Surveillance for World Trade Center disaster health effects among survivors of collapsed and damaged buildings.

Robert M. Brackbill, Lorna Thorpe, Laura DiGrande, Megan Perrin, James H. Sapp, David Wu, Sharon Campolucci, Deborah J. Walker, Jim Cone, Paul Pulliam, Lisa Thalji, Mark R. Farfel, Pauline Thomas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

PROBLEM/CONDITION: Survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings from the attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) were among those most exposed to injury hazards, air pollution, and traumatic events. REPORTING PERIOD: This report summarizes data from health outcomes collected during interviews conducted from September 5, 2003, to the close of the World Trade Center Health Registry (WTCHR) enrollment on November 20, 2004. DESCRIPTION OF SYSTEM: WTCHR will be used to monitor periodically the mental and physical health of 71,437 enrollees for 20 years. The analysis is limited to 8,418 adult survivors of collapsed buildings (n = 5,095) and buildings with major or moderate damage (n = 3,323), excluding those who were involved in rescue and recovery. RESULTS: A total of 62.4% of survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings were caught in the dust and debris cloud that resulted from the collapse of the WTC towers, and 63.8% experienced three or more potentially psychologically traumatizing events. Injuries were common (43.6%), but few survivors reported injuries that would have required extensive treatment. More than half (56.6%) of survivors reported experiencing new or worsening respiratory symptoms after the attacks, 23.9% had heartburn/reflux, and 21.0% had severe headaches. At the time of the interview, 10.7% of building survivors screened positive for serious psychological distress (SPD) using the K6 instrument. After multiple adjustments, data indicated that survivors caught in the dust and debris cloud were more likely to report any injuries (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 3.9; p< or =0.05); any respiratory symptom (AOR = 2.7; p< or =0.05); severe headaches (AOR = 2.0; p< or =0.05); skin rash/irritation (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); hearing problems or loss (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); heartburn (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); diagnosed stroke (AOR = 5.6; p< or =0.05); self-reported depression, anxiety, or other emotional problem (AOR = 1.4; p< or =0.05); and current SPD (AOR = 2.2; p< or =0.05). Adjustment for SPD did not diminish the observed associations between dust cloud exposure and physical health outcomes. Building type and time of evacuation were associated with injuries on September 11, 2001 and reported symptoms; building type (collapsed versus damaged) also was associated with mental distress. INTERPRETATION: Two to three years after September 11, survivors of buildings that collapsed or that were damaged as a result of the WTC attack reported substantial physical and mental health problems. The long-term ramifications of these effects are unknown. Many survivors were caught directly in the dust and debris of collapsing towers, a dense cloud of particulate matter that might have produced or exacerbated these health effects. PUBLIC HEALTH ACTION RECOMMENDED: Long-term follow-up of building survivors and all other persons enrolled in WTCHR should be maintained, with particular attention to those persons exposed to the dust cloud. Some of these findings might lead to building designs that can minimize injury hazards.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-18
Number of pages18
JournalMMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC
Volume55
Issue number2
StatePublished - 2006

Fingerprint

Disasters
world trade
surveillance
disaster
building
Survivors
Odds Ratio
Dust
Health
health
Wounds and Injuries
Registries
Heartburn
Headache
Mental Health
human being
event
September 11, 2001
Interviews
Psychology

Cite this

Surveillance for World Trade Center disaster health effects among survivors of collapsed and damaged buildings. / Brackbill, Robert M.; Thorpe, Lorna; DiGrande, Laura; Perrin, Megan; Sapp, James H.; Wu, David; Campolucci, Sharon; Walker, Deborah J.; Cone, Jim; Pulliam, Paul; Thalji, Lisa; Farfel, Mark R.; Thomas, Pauline.

