The speed of the 'bullet' in the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56

Volker Springel, Glennys R. Farrar

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Deep Chandra exposures of the hot galaxy cluster 1E0657-56 have revealed a highly dynamical state of the system due to an ongoing merger with a massive subcluster. The system is observed shortly after the first core-passage of the infalling subcluster, which moves approximately in the plane of the sky and is preceded by a prominent bow shock with Mach number. The inferred shock velocity of ∼4700 km s-1 has been commonly interpreted as the velocity of the 'bullet' subcluster itself in the rest frame of the parent cluster. This velocity is unexpectedly high in the Lambda cold dark matter (ΛCDM) cosmology, which may require non-trivial modifications in the dark sector such as additional long-range scalar forces if taken at face value. Here we present explicit hydrodynamical toy models of galaxy cluster mergers which very well reproduce the observed dynamical state of 1E0657-56 and the mass models inferred from gravitational lensing observations. However, despite a shock speed of 4500 km s-1, the subcluster's mass centroid is moving only with ∼2700 km s-1 in the rest frame of the parent cluster. The difference arises in part due to a gravitationally induced inflow velocity of the gas ahead of the shock towards the bullet, which amounts to ∼1100 km s-1 for our assumed 10:1 mass ratio of the merger. A second effect is that the shock front moves faster than the subcluster itself, enlarging the distance between the subcluster and the bow shock with time. We also discuss the expected location of the lensing mass peak relative to the hydrodynamical features of the flow, and show that their spatial separation depends sensitively on the relative concentrations and gas fractions of the merging clusters, in addition to being highly time dependent. A generic ΛCDM collision model, where a bullet subcluster with concentration c = 7.2 merges with a parent cluster with concentration c = 3 on a zero-energy orbit, reproduces all the main observational features seen in 1E0657-56 with good accuracy, suggesting that 1E0657-56 is well in line with expectations from standard cosmological models. In theories with an additional 'fifth' force in the dark sector, the bullet subcluster can be accelerated beyond the velocity reached in ΛCDM, and the spatial offset between the X-ray peak and the mass centroid of the subcluster can be significantly enlarged. Our results stress the need for explicit hydrodynamical models for the proper interpretation of actively merging systems such as 1E0657-56.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)911-925
    Number of pages15
    JournalMonthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
    Volume380
    Issue number3
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Sep 2007

    Fingerprint

    galaxies
    shock
    merger
    dark matter
    bows
    centroids
    sectors
    cosmology
    gas
    shock fronts
    gases
    inflow
    Mach number
    mass ratios
    collision
    sky
    speed
    scalars
    orbits
    collisions

    Keywords

    • Galaxies: structure
    • Methods: numerical
    • X-rays: galaxies: clusters

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Space and Planetary Science

    Cite this

    The speed of the 'bullet' in the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56. / Springel, Volker; Farrar, Glennys R.

    In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 380, No. 3, 09.2007, p. 911-925.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Springel, Volker ; Farrar, Glennys R. / The speed of the 'bullet' in the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56. In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 2007 ; Vol. 380, No. 3. pp. 911-925.
    @article{4e5c3ad4fe4c451fb8610dd80084412b,
    title = "The speed of the 'bullet' in the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56",
    abstract = "Deep Chandra exposures of the hot galaxy cluster 1E0657-56 have revealed a highly dynamical state of the system due to an ongoing merger with a massive subcluster. The system is observed shortly after the first core-passage of the infalling subcluster, which moves approximately in the plane of the sky and is preceded by a prominent bow shock with Mach number. The inferred shock velocity of ∼4700 km s-1 has been commonly interpreted as the velocity of the 'bullet' subcluster itself in the rest frame of the parent cluster. This velocity is unexpectedly high in the Lambda cold dark matter (ΛCDM) cosmology, which may require non-trivial modifications in the dark sector such as additional long-range scalar forces if taken at face value. Here we present explicit hydrodynamical toy models of galaxy cluster mergers which very well reproduce the observed dynamical state of 1E0657-56 and the mass models inferred from gravitational lensing observations. However, despite a shock speed of 4500 km s-1, the subcluster's mass centroid is moving only with ∼2700 km s-1 in the rest frame of the parent cluster. The difference arises in part due to a gravitationally induced inflow velocity of the gas ahead of the shock towards the bullet, which amounts to ∼1100 km s-1 for our assumed 10:1 mass ratio of the merger. A second effect is that the shock front moves faster than the subcluster itself, enlarging the distance between the subcluster and the bow shock with time. We also discuss the expected location of the lensing mass peak relative to the hydrodynamical features of the flow, and show that their spatial separation depends sensitively on the relative concentrations and gas fractions of the merging clusters, in addition to being highly time dependent. A generic ΛCDM collision model, where a bullet subcluster with concentration c = 7.2 merges with a parent cluster with concentration c = 3 on a zero-energy orbit, reproduces all the main observational features seen in 1E0657-56 with good accuracy, suggesting that 1E0657-56 is well in line with expectations from standard cosmological models. In theories with an additional 'fifth' force in the dark sector, the bullet subcluster can be accelerated beyond the velocity reached in ΛCDM, and the spatial offset between the X-ray peak and the mass centroid of the subcluster can be significantly enlarged. Our results stress the need for explicit hydrodynamical models for the proper interpretation of actively merging systems such as 1E0657-56.",
    keywords = "Galaxies: structure, Methods: numerical, X-rays: galaxies: clusters",
    author = "Volker Springel and Farrar, {Glennys R.}",
    year = "2007",
    month = "9",
    doi = "10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12159.x",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "380",
    pages = "911--925",
    journal = "Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society",
    issn = "0035-8711",
    publisher = "Oxford University Press",
    number = "3",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The speed of the 'bullet' in the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56

    AU - Springel, Volker

    AU - Farrar, Glennys R.

