The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations

R. Samadi, H. G. Ludwig, K. Belkacem, M. J. Goupil, Othman Benomar, B. Mosser, M. A. Dupret, F. Baudin, T. Appourchaux, E. Michel

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Context: The seismic data obtained by CoRoT for the star HD 49933 enable us for the first time to measure directly the amplitudes and linewidths of solar-like oscillations for a star other than the Sun. From those measurements it is possible, as was done for the Sun, to constrain models of the excitation of acoustic modes by turbulent convection. Aims: We compare a stochastic excitation model described in Paper I with the asteroseismology data for HD 49933, a star that is rather metal poor and significantly hotter than the Sun. Methods: Using the seismic determinations of the mode linewidths detected by CoRoT for HD 49933 and the theoretical mode excitation rates computed in Paper I for the specific case of HD 49933, we derive the expected surface velocity amplitudes of the acoustic modes detected in HD 49933. Using a calibrated quasi-adiabatic approximation relating the mode amplitudes in intensity to those in velocity, we derive the expected values of the mode amplitude in intensity. Results: Except at rather high frequency, our amplitude calculations are within 1-σ error bars of the mode surface velocity spectrum derived with the HARPS spectrograph. The same is found with respect to the mode amplitudes in intensity derived for HD 49933 from the CoRoT data. On the other hand, at high frequency (? ≳ 1.9 mHz), our calculations depart significantly from the CoRoT and HARPS measurements. We show that assuming a solar metal abundance rather than the actual metal abundance of the star would result in a larger discrepancy with the seismic data. Furthermore, we present calculations which assume the "new" solar chemical mixture to be in better agreement with the seismic data than those that assumed the "old" solar chemical mixture. Conclusions. These results validate in the case of a star significantly hotter than the Sun and α Cen A the main assumptions in the model of stochastic excitation. However, the discrepancies seen at high frequency highlight some deficiencies of the modelling, whose origin remains to be understood.We also show that it is important to take the surface metal abundance of the solar-like pulsators into account.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Article numberA15
    JournalAstronomy and Astrophysics
    Volume509
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Jan 1 2010

    Fingerprint

    seismic data
    sun
    metal
    stars
    acoustics
    excitation
    metals
    solar oscillations
    asteroseismology
    hot stars
    comparison
    convection
    oscillation
    metal surfaces
    spectrographs
    modeling
    calculation
    approximation
    chemical
    rate

    Keywords

    • Convection - Turbulence - Stars
    • HD 49933
    • Helioseismology - Stars
    • Individual
    • Oscillations - Sun

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Astronomy and Astrophysics
    • Space and Planetary Science

    Cite this

    Samadi, R., Ludwig, H. G., Belkacem, K., Goupil, M. J., Benomar, O., Mosser, B., ... Michel, E. (2010). The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 509(1), [A15]. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200911868

    The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations. / Samadi, R.; Ludwig, H. G.; Belkacem, K.; Goupil, M. J.; Benomar, Othman; Mosser, B.; Dupret, M. A.; Baudin, F.; Appourchaux, T.; Michel, E.

    In: Astronomy and Astrophysics, Vol. 509, No. 1, A15, 01.01.2010.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Samadi, R, Ludwig, HG, Belkacem, K, Goupil, MJ, Benomar, O, Mosser, B, Dupret, MA, Baudin, F, Appourchaux, T & Michel, E 2010, 'The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations', Astronomy and Astrophysics, vol. 509, no. 1, A15. https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200911868
    Samadi, R. ; Ludwig, H. G. ; Belkacem, K. ; Goupil, M. J. ; Benomar, Othman ; Mosser, B. ; Dupret, M. A. ; Baudin, F. ; Appourchaux, T. ; Michel, E. / The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations. In: Astronomy and Astrophysics. 2010 ; Vol. 509, No. 1.
    @article{86a8663993744919951e6897fd3b5a80,
    title = "The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations",
    abstract = "Context: The seismic data obtained by CoRoT for the star HD 49933 enable us for the first time to measure directly the amplitudes and linewidths of solar-like oscillations for a star other than the Sun. From those measurements it is possible, as was done for the Sun, to constrain models of the excitation of acoustic modes by turbulent convection. Aims: We compare a stochastic excitation model described in Paper I with the asteroseismology data for HD 49933, a star that is rather metal poor and significantly hotter than the Sun. Methods: Using the seismic determinations of the mode linewidths detected by CoRoT for HD 49933 and the theoretical mode excitation rates computed in Paper I for the specific case of HD 49933, we derive the expected surface velocity amplitudes of the acoustic modes detected in HD 49933. Using a calibrated quasi-adiabatic approximation relating the mode amplitudes in intensity to those in velocity, we derive the expected values of the mode amplitude in intensity. Results: Except at rather high frequency, our amplitude calculations are within 1-σ error bars of the mode surface velocity spectrum derived with the HARPS spectrograph. The same is found with respect to the mode amplitudes in intensity derived for HD 49933 from the CoRoT data. On the other hand, at high frequency (? ≳ 1.9 mHz), our calculations depart significantly from the CoRoT and HARPS measurements. We show that assuming a solar metal abundance rather than the actual metal abundance of the star would result in a larger discrepancy with the seismic data. Furthermore, we present calculations which assume the {"}new{"} solar chemical mixture to be in better agreement with the seismic data than those that assumed the {"}old{"} solar chemical mixture. Conclusions. These results validate in the case of a star significantly hotter than the Sun and α Cen A the main assumptions in the model of stochastic excitation. However, the discrepancies seen at high frequency highlight some deficiencies of the modelling, whose origin remains to be understood.We also show that it is important to take the surface metal abundance of the solar-like pulsators into account.",
    keywords = "Convection - Turbulence - Stars, HD 49933, Helioseismology - Stars, Individual, Oscillations - Sun",
    author = "R. Samadi and Ludwig, {H. G.} and K. Belkacem and Goupil, {M. J.} and Othman Benomar and B. Mosser and Dupret, {M. A.} and F. Baudin and T. Appourchaux and E. Michel",
    year = "2010",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1051/0004-6361/200911868",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "509",
    journal = "Astronomy and Astrophysics",
    issn = "0004-6361",
    publisher = "EDP Sciences",
    number = "1",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The CoRoT target HD 49933 II. Comparison of theoretical mode amplitudes with observations

