Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents

Catherine A. Belitsky, Brenda B. Toner, Alisha Ali, Betty Yu, Susan L. Osborne, Elizabeth DeRooy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective: To measure sex-role beliefs of psychiatry residents and to examine bias in clinical appraisal. Method: Residents (45 female, 51 male) evaluated 1 of 4 possible clinical case histories -a female or male patient with histrionic personality disorder (HPD) or antisocial personality disorder (APD) - and completed the Sex-Role Egalitarianism Scale (SRES). Results: As predicted, female residents were more egalitarian than male residents (P < 0.03) according to the SRES. As expected, significantly more male than female patients received the diagnosis of APD (P < 0.00002). Although it was predicted that female patients would more often be given the HPD diagnosis than males, no significant gender differences were found. Sex of resident was not found to influence clinical behaviour significantly. Conclusions: These results highlight differential sex-role attitudes, as measured by the SRES, between female and male residents and suggest that residents' sex-role biases affect the diagnosis of APD. These results have implications for psychiatric assessment and treatment. Further understanding of these issues is critical to the development of educational tools to address sex biases in psychiatry.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)503-508
Number of pages6
JournalCanadian Journal of Psychiatry
Volume41
Issue number8
StatePublished - Oct 1996

Fingerprint

Psychiatry
Antisocial Personality Disorder
Histrionic Personality Disorder
Sexism

Keywords

  • diagnosis
  • gender
  • personality disorders
  • resident education
  • sex bias
  • women's mental health

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

Belitsky, C. A., Toner, B. B., Ali, A., Yu, B., Osborne, S. L., & DeRooy, E. (1996). Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 41(8), 503-508.

Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents. / Belitsky, Catherine A.; Toner, Brenda B.; Ali, Alisha; Yu, Betty; Osborne, Susan L.; DeRooy, Elizabeth.

In: Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, Vol. 41, No. 8, 10.1996, p. 503-508.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Belitsky, CA, Toner, BB, Ali, A, Yu, B, Osborne, SL & DeRooy, E 1996, 'Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents', Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, vol. 41, no. 8, pp. 503-508.
Belitsky CA, Toner BB, Ali A, Yu B, Osborne SL, DeRooy E. Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry. 1996 Oct;41(8):503-508.
Belitsky, Catherine A. ; Toner, Brenda B. ; Ali, Alisha ; Yu, Betty ; Osborne, Susan L. ; DeRooy, Elizabeth. / Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents. In: Canadian Journal of Psychiatry. 1996 ; Vol. 41, No. 8. pp. 503-508.
@article{d6bc2fde74944506a43f58a62388063f,
title = "Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents",
abstract = "Objective: To measure sex-role beliefs of psychiatry residents and to examine bias in clinical appraisal. Method: Residents (45 female, 51 male) evaluated 1 of 4 possible clinical case histories -a female or male patient with histrionic personality disorder (HPD) or antisocial personality disorder (APD) - and completed the Sex-Role Egalitarianism Scale (SRES). Results: As predicted, female residents were more egalitarian than male residents (P < 0.03) according to the SRES. As expected, significantly more male than female patients received the diagnosis of APD (P < 0.00002). Although it was predicted that female patients would more often be given the HPD diagnosis than males, no significant gender differences were found. Sex of resident was not found to influence clinical behaviour significantly. Conclusions: These results highlight differential sex-role attitudes, as measured by the SRES, between female and male residents and suggest that residents' sex-role biases affect the diagnosis of APD. These results have implications for psychiatric assessment and treatment. Further understanding of these issues is critical to the development of educational tools to address sex biases in psychiatry.",
keywords = "diagnosis, gender, personality disorders, resident education, sex bias, women's mental health",
author = "Belitsky, {Catherine A.} and Toner, {Brenda B.} and Alisha Ali and Betty Yu and Osborne, {Susan L.} and Elizabeth DeRooy",
year = "1996",
month = "10",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "41",
pages = "503--508",
journal = "Canadian Journal of Psychiatry",
issn = "0706-7437",
publisher = "Canadian Psychiatric Association",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sex-role attitudes and clinical appraisal in psychiatry residents

AU - Belitsky, Catherine A.

AU - Toner, Brenda B.

AU - Ali, Alisha

AU - Yu, Betty

AU - Osborne, Susan L.

AU - DeRooy, Elizabeth

PY - 1996/10

Y1 - 1996/10

N2 - Objective: To measure sex-role beliefs of psychiatry residents and to examine bias in clinical appraisal. Method: Residents (45 female, 51 male) evaluated 1 of 4 possible clinical case histories -a female or male patient with histrionic personality disorder (HPD) or antisocial personality disorder (APD) - and completed the Sex-Role Egalitarianism Scale (SRES). Results: As predicted, female residents were more egalitarian than male residents (P < 0.03) according to the SRES. As expected, significantly more male than female patients received the diagnosis of APD (P < 0.00002). Although it was predicted that female patients would more often be given the HPD diagnosis than males, no significant gender differences were found. Sex of resident was not found to influence clinical behaviour significantly. Conclusions: These results highlight differential sex-role attitudes, as measured by the SRES, between female and male residents and suggest that residents' sex-role biases affect the diagnosis of APD. These results have implications for psychiatric assessment and treatment. Further understanding of these issues is critical to the development of educational tools to address sex biases in psychiatry.

AB - Objective: To measure sex-role beliefs of psychiatry residents and to examine bias in clinical appraisal. Method: Residents (45 female, 51 male) evaluated 1 of 4 possible clinical case histories -a female or male patient with histrionic personality disorder (HPD) or antisocial personality disorder (APD) - and completed the Sex-Role Egalitarianism Scale (SRES). Results: As predicted, female residents were more egalitarian than male residents (P < 0.03) according to the SRES. As expected, significantly more male than female patients received the diagnosis of APD (P < 0.00002). Although it was predicted that female patients would more often be given the HPD diagnosis than males, no significant gender differences were found. Sex of resident was not found to influence clinical behaviour significantly. Conclusions: These results highlight differential sex-role attitudes, as measured by the SRES, between female and male residents and suggest that residents' sex-role biases affect the diagnosis of APD. These results have implications for psychiatric assessment and treatment. Further understanding of these issues is critical to the development of educational tools to address sex biases in psychiatry.

KW - diagnosis

KW - gender

KW - personality disorders

KW - resident education

KW - sex bias

KW - women's mental health

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0029862288&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0029862288&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 8899235

AN - SCOPUS:0029862288

VL - 41

SP - 503

EP - 508

JO - Canadian Journal of Psychiatry

JF - Canadian Journal of Psychiatry

SN - 0706-7437

IS - 8

ER -