The U.S.-China contest (II)

Risk of a thucydides trap (?)

James Hsiung

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Abstract

    I put a question mark after "Thucydides Trap" in the chapter's title to register my skepticism about the supposed similarity between the current China-U.S. face-off and the Athens-Sparta contest preceding the Peloponnesian War. There are, to me, at least three substantive reasons why the two situations are totally incompatible: (a) China is not a first-time upstart, but is on its second rise after a century and a half of decline, during which it learned that the world needed social justice and safeguards against the encroachments by the powerful against the weak, as discussed in Chapter 6. (b) The system of states in which China and the United States find themselves today, wrapped in a relationship that Richard Rosecrance depicts as "vulnerability interdependence," is qualitatively different from the ancient Greek system of states where such interdependence was unknown between Athens and Sparta. (c) China's clout thus far is derived predominantly from its surging economic expansion; but its military might is not up to a level that would instill the sort of "fear" that the rising Athens did in Sparta, as Thucydides observed.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Title of host publicationSeries on Contemporary China
    PublisherWorld Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd
    Pages141-151
    Number of pages11
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Jan 1 2018

    Publication series

    NameSeries on Contemporary China
    Volume43
    ISSN (Print)1793-0847

    Fingerprint

    China
    interdependence
    social justice
    vulnerability
    Military
    anxiety
    Contests
    economics
    Sparta
    Athens
    Interdependence
    Social Justice
    Skepticism
    Economics
    Thucydides
    Rise
    Vulnerability
    Peloponnesian War
    Ancient Greek
    Safeguards

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Sociology and Political Science
    • Political Science and International Relations
    • Cultural Studies
    • Anthropology
    • History
    • Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous)

    Cite this

    Hsiung, J. (2018). The U.S.-China contest (II): Risk of a thucydides trap (?). In Series on Contemporary China (pp. 141-151). (Series on Contemporary China; Vol. 43). World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1142/9789813231108_0007

    The U.S.-China contest (II) : Risk of a thucydides trap (?). / Hsiung, James.

    Series on Contemporary China. World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd, 2018. p. 141-151 (Series on Contemporary China; Vol. 43).

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Hsiung, J 2018, The U.S.-China contest (II): Risk of a thucydides trap (?). in Series on Contemporary China. Series on Contemporary China, vol. 43, World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd, pp. 141-151. https://doi.org/10.1142/9789813231108_0007
    Hsiung J. The U.S.-China contest (II): Risk of a thucydides trap (?). In Series on Contemporary China. World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd. 2018. p. 141-151. (Series on Contemporary China). https://doi.org/10.1142/9789813231108_0007
    Hsiung, James. / The U.S.-China contest (II) : Risk of a thucydides trap (?). Series on Contemporary China. World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd, 2018. pp. 141-151 (Series on Contemporary China).
    @inbook{877960ea466348a38947a405f2d4e600,
    title = "The U.S.-China contest (II): Risk of a thucydides trap (?)",
    abstract = "I put a question mark after {"}Thucydides Trap{"} in the chapter's title to register my skepticism about the supposed similarity between the current China-U.S. face-off and the Athens-Sparta contest preceding the Peloponnesian War. There are, to me, at least three substantive reasons why the two situations are totally incompatible: (a) China is not a first-time upstart, but is on its second rise after a century and a half of decline, during which it learned that the world needed social justice and safeguards against the encroachments by the powerful against the weak, as discussed in Chapter 6. (b) The system of states in which China and the United States find themselves today, wrapped in a relationship that Richard Rosecrance depicts as {"}vulnerability interdependence,{"} is qualitatively different from the ancient Greek system of states where such interdependence was unknown between Athens and Sparta. (c) China's clout thus far is derived predominantly from its surging economic expansion; but its military might is not up to a level that would instill the sort of {"}fear{"} that the rising Athens did in Sparta, as Thucydides observed.",
    author = "James Hsiung",
    year = "2018",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1142/9789813231108_0007",
    language = "English (US)",
    series = "Series on Contemporary China",
    publisher = "World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd",
    pages = "141--151",
    booktitle = "Series on Contemporary China",
    address = "Singapore",

    }

    TY - CHAP

    T1 - The U.S.-China contest (II)

    T2 - Risk of a thucydides trap (?)

    AU - Hsiung, James

    PY - 2018/1/1

    Y1 - 2018/1/1

    N2 - I put a question mark after "Thucydides Trap" in the chapter's title to register my skepticism about the supposed similarity between the current China-U.S. face-off and the Athens-Sparta contest preceding the Peloponnesian War. There are, to me, at least three substantive reasons why the two situations are totally incompatible: (a) China is not a first-time upstart, but is on its second rise after a century and a half of decline, during which it learned that the world needed social justice and safeguards against the encroachments by the powerful against the weak, as discussed in Chapter 6. (b) The system of states in which China and the United States find themselves today, wrapped in a relationship that Richard Rosecrance depicts as "vulnerability interdependence," is qualitatively different from the ancient Greek system of states where such interdependence was unknown between Athens and Sparta. (c) China's clout thus far is derived predominantly from its surging economic expansion; but its military might is not up to a level that would instill the sort of "fear" that the rising Athens did in Sparta, as Thucydides observed.

    AB - I put a question mark after "Thucydides Trap" in the chapter's title to register my skepticism about the supposed similarity between the current China-U.S. face-off and the Athens-Sparta contest preceding the Peloponnesian War. There are, to me, at least three substantive reasons why the two situations are totally incompatible: (a) China is not a first-time upstart, but is on its second rise after a century and a half of decline, during which it learned that the world needed social justice and safeguards against the encroachments by the powerful against the weak, as discussed in Chapter 6. (b) The system of states in which China and the United States find themselves today, wrapped in a relationship that Richard Rosecrance depicts as "vulnerability interdependence," is qualitatively different from the ancient Greek system of states where such interdependence was unknown between Athens and Sparta. (c) China's clout thus far is derived predominantly from its surging economic expansion; but its military might is not up to a level that would instill the sort of "fear" that the rising Athens did in Sparta, as Thucydides observed.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047649295&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85047649295&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1142/9789813231108_0007

    DO - 10.1142/9789813231108_0007

    M3 - Chapter

    T3 - Series on Contemporary China

    SP - 141

    EP - 151

    BT - Series on Contemporary China

    PB - World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte Ltd

    ER -