Selective nucleation and discovery of organic polymorphs through epitaxy with single crystal substrates

C. A. Mitchell, L. Yu, Michael Ward

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Crystallization of 5-methyl-2-[(2-nitrophenyl)amino]-3-thiophenecarbonitrile (1), previously found to produce six conformational polymorphs from solution, on single-crystal pimelic acid (PA) substrates results in selective and oriented growth of the metastable "YN" (yellow needle) polymorph on the (101) PA faces of the substrate. Though the freshly cleaved substrate crystals expose (101) PA and (111) PA faces, which are both decorated with [101] PA ledges that could serve as nucleation sites, crystal growth of YN occurs on only (101) PA. Goniometry measurements performed with an atomic force microscope reveal that the (001) YN plane contacts (101) PA with a crystal orientation [100] YN||[010] PA and [010] YN||[101] PA. A geometric lattice analysis using a newly developed program dubbed GRACE (geometric real-space analysis of crystal epitaxy) indicates that this interfacial configuration arises from optimal two-dimensional epitaxy and that among the six polymorphs of 1, only the YN polymorph, in the observed orientation, achieves reasonable epitaxial match to (101) PA. The geometric analysis also reveals that none of the polymorphs, including YN, can achieve comparable epitaxial match with (111) PA, consistent with the absence of nucleation on this crystal face. In contrast, sublimation of 1 on cleaved succinic acid (SA) substrates, which expose large (010) SA faces decorated with steps along [101̄] SA, affords growth of several polymorphs, each with multiple orientations, as well as oriented crystals of a new metastable polymorph on the (010) SA surfaces. The lack of polymorphic selectivity on (010) SA can be explained by the geometric lattice analysis, which reveals low-grade epitaxial matches between (010) SA and several polymorphs of 1 but no inherent selectivity toward a single polymorph. These observations demonstrate the sensitivity of crystal nucleation to substrate surface structure, the potential of crystalline substrates for selective nucleation and discovery of polymorphs, and the utility of geometric lattice modeling for screening of substrate libraries for controlling polymorphism.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)10830-10839
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of the American Chemical Society
Volume123
Issue number44
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 7 2001

Fingerprint

Pimelic Acids
Polymorphism
Epitaxial growth
Nucleation
Single crystals
Succinic Acid
Acids
Substrates
Crystals
Crystallization
Crystal orientation
Sublimation
Growth

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Chemistry(all)

Cite this

Selective nucleation and discovery of organic polymorphs through epitaxy with single crystal substrates. / Mitchell, C. A.; Yu, L.; Ward, Michael.

In: Journal of the American Chemical Society, Vol. 123, No. 44, 07.11.2001, p. 10830-10839.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{d8f2a306eddd49cba718a6e4b48766b2,
title = "Selective nucleation and discovery of organic polymorphs through epitaxy with single crystal substrates",
abstract = "Crystallization of 5-methyl-2-[(2-nitrophenyl)amino]-3-thiophenecarbonitrile (1), previously found to produce six conformational polymorphs from solution, on single-crystal pimelic acid (PA) substrates results in selective and oriented growth of the metastable {"}YN{"} (yellow needle) polymorph on the (101) PA faces of the substrate. Though the freshly cleaved substrate crystals expose (101) PA and (111) PA faces, which are both decorated with [101] PA ledges that could serve as nucleation sites, crystal growth of YN occurs on only (101) PA. Goniometry measurements performed with an atomic force microscope reveal that the (001) YN plane contacts (101) PA with a crystal orientation [100] YN||[010] PA and [010] YN||[101] PA. A geometric lattice analysis using a newly developed program dubbed GRACE (geometric real-space analysis of crystal epitaxy) indicates that this interfacial configuration arises from optimal two-dimensional epitaxy and that among the six polymorphs of 1, only the YN polymorph, in the observed orientation, achieves reasonable epitaxial match to (101) PA. The geometric analysis also reveals that none of the polymorphs, including YN, can achieve comparable epitaxial match with (111) PA, consistent with the absence of nucleation on this crystal face. In contrast, sublimation of 1 on cleaved succinic acid (SA) substrates, which expose large (010) SA faces decorated with steps along [101̄] SA, affords growth of several polymorphs, each with multiple orientations, as well as oriented crystals of a new metastable polymorph on the (010) SA surfaces. The lack of polymorphic selectivity on (010) SA can be explained by the geometric lattice analysis, which reveals low-grade epitaxial matches between (010) SA and several polymorphs of 1 but no inherent selectivity toward a single polymorph. These observations demonstrate the sensitivity of crystal nucleation to substrate surface structure, the potential of crystalline substrates for selective nucleation and discovery of polymorphs, and the utility of geometric lattice modeling for screening of substrate libraries for controlling polymorphism.",
author = "Mitchell, {C. A.} and L. Yu and Michael Ward",
year = "2001",
month = "11",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1021/ja004085f",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "123",
pages = "10830--10839",
journal = "Journal of the American Chemical Society",
issn = "0002-7863",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "44",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Selective nucleation and discovery of organic polymorphs through epitaxy with single crystal substrates

AU - Mitchell, C. A.