    PY - 2007/9

    Y1 - 2007/9

    N2 - Deep Chandra exposures of the hot galaxy cluster 1E0657-56 have revealed a highly dynamical state of the system due to an ongoing merger with a massive subcluster. The system is observed shortly after the first core-passage of the infalling subcluster, which moves approximately in the plane of the sky and is preceded by a prominent bow shock with Mach number. The inferred shock velocity of ∼4700 km s-1 has been commonly interpreted as the velocity of the 'bullet' subcluster itself in the rest frame of the parent cluster. This velocity is unexpectedly high in the Lambda cold dark matter (ΛCDM) cosmology, which may require non-trivial modifications in the dark sector such as additional long-range scalar forces if taken at face value. Here we present explicit hydrodynamical toy models of galaxy cluster mergers which very well reproduce the observed dynamical state of 1E0657-56 and the mass models inferred from gravitational lensing observations. However, despite a shock speed of 4500 km s-1, the subcluster's mass centroid is moving only with ∼2700 km s-1 in the rest frame of the parent cluster. The difference arises in part due to a gravitationally induced inflow velocity of the gas ahead of the shock towards the bullet, which amounts to ∼1100 km s-1 for our assumed 10:1 mass ratio of the merger. A second effect is that the shock front moves faster than the subcluster itself, enlarging the distance between the subcluster and the bow shock with time. We also discuss the expected location of the lensing mass peak relative to the hydrodynamical features of the flow, and show that their spatial separation depends sensitively on the relative concentrations and gas fractions of the merging clusters, in addition to being highly time dependent. A generic ΛCDM collision model, where a bullet subcluster with concentration c = 7.2 merges with a parent cluster with concentration c = 3 on a zero-energy orbit, reproduces all the main observational features seen in 1E0657-56 with good accuracy, suggesting that 1E0657-56 is well in line with expectations from standard cosmological models. In theories with an additional 'fifth' force in the dark sector, the bullet subcluster can be accelerated beyond the velocity reached in ΛCDM, and the spatial offset between the X-ray peak and the mass centroid of the subcluster can be significantly enlarged. Our results stress the need for explicit hydrodynamical models for the proper interpretation of actively merging systems such as 1E0657-56.

    AB - Deep Chandra exposures of the hot galaxy cluster 1E0657-56 have revealed a highly dynamical state of the system due to an ongoing merger with a massive subcluster. The system is observed shortly after the first core-passage of the infalling subcluster, which moves approximately in the plane of the sky and is preceded by a prominent bow shock with Mach number. The inferred shock velocity of ∼4700 km s-1 has been commonly interpreted as the velocity of the 'bullet' subcluster itself in the rest frame of the parent cluster. This velocity is unexpectedly high in the Lambda cold dark matter (ΛCDM) cosmology, which may require non-trivial modifications in the dark sector such as additional long-range scalar forces if taken at face value. Here we present explicit hydrodynamical toy models of galaxy cluster mergers which very well reproduce the observed dynamical state of 1E0657-56 and the mass models inferred from gravitational lensing observations. However, despite a shock speed of 4500 km s-1, the subcluster's mass centroid is moving only with ∼2700 km s-1 in the rest frame of the parent cluster. The difference arises in part due to a gravitationally induced inflow velocity of the gas ahead of the shock towards the bullet, which amounts to ∼1100 km s-1 for our assumed 10:1 mass ratio of the merger. A second effect is that the shock front moves faster than the subcluster itself, enlarging the distance between the subcluster and the bow shock with time. We also discuss the expected location of the lensing mass peak relative to the hydrodynamical features of the flow, and show that their spatial separation depends sensitively on the relative concentrations and gas fractions of the merging clusters, in addition to being highly time dependent. A generic ΛCDM collision model, where a bullet subcluster with concentration c = 7.2 merges with a parent cluster with concentration c = 3 on a zero-energy orbit, reproduces all the main observational features seen in 1E0657-56 with good accuracy, suggesting that 1E0657-56 is well in line with expectations from standard cosmological models. In theories with an additional 'fifth' force in the dark sector, the bullet subcluster can be accelerated beyond the velocity reached in ΛCDM, and the spatial offset between the X-ray peak and the mass centroid of the subcluster can be significantly enlarged. Our results stress the need for explicit hydrodynamical models for the proper interpretation of actively merging systems such as 1E0657-56.

    KW - Galaxies: structure

    KW - Methods: numerical

    KW - X-rays: galaxies: clusters

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34548619273&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34548619273&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12159.x

    DO - 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12159.x

    M3 - Article

    VL - 380

    SP - 911

    EP - 925

    JO - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

    JF - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

    SN - 0035-8711

    IS - 3

    ER -