    AU - Samadi, R.

    AU - Ludwig, H. G.

    AU - Belkacem, K.

    AU - Goupil, M. J.

    AU - Benomar, Othman

    AU - Mosser, B.

    AU - Dupret, M. A.

    AU - Baudin, F.

    AU - Appourchaux, T.

    AU - Michel, E.

    PY - 2010/1/1

    Y1 - 2010/1/1

    N2 - Context: The seismic data obtained by CoRoT for the star HD 49933 enable us for the first time to measure directly the amplitudes and linewidths of solar-like oscillations for a star other than the Sun. From those measurements it is possible, as was done for the Sun, to constrain models of the excitation of acoustic modes by turbulent convection. Aims: We compare a stochastic excitation model described in Paper I with the asteroseismology data for HD 49933, a star that is rather metal poor and significantly hotter than the Sun. Methods: Using the seismic determinations of the mode linewidths detected by CoRoT for HD 49933 and the theoretical mode excitation rates computed in Paper I for the specific case of HD 49933, we derive the expected surface velocity amplitudes of the acoustic modes detected in HD 49933. Using a calibrated quasi-adiabatic approximation relating the mode amplitudes in intensity to those in velocity, we derive the expected values of the mode amplitude in intensity. Results: Except at rather high frequency, our amplitude calculations are within 1-σ error bars of the mode surface velocity spectrum derived with the HARPS spectrograph. The same is found with respect to the mode amplitudes in intensity derived for HD 49933 from the CoRoT data. On the other hand, at high frequency (? ≳ 1.9 mHz), our calculations depart significantly from the CoRoT and HARPS measurements. We show that assuming a solar metal abundance rather than the actual metal abundance of the star would result in a larger discrepancy with the seismic data. Furthermore, we present calculations which assume the "new" solar chemical mixture to be in better agreement with the seismic data than those that assumed the "old" solar chemical mixture. Conclusions. These results validate in the case of a star significantly hotter than the Sun and α Cen A the main assumptions in the model of stochastic excitation. However, the discrepancies seen at high frequency highlight some deficiencies of the modelling, whose origin remains to be understood.We also show that it is important to take the surface metal abundance of the solar-like pulsators into account.

    AB - Context: The seismic data obtained by CoRoT for the star HD 49933 enable us for the first time to measure directly the amplitudes and linewidths of solar-like oscillations for a star other than the Sun. From those measurements it is possible, as was done for the Sun, to constrain models of the excitation of acoustic modes by turbulent convection. Aims: We compare a stochastic excitation model described in Paper I with the asteroseismology data for HD 49933, a star that is rather metal poor and significantly hotter than the Sun. Methods: Using the seismic determinations of the mode linewidths detected by CoRoT for HD 49933 and the theoretical mode excitation rates computed in Paper I for the specific case of HD 49933, we derive the expected surface velocity amplitudes of the acoustic modes detected in HD 49933. Using a calibrated quasi-adiabatic approximation relating the mode amplitudes in intensity to those in velocity, we derive the expected values of the mode amplitude in intensity. Results: Except at rather high frequency, our amplitude calculations are within 1-σ error bars of the mode surface velocity spectrum derived with the HARPS spectrograph. The same is found with respect to the mode amplitudes in intensity derived for HD 49933 from the CoRoT data. On the other hand, at high frequency (? ≳ 1.9 mHz), our calculations depart significantly from the CoRoT and HARPS measurements. We show that assuming a solar metal abundance rather than the actual metal abundance of the star would result in a larger discrepancy with the seismic data. Furthermore, we present calculations which assume the "new" solar chemical mixture to be in better agreement with the seismic data than those that assumed the "old" solar chemical mixture. Conclusions. These results validate in the case of a star significantly hotter than the Sun and α Cen A the main assumptions in the model of stochastic excitation. However, the discrepancies seen at high frequency highlight some deficiencies of the modelling, whose origin remains to be understood.We also show that it is important to take the surface metal abundance of the solar-like pulsators into account.

    KW - Convection - Turbulence - Stars

    KW - HD 49933

    KW - Helioseismology - Stars

    KW - Individual

    KW - Oscillations - Sun

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=76349094474&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=76349094474&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1051/0004-6361/200911868

    DO - 10.1051/0004-6361/200911868

    M3 - Article

    VL - 509

    JO - Astronomy and Astrophysics

    JF - Astronomy and Astrophysics

    SN - 0004-6361

    IS - 1

    M1 - A15

    ER -