Student thinking with examples: The criteria-affordances-purposes-strategies framework

Amy B. Ellis, Zekiye Ozgur, Rebecca Vinsonhaler, Muhammed Fatih Dogan, Tracy Carolan, Elise Lockwood, Alison Lynch, Pooneh Sabouri, Eric Knuth, Orit Zaslavsky

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

A persistent challenge in supporting students' proof activity is fostering the transition from less formal, empirical arguments to formal deductive arguments. A number of researchers have begun to investigate students' thinking with examples, addressing how example use can support conjecture understanding, exploration, and proof. We extend this line of work in presenting the CAPS (Criteria, Affordances, Purposes, and Strategies) Framework, a framework addressing students' choices, uses, strategies, and affordances gained with examples. Based on individual interviews with 38 participants from middle school through the undergraduate level, the CAPS Framework simultaneously addresses multiple aspects of students' example-based exploration and provides a way to analyze how these different aspects mutually inform one another as students conjecture and prove. We present the framework, exemplify its use through vignettes of student thinking, and share findings on how students' thinking with examples shifts across the populations of middle school, high school, and undergraduate students.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalJournal of Mathematical Behavior
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - 2017

Fingerprint

Affordances
Students
student
Foster Home Care
Strategy
Framework
Line
Research Personnel
Interviews
interview

Keywords

  • Conjecturing and proving
  • Example use
  • Student reasoning

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Applied Psychology
  • Applied Mathematics

Cite this

Student thinking with examples : The criteria-affordances-purposes-strategies framework. / Ellis, Amy B.; Ozgur, Zekiye; Vinsonhaler, Rebecca; Dogan, Muhammed Fatih; Carolan, Tracy; Lockwood, Elise; Lynch, Alison; Sabouri, Pooneh; Knuth, Eric; Zaslavsky, Orit.

In: Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ellis, Amy B. ; Ozgur, Zekiye ; Vinsonhaler, Rebecca ; Dogan, Muhammed Fatih ; Carolan, Tracy ; Lockwood, Elise ; Lynch, Alison ; Sabouri, Pooneh ; Knuth, Eric ; Zaslavsky, Orit. / Student thinking with examples : The criteria-affordances-purposes-strategies framework. In: Journal of Mathematical Behavior. 2017.
@article{a3b97ce6fcaa423a89dbd28a580fc386,
title = "Student thinking with examples: The criteria-affordances-purposes-strategies framework",
abstract = "A persistent challenge in supporting students' proof activity is fostering the transition from less formal, empirical arguments to formal deductive arguments. A number of researchers have begun to investigate students' thinking with examples, addressing how example use can support conjecture understanding, exploration, and proof. We extend this line of work in presenting the CAPS (Criteria, Affordances, Purposes, and Strategies) Framework, a framework addressing students' choices, uses, strategies, and affordances gained with examples. Based on individual interviews with 38 participants from middle school through the undergraduate level, the CAPS Framework simultaneously addresses multiple aspects of students' example-based exploration and provides a way to analyze how these different aspects mutually inform one another as students conjecture and prove. We present the framework, exemplify its use through vignettes of student thinking, and share findings on how students' thinking with examples shifts across the populations of middle school, high school, and undergraduate students.",
keywords = "Conjecturing and proving, Example use, Student reasoning",
author = "Ellis, {Amy B.} and Zekiye Ozgur and Rebecca Vinsonhaler and Dogan, {Muhammed Fatih} and Tracy Carolan and Elise Lockwood and Alison Lynch and Pooneh Sabouri and Eric Knuth and Orit Zaslavsky",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.1016/j.jmathb.2017.06.003",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Journal of Mathematical Behavior",
issn = "0732-3123",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Student thinking with examples

T2 - The criteria-affordances-purposes-strategies framework

AU - Ellis, Amy B.

AU - Ozgur, Zekiye

AU - Vinsonhaler, Rebecca

AU - Dogan, Muhammed Fatih

AU - Carolan, Tracy

AU - Lockwood, Elise

AU - Lynch, Alison

AU - Sabouri, Pooneh

AU - Knuth, Eric

AU - Zaslavsky, Orit

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - A persistent challenge in supporting students' proof activity is fostering the transition from less formal, empirical arguments to formal deductive arguments. A number of researchers have begun to investigate students' thinking with examples, addressing how example use can support conjecture understanding, exploration, and proof. We extend this line of work in presenting the CAPS (Criteria, Affordances, Purposes, and Strategies) Framework, a framework addressing students' choices, uses, strategies, and affordances gained with examples. Based on individual interviews with 38 participants from middle school through the undergraduate level, the CAPS Framework simultaneously addresses multiple aspects of students' example-based exploration and provides a way to analyze how these different aspects mutually inform one another as students conjecture and prove. We present the framework, exemplify its use through vignettes of student thinking, and share findings on how students' thinking with examples shifts across the populations of middle school, high school, and undergraduate students.

AB - A persistent challenge in supporting students' proof activity is fostering the transition from less formal, empirical arguments to formal deductive arguments. A number of researchers have begun to investigate students' thinking with examples, addressing how example use can support conjecture understanding, exploration, and proof. We extend this line of work in presenting the CAPS (Criteria, Affordances, Purposes, and Strategies) Framework, a framework addressing students' choices, uses, strategies, and affordances gained with examples. Based on individual interviews with 38 participants from middle school through the undergraduate level, the CAPS Framework simultaneously addresses multiple aspects of students' example-based exploration and provides a way to analyze how these different aspects mutually inform one another as students conjecture and prove. We present the framework, exemplify its use through vignettes of student thinking, and share findings on how students' thinking with examples shifts across the populations of middle school, high school, and undergraduate students.

KW - Conjecturing and proving

KW - Example use

KW - Student reasoning

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85028588941&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85028588941&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jmathb.2017.06.003

DO - 10.1016/j.jmathb.2017.06.003

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85028588941

JO - Journal of Mathematical Behavior

JF - Journal of Mathematical Behavior

SN - 0732-3123

ER -