In: MMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC, Vol. 55, No. 2, 2006, p. 1-18.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Brackbill, RM, Thorpe, L, DiGrande, L, Perrin, M, Sapp, JH, Wu, D, Campolucci, S, Walker, DJ, Cone, J, Pulliam, P, Thalji, L, Farfel, MR & Thomas, P 2006, 'Surveillance for World Trade Center disaster health effects among survivors of collapsed and damaged buildings.', MMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC, vol. 55, no. 2, pp. 1-18.
Brackbill, Robert M. ; Thorpe, Lorna ; DiGrande, Laura ; Perrin, Megan ; Sapp, James H. ; Wu, David ; Campolucci, Sharon ; Walker, Deborah J. ; Cone, Jim ; Pulliam, Paul ; Thalji, Lisa ; Farfel, Mark R. ; Thomas, Pauline. / Surveillance for World Trade Center disaster health effects among survivors of collapsed and damaged buildings. In: MMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC. 2006 ; Vol. 55, No. 2. pp. 1-18.
@article{9d352e22223b42f1a466132ec9f2de86,
title = "Surveillance for World Trade Center disaster health effects among survivors of collapsed and damaged buildings.",
abstract = "PROBLEM/CONDITION: Survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings from the attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) were among those most exposed to injury hazards, air pollution, and traumatic events. REPORTING PERIOD: This report summarizes data from health outcomes collected during interviews conducted from September 5, 2003, to the close of the World Trade Center Health Registry (WTCHR) enrollment on November 20, 2004. DESCRIPTION OF SYSTEM: WTCHR will be used to monitor periodically the mental and physical health of 71,437 enrollees for 20 years. The analysis is limited to 8,418 adult survivors of collapsed buildings (n = 5,095) and buildings with major or moderate damage (n = 3,323), excluding those who were involved in rescue and recovery. RESULTS: A total of 62.4{\%} of survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings were caught in the dust and debris cloud that resulted from the collapse of the WTC towers, and 63.8{\%} experienced three or more potentially psychologically traumatizing events. Injuries were common (43.6{\%}), but few survivors reported injuries that would have required extensive treatment. More than half (56.6{\%}) of survivors reported experiencing new or worsening respiratory symptoms after the attacks, 23.9{\%} had heartburn/reflux, and 21.0{\%} had severe headaches. At the time of the interview, 10.7{\%} of building survivors screened positive for serious psychological distress (SPD) using the K6 instrument. After multiple adjustments, data indicated that survivors caught in the dust and debris cloud were more likely to report any injuries (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 3.9; p< or =0.05); any respiratory symptom (AOR = 2.7; p< or =0.05); severe headaches (AOR = 2.0; p< or =0.05); skin rash/irritation (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); hearing problems or loss (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); heartburn (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); diagnosed stroke (AOR = 5.6; p< or =0.05); self-reported depression, anxiety, or other emotional problem (AOR = 1.4; p< or =0.05); and current SPD (AOR = 2.2; p< or =0.05). Adjustment for SPD did not diminish the observed associations between dust cloud exposure and physical health outcomes. Building type and time of evacuation were associated with injuries on September 11, 2001 and reported symptoms; building type (collapsed versus damaged) also was associated with mental distress. INTERPRETATION: Two to three years after September 11, survivors of buildings that collapsed or that were damaged as a result of the WTC attack reported substantial physical and mental health problems. The long-term ramifications of these effects are unknown. Many survivors were caught directly in the dust and debris of collapsing towers, a dense cloud of particulate matter that might have produced or exacerbated these health effects. PUBLIC HEALTH ACTION RECOMMENDED: Long-term follow-up of building survivors and all other persons enrolled in WTCHR should be maintained, with particular attention to those persons exposed to the dust cloud. Some of these findings might lead to building designs that can minimize injury hazards.",
author = "Brackbill, {Robert M.} and Lorna Thorpe and Laura DiGrande and Megan Perrin and Sapp, {James H.} and David Wu and Sharon Campolucci and Walker, {Deborah J.} and Jim Cone and Paul Pulliam and Lisa Thalji and Farfel, {Mark R.} and Pauline Thomas",
year = "2006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "55",
pages = "1--18",
journal = "MMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC",
issn = "1546-0738",
publisher = "Epidemiology Program Office",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Surveillance for World Trade Center disaster health effects among survivors of collapsed and damaged buildings.

AU - Brackbill, Robert M.

AU - Thorpe, Lorna

AU - DiGrande, Laura

AU - Perrin, Megan

AU - Sapp, James H.

AU - Wu, David

AU - Campolucci, Sharon

AU - Walker, Deborah J.

AU - Cone, Jim

AU - Pulliam, Paul

AU - Thalji, Lisa

AU - Farfel, Mark R.