AU - Yu, L.

AU - Ward, Michael

PY - 2001/11/7

Y1 - 2001/11/7

N2 - Crystallization of 5-methyl-2-[(2-nitrophenyl)amino]-3-thiophenecarbonitrile (1), previously found to produce six conformational polymorphs from solution, on single-crystal pimelic acid (PA) substrates results in selective and oriented growth of the metastable "YN" (yellow needle) polymorph on the (101) PA faces of the substrate. Though the freshly cleaved substrate crystals expose (101) PA and (111) PA faces, which are both decorated with [101] PA ledges that could serve as nucleation sites, crystal growth of YN occurs on only (101) PA. Goniometry measurements performed with an atomic force microscope reveal that the (001) YN plane contacts (101) PA with a crystal orientation [100] YN||[010] PA and [010] YN||[101] PA. A geometric lattice analysis using a newly developed program dubbed GRACE (geometric real-space analysis of crystal epitaxy) indicates that this interfacial configuration arises from optimal two-dimensional epitaxy and that among the six polymorphs of 1, only the YN polymorph, in the observed orientation, achieves reasonable epitaxial match to (101) PA. The geometric analysis also reveals that none of the polymorphs, including YN, can achieve comparable epitaxial match with (111) PA, consistent with the absence of nucleation on this crystal face. In contrast, sublimation of 1 on cleaved succinic acid (SA) substrates, which expose large (010) SA faces decorated with steps along [101̄] SA, affords growth of several polymorphs, each with multiple orientations, as well as oriented crystals of a new metastable polymorph on the (010) SA surfaces. The lack of polymorphic selectivity on (010) SA can be explained by the geometric lattice analysis, which reveals low-grade epitaxial matches between (010) SA and several polymorphs of 1 but no inherent selectivity toward a single polymorph. These observations demonstrate the sensitivity of crystal nucleation to substrate surface structure, the potential of crystalline substrates for selective nucleation and discovery of polymorphs, and the utility of geometric lattice modeling for screening of substrate libraries for controlling polymorphism.

AB - Crystallization of 5-methyl-2-[(2-nitrophenyl)amino]-3-thiophenecarbonitrile (1), previously found to produce six conformational polymorphs from solution, on single-crystal pimelic acid (PA) substrates results in selective and oriented growth of the metastable "YN" (yellow needle) polymorph on the (101) PA faces of the substrate. Though the freshly cleaved substrate crystals expose (101) PA and (111) PA faces, which are both decorated with [101] PA ledges that could serve as nucleation sites, crystal growth of YN occurs on only (101) PA. Goniometry measurements performed with an atomic force microscope reveal that the (001) YN plane contacts (101) PA with a crystal orientation [100] YN||[010] PA and [010] YN||[101] PA. A geometric lattice analysis using a newly developed program dubbed GRACE (geometric real-space analysis of crystal epitaxy) indicates that this interfacial configuration arises from optimal two-dimensional epitaxy and that among the six polymorphs of 1, only the YN polymorph, in the observed orientation, achieves reasonable epitaxial match to (101) PA. The geometric analysis also reveals that none of the polymorphs, including YN, can achieve comparable epitaxial match with (111) PA, consistent with the absence of nucleation on this crystal face. In contrast, sublimation of 1 on cleaved succinic acid (SA) substrates, which expose large (010) SA faces decorated with steps along [101̄] SA, affords growth of several polymorphs, each with multiple orientations, as well as oriented crystals of a new metastable polymorph on the (010) SA surfaces. The lack of polymorphic selectivity on (010) SA can be explained by the geometric lattice analysis, which reveals low-grade epitaxial matches between (010) SA and several polymorphs of 1 but no inherent selectivity toward a single polymorph. These observations demonstrate the sensitivity of crystal nucleation to substrate surface structure, the potential of crystalline substrates for selective nucleation and discovery of polymorphs, and the utility of geometric lattice modeling for screening of substrate libraries for controlling polymorphism.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035823875&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0035823875&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/ja004085f

DO - 10.1021/ja004085f

M3 - Article

VL - 123

SP - 10830

EP - 10839

JO - Journal of the American Chemical Society

JF - Journal of the American Chemical Society

SN - 0002-7863

IS - 44

ER -