the substrate ledge sites and a pair of aggregate planes whose identity is assigned on the basis of the structure of the mature crystal. For example, the [101̄]sa ledge has a 1.0{\%} lattice mismatch with the [110] direction of benzoic acid and a difference of only 0.6° between the ledge dihedral angle and the dihedral angle of the (001)ba ∩ (11̄2)ba planes. On the basis of the crystal structures, these interfaces consist of {"}molecularly smooth{"} low-energy planes, consistent with stabilization of the prenucleation aggregates by dispersive interactions. As a consequence of these epitaxial effects and the crystallographic symmetry of the monoclinic space groups of the substrates and benzoic acid, benzoic acid growth is highly oriented. Oriented growth of 4-nitroaniline (pna) crystals is also observed on [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites, with [101̄]pna, the direction containing hydrogen-bonded 4-nitroaniline chains, aligned along the ledge directions. In each case, the lattice mismatch along the ledge direction is small and stabilization of the prenucleation aggregate by interaction with both planes of the ledge is evident from the absence of nucleation on ledge-free areas of the substrates. Experimental observations and calculations suggest that topographically directed growth orientation is observed when aggregate adsorption at the ledge is dominated by dispersive forces. Smaller contributions from dipolar and hydrogen bonding interactions may also play a role in nucleation of 4-nitroaniline on L-valine, in which 4-nitroaniline chains align with the polar [010]val axis of the substrate ledge. These studies indicate that generally accepted epitaxy concepts involving principal lattice directions of the substrate and growing phase may be an oversimplified explanation of crystal growth on crystalline substrates. Rather, nucleation of crystalline phases on molecular crystal substrates is controlled by topographic structure, lattice parameters of ledge nucleation sites, symmetry constraints, and molecular composition of aggregate and substrate crystal planes.",
author = "Carter, {Phillip W.} and Michael Ward",
year = "1993",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "115",
pages = "11521--11535",
journal = "Journal of the American Chemical Society",
issn = "0002-7863",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "24",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Topographically directed nucleation of organic crystals on molecular single-crystal substrates

AU - Carter, Phillip W.

AU - Ward, Michael

PY - 1993

Y1 - 1993

N2 - The role of specific crystal planes of single crystals of β-succinic acid (sa) and L-valine (val) as substrates for the nucleation and growth of organic crystals has been examined. Freshly cleaved crystals of these substrates provide flat terraces and ledge sites corresponding to planes whose molecular structures are well-defined by the crystallographic structure of the substrate. Nucleation of benzoic acid on these substrates occurs at low driving force at [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites formed from pairs of planes identified by atomic force microscopy as (01̄0)sa ∩ (11̄1)sa and (001)val ∩ (2̄01)val, respectively. Growth from these ledge sites is attributed to lowering of the prenucleation aggregate free energy via "ledge directed epitaxy" that involves a lattice match between the substrate and growing phase along the ledge direction, and equivalent dihedral angles of the substrate ledge sites and a pair of aggregate planes whose identity is assigned on the basis of the structure of the mature crystal. For example, the [101̄]sa ledge has a 1.0% lattice mismatch with the [110] direction of benzoic acid and a difference of only 0.6° between the ledge dihedral angle and the dihedral angle of the (001)ba ∩ (11̄2)ba planes. On the basis of the crystal structures, these interfaces consist of "molecularly smooth" low-energy planes, consistent with stabilization of the prenucleation aggregates by dispersive interactions. As a consequence of these epitaxial effects and the crystallographic symmetry of the monoclinic space groups of the substrates and benzoic acid, benzoic acid growth is highly oriented. Oriented growth of 4-nitroaniline (pna) crystals is also observed on [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites, with [101̄]pna, the direction containing hydrogen-bonded 4-nitroaniline chains, aligned along the ledge directions. In each case, the lattice mismatch along the ledge direction is small and stabilization of the prenucleation aggregate by interaction with both planes of the ledge is evident from the absence of nucleation on ledge-free areas of the substrates. Experimental observations and calculations suggest that topographically directed growth orientation is observed when aggregate adsorption at the ledge is dominated by dispersive forces. Smaller contributions from dipolar and hydrogen bonding interactions may also play a role in nucleation of 4-nitroaniline on L-valine, in which 4-nitroaniline chains align with the polar [010]val axis of the substrate ledge. These studies indicate that generally accepted epitaxy concepts involving principal lattice directions of the substrate and growing phase may be an oversimplified explanation of crystal growth on crystalline substrates. Rather, nucleation of crystalline phases on molecular crystal substrates is controlled by topographic structure, lattice parameters of ledge nucleation sites, symmetry constraints, and molecular composition of aggregate and substrate crystal planes.

AB - The role of specific crystal planes of single crystals of β-succinic acid (sa) and L-valine (val) as substrates for the nucleation and growth of organic crystals has been examined. Freshly cleaved crystals of these substrates provide flat terraces and ledge sites corresponding to planes whose molecular structures are well-defined by the crystallographic structure of the substrate. Nucleation of benzoic acid on these substrates occurs at low driving force at [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites formed from pairs of planes identified by atomic force microscopy as (01̄0)sa ∩ (11̄1)sa and (001)val ∩ (2̄01)val, respectively. Growth from these ledge sites is attributed to lowering of the prenucleation aggregate free energy via "ledge directed epitaxy" that involves a lattice match between the substrate and growing phase along the ledge direction, and equivalent dihedral angles of the substrate ledge sites and a pair of aggregate planes whose identity is assigned on the basis of the structure of the mature crystal. For example, the [101̄]sa ledge has a 1.0% lattice mismatch with the [110] direction of benzoic acid and a difference of only 0.6° between the ledge dihedral angle and the dihedral angle of the (001)ba ∩ (11̄2)ba planes. On the basis of the crystal structures, these interfaces consist of "molecularly smooth" low-energy planes, consistent with stabilization of the prenucleation aggregates by dispersive interactions. As a consequence of these epitaxial effects and the crystallographic symmetry of the monoclinic space groups of the substrates and benzoic acid, benzoic acid growth is highly oriented. Oriented growth of 4-nitroaniline (pna) crystals is also observed on [101̄]sa and [010]val ledge sites, with [101̄]pna, the direction containing hydrogen-bonded 4-nitroaniline chains, aligned along the ledge directions. In each case, the lattice mismatch along the ledge direction is small and stabilization of the prenucleation aggregate by interaction with both planes of the ledge is evident from the absence of nucleation on ledge-free areas of the substrates. Experimental observations and calculations suggest that topographically directed growth orientation is observed when aggregate adsorption at the ledge is dominated by dispersive forces. Smaller contributions from dipolar and hydrogen bonding interactions may also play a role in nucleation of 4-nitroaniline on L-valine, in which 4-nitroaniline chains align with the polar [010]val axis of the substrate ledge. These studies indicate that generally accepted epitaxy concepts involving principal lattice directions of the substrate and growing phase may be an oversimplified explanation of crystal growth on crystalline substrates. Rather, nucleation of crystalline phases on molecular crystal substrates is controlled by topographic structure, lattice parameters of ledge nucleation sites, symmetry constraints, and molecular composition of aggregate and substrate crystal planes.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0000864883&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0000864883&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0000864883

VL - 115

SP - 11521

EP - 11535

JO - Journal of the American Chemical Society

JF - Journal of the American Chemical Society

SN - 0002-7863

IS - 24

ER -