The quandaries of consumer-based labor activism: A low-wage case study

Andrew Ross

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    This essay takes anti-sweatshop activism as a case-study of a labor movement that engages consumer politics with mixed results. It reviews the success of the media-honed strategies deployed to raise public concern about substandard workplace conditions in the global garment industry, and summarizes corporate efforts to redeem their tarnished image through the public relations vehicle of 'corporate social responsibility'. The record of attention to labor abuses with the history of the consumer movement confirms the existence of a longstanding dialogue between advocacy organizations oriented to the politics of production and consumption respectively. But there is also a history of missed opportunities on the labor side to question the dominant materialist lifestyle of a consumer civilization. This shortcoming is highlighted by the rise of the anti-consumer movement, which evangelizes sweeping changes in lifestyle, trading, and modes of livelihood, and sees ethical consumption as little more than a way to greenwash the status quo. The essay argues that anti-sweatshop activists (who give short shrift to foundational challenges to the prevailing system) and anti-consumerists (often insensitive to the livelihoods that are tied to servicing the goods economy) would each benefit from integrating more of the others' philosophies and goals. Concerns about the unsustainability of a consumer civilization can and should be addressed at the point of production. On the other side, anti-consumerists ought to consider production workers and labor-based organizations as likely allies rather than as hapless victims of false consciousness.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)770-787
    Number of pages18
    JournalCultural Studies
    Volume22
    Issue number5
    DOIs
    StatePublished - 2008

    Fingerprint

    low wage
    labor
    civilization
    livelihood
    textile industry
    labor movement
    politics
    social responsibility
    history
    allies
    consciousness
    abuse
    workplace
    dialogue
    Wages
    Activism
    Labor
    worker
    economy
    Livelihoods

    Keywords

    • Anti-consumerism
    • Brand-busting
    • Consumer boycotts
    • Labor movement
    • Sweatshops
    • Union organizing

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)
    • Anthropology
    • Social Sciences(all)

    Cite this

    The quandaries of consumer-based labor activism : A low-wage case study. / Ross, Andrew.

    In: Cultural Studies, Vol. 22, No. 5, 2008, p. 770-787.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Ross, Andrew. / The quandaries of consumer-based labor activism : A low-wage case study. In: Cultural Studies. 2008 ; Vol. 22, No. 5. pp. 770-787.
    @article{7ce346a98d684f3483abc908dda70865,
    title = "The quandaries of consumer-based labor activism: A low-wage case study",
    abstract = "This essay takes anti-sweatshop activism as a case-study of a labor movement that engages consumer politics with mixed results. It reviews the success of the media-honed strategies deployed to raise public concern about substandard workplace conditions in the global garment industry, and summarizes corporate efforts to redeem their tarnished image through the public relations vehicle of 'corporate social responsibility'. The record of attention to labor abuses with the history of the consumer movement confirms the existence of a longstanding dialogue between advocacy organizations oriented to the politics of production and consumption respectively. But there is also a history of missed opportunities on the labor side to question the dominant materialist lifestyle of a consumer civilization. This shortcoming is highlighted by the rise of the anti-consumer movement, which evangelizes sweeping changes in lifestyle, trading, and modes of livelihood, and sees ethical consumption as little more than a way to greenwash the status quo. The essay argues that anti-sweatshop activists (who give short shrift to foundational challenges to the prevailing system) and anti-consumerists (often insensitive to the livelihoods that are tied to servicing the goods economy) would each benefit from integrating more of the others' philosophies and goals. Concerns about the unsustainability of a consumer civilization can and should be addressed at the point of production. On the other side, anti-consumerists ought to consider production workers and labor-based organizations as likely allies rather than as hapless victims of false consciousness.",
    keywords = "Anti-consumerism, Brand-busting, Consumer boycotts, Labor movement, Sweatshops, Union organizing",
    author = "Andrew Ross",
    year = "2008",
    doi = "10.1080/09502380802246017",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "22",
    pages = "770--787",
    journal = "Cultural Studies",
    issn = "0950-2386",
    publisher = "Routledge",
    number = "5",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The quandaries of consumer-based labor activism

    T2 - A low-wage case study

    AU - Ross, Andrew

    PY - 2008

    Y1 - 2008

    N2 - This essay takes anti-sweatshop activism as a case-study of a labor movement that engages consumer politics with mixed results. It reviews the success of the media-honed strategies deployed to raise public concern about substandard workplace conditions in the global garment industry, and summarizes corporate efforts to redeem their tarnished image through the public relations vehicle of 'corporate social responsibility'. The record of attention to labor abuses with the history of the consumer movement confirms the existence of a longstanding dialogue between advocacy organizations oriented to the politics of production and consumption respectively. But there is also a history of missed opportunities on the labor side to question the dominant materialist lifestyle of a consumer civilization. This shortcoming is highlighted by the rise of the anti-consumer movement, which evangelizes sweeping changes in lifestyle, trading, and modes of livelihood, and sees ethical consumption as little more than a way to greenwash the status quo. The essay argues that anti-sweatshop activists (who give short shrift to foundational challenges to the prevailing system) and anti-consumerists (often insensitive to the livelihoods that are tied to servicing the goods economy) would each benefit from integrating more of the others' philosophies and goals. Concerns about the unsustainability of a consumer civilization can and should be addressed at the point of production. On the other side, anti-consumerists ought to consider production workers and labor-based organizations as likely allies rather than as hapless victims of false consciousness.

    AB - This essay takes anti-sweatshop activism as a case-study of a labor movement that engages consumer politics with mixed results. It reviews the success of the media-honed strategies deployed to raise public concern about substandard workplace conditions in the global garment industry, and summarizes corporate efforts to redeem their tarnished image through the public relations vehicle of 'corporate social responsibility'. The record of attention to labor abuses with the history of the consumer movement confirms the existence of a longstanding dialogue between advocacy organizations oriented to the politics of production and consumption respectively. But there is also a history of missed opportunities on the labor side to question the dominant materialist lifestyle of a consumer civilization. This shortcoming is highlighted by the rise of the anti-consumer movement, which evangelizes sweeping changes in lifestyle, trading, and modes of livelihood, and sees ethical consumption as little more than a way to greenwash the status quo. The essay argues that anti-sweatshop activists (who give short shrift to foundational challenges to the prevailing system) and anti-consumerists (often insensitive to the livelihoods that are tied to servicing the goods economy) would each benefit from integrating more of the others' philosophies and goals. Concerns about the unsustainability of a consumer civilization can and should be addressed at the point of production. On the other side, anti-consumerists ought to consider production workers and labor-based organizations as likely allies rather than as hapless victims of false consciousness.

    KW - Anti-consumerism

    KW - Brand-busting

    KW - Consumer boycotts

    KW - Labor movement

    KW - Sweatshops

    KW - Union organizing

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=50449108868&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=50449108868&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/09502380802246017

    DO - 10.1080/09502380802246017

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:50449108868

    VL - 22

    SP - 770

    EP - 787

    JO - Cultural Studies

    JF - Cultural Studies

    SN - 0950-2386

    IS - 5

    ER -