AU - Thomas, Pauline

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - PROBLEM/CONDITION: Survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings from the attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) were among those most exposed to injury hazards, air pollution, and traumatic events. REPORTING PERIOD: This report summarizes data from health outcomes collected during interviews conducted from September 5, 2003, to the close of the World Trade Center Health Registry (WTCHR) enrollment on November 20, 2004. DESCRIPTION OF SYSTEM: WTCHR will be used to monitor periodically the mental and physical health of 71,437 enrollees for 20 years. The analysis is limited to 8,418 adult survivors of collapsed buildings (n = 5,095) and buildings with major or moderate damage (n = 3,323), excluding those who were involved in rescue and recovery. RESULTS: A total of 62.4% of survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings were caught in the dust and debris cloud that resulted from the collapse of the WTC towers, and 63.8% experienced three or more potentially psychologically traumatizing events. Injuries were common (43.6%), but few survivors reported injuries that would have required extensive treatment. More than half (56.6%) of survivors reported experiencing new or worsening respiratory symptoms after the attacks, 23.9% had heartburn/reflux, and 21.0% had severe headaches. At the time of the interview, 10.7% of building survivors screened positive for serious psychological distress (SPD) using the K6 instrument. After multiple adjustments, data indicated that survivors caught in the dust and debris cloud were more likely to report any injuries (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 3.9; p< or =0.05); any respiratory symptom (AOR = 2.7; p< or =0.05); severe headaches (AOR = 2.0; p< or =0.05); skin rash/irritation (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); hearing problems or loss (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); heartburn (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); diagnosed stroke (AOR = 5.6; p< or =0.05); self-reported depression, anxiety, or other emotional problem (AOR = 1.4; p< or =0.05); and current SPD (AOR = 2.2; p< or =0.05). Adjustment for SPD did not diminish the observed associations between dust cloud exposure and physical health outcomes. Building type and time of evacuation were associated with injuries on September 11, 2001 and reported symptoms; building type (collapsed versus damaged) also was associated with mental distress. INTERPRETATION: Two to three years after September 11, survivors of buildings that collapsed or that were damaged as a result of the WTC attack reported substantial physical and mental health problems. The long-term ramifications of these effects are unknown. Many survivors were caught directly in the dust and debris of collapsing towers, a dense cloud of particulate matter that might have produced or exacerbated these health effects. PUBLIC HEALTH ACTION RECOMMENDED: Long-term follow-up of building survivors and all other persons enrolled in WTCHR should be maintained, with particular attention to those persons exposed to the dust cloud. Some of these findings might lead to building designs that can minimize injury hazards.

AB - PROBLEM/CONDITION: Survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings from the attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) were among those most exposed to injury hazards, air pollution, and traumatic events. REPORTING PERIOD: This report summarizes data from health outcomes collected during interviews conducted from September 5, 2003, to the close of the World Trade Center Health Registry (WTCHR) enrollment on November 20, 2004. DESCRIPTION OF SYSTEM: WTCHR will be used to monitor periodically the mental and physical health of 71,437 enrollees for 20 years. The analysis is limited to 8,418 adult survivors of collapsed buildings (n = 5,095) and buildings with major or moderate damage (n = 3,323), excluding those who were involved in rescue and recovery. RESULTS: A total of 62.4% of survivors of collapsed or damaged buildings were caught in the dust and debris cloud that resulted from the collapse of the WTC towers, and 63.8% experienced three or more potentially psychologically traumatizing events. Injuries were common (43.6%), but few survivors reported injuries that would have required extensive treatment. More than half (56.6%) of survivors reported experiencing new or worsening respiratory symptoms after the attacks, 23.9% had heartburn/reflux, and 21.0% had severe headaches. At the time of the interview, 10.7% of building survivors screened positive for serious psychological distress (SPD) using the K6 instrument. After multiple adjustments, data indicated that survivors caught in the dust and debris cloud were more likely to report any injuries (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 3.9; p< or =0.05); any respiratory symptom (AOR = 2.7; p< or =0.05); severe headaches (AOR = 2.0; p< or =0.05); skin rash/irritation (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); hearing problems or loss (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); heartburn (AOR = 1.7; p< or =0.05); diagnosed stroke (AOR = 5.6; p< or =0.05); self-reported depression, anxiety, or other emotional problem (AOR = 1.4; p< or =0.05); and current SPD (AOR = 2.2; p< or =0.05). Adjustment for SPD did not diminish the observed associations between dust cloud exposure and physical health outcomes. Building type and time of evacuation were associated with injuries on September 11, 2001 and reported symptoms; building type (collapsed versus damaged) also was associated with mental distress. INTERPRETATION: Two to three years after September 11, survivors of buildings that collapsed or that were damaged as a result of the WTC attack reported substantial physical and mental health problems. The long-term ramifications of these effects are unknown. Many survivors were caught directly in the dust and debris of collapsing towers, a dense cloud of particulate matter that might have produced or exacerbated these health effects. PUBLIC HEALTH ACTION RECOMMENDED: Long-term follow-up of building survivors and all other persons enrolled in WTCHR should be maintained, with particular attention to those persons exposed to the dust cloud. Some of these findings might lead to building designs that can minimize injury hazards.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33645526530&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33645526530&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 55

SP - 1

EP - 18

JO - MMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC

JF - MMWR. Surveillance summaries : Morbidity and mortality weekly report. Surveillance summaries / CDC

SN - 1546-0738

IS - 2

ER -