Rethinking Early Elementary Grade Retention: Examining Long-Term Academic and Psychosocial Outcomes

Sophia H.J. Hwang, Elise Cappella

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Grade retention, the practice of requiring a student to remain in the same grade the following year, disproportionately affects students with sociodemographic risk and facing academic challenges. Each year, the United States spends $20 billion on retention and two million children are retained. Extant studies examining early elementary grade retention generally focus on short-term effects and academic outcomes; little is known about long-term effects on academic and psychosocial outcomes in the middle grades. The current study uses propensity score methods and a national data set to estimate the effect of first- or second-grade retention on academic achievement and psychosocial outcomes six or seven years later. By comparing students who were retained to students who were similar on observed characteristics but otherwise promoted, we generate causal estimates that show a statistically significant negative effect of retention on reading achievement. Significant and robust effects were not consistently detected for other academic or psychosocial outcomes. As grade retention is a widely used educational intervention, implications for its effectiveness from a policy and practice perspective are discussed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)559-587
Number of pages29
JournalJournal of Research on Educational Effectiveness
Volume11
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 2 2018

Fingerprint

school grade
student
academic achievement

Keywords

  • adolescence
  • grade retention
  • propensity score
  • psychosocial
  • reading

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

Rethinking Early Elementary Grade Retention : Examining Long-Term Academic and Psychosocial Outcomes. / Hwang, Sophia H.J.; Cappella, Elise.

In: Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, Vol. 11, No. 4, 02.10.2018, p. 559-587.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{507df51f5a3d48ac9e1de4c28c455332,
title = "Rethinking Early Elementary Grade Retention: Examining Long-Term Academic and Psychosocial Outcomes",
abstract = "Grade retention, the practice of requiring a student to remain in the same grade the following year, disproportionately affects students with sociodemographic risk and facing academic challenges. Each year, the United States spends $20 billion on retention and two million children are retained. Extant studies examining early elementary grade retention generally focus on short-term effects and academic outcomes; little is known about long-term effects on academic and psychosocial outcomes in the middle grades. The current study uses propensity score methods and a national data set to estimate the effect of first- or second-grade retention on academic achievement and psychosocial outcomes six or seven years later. By comparing students who were retained to students who were similar on observed characteristics but otherwise promoted, we generate causal estimates that show a statistically significant negative effect of retention on reading achievement. Significant and robust effects were not consistently detected for other academic or psychosocial outcomes. As grade retention is a widely used educational intervention, implications for its effectiveness from a policy and practice perspective are discussed.",
keywords = "adolescence, grade retention, propensity score, psychosocial, reading",
author = "Hwang, {Sophia H.J.} and Elise Cappella",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1080/19345747.2018.1496500",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "11",
pages = "559--587",
journal = "Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness",
issn = "1934-5747",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rethinking Early Elementary Grade Retention

T2 - Examining Long-Term Academic and Psychosocial Outcomes

AU - Hwang, Sophia H.J.

AU - Cappella, Elise

PY - 2018/10/2

Y1 - 2018/10/2

N2 - Grade retention, the practice of requiring a student to remain in the same grade the following year, disproportionately affects students with sociodemographic risk and facing academic challenges. Each year, the United States spends $20 billion on retention and two million children are retained. Extant studies examining early elementary grade retention generally focus on short-term effects and academic outcomes; little is known about long-term effects on academic and psychosocial outcomes in the middle grades. The current study uses propensity score methods and a national data set to estimate the effect of first- or second-grade retention on academic achievement and psychosocial outcomes six or seven years later. By comparing students who were retained to students who were similar on observed characteristics but otherwise promoted, we generate causal estimates that show a statistically significant negative effect of retention on reading achievement. Significant and robust effects were not consistently detected for other academic or psychosocial outcomes. As grade retention is a widely used educational intervention, implications for its effectiveness from a policy and practice perspective are discussed.

AB - Grade retention, the practice of requiring a student to remain in the same grade the following year, disproportionately affects students with sociodemographic risk and facing academic challenges. Each year, the United States spends $20 billion on retention and two million children are retained. Extant studies examining early elementary grade retention generally focus on short-term effects and academic outcomes; little is known about long-term effects on academic and psychosocial outcomes in the middle grades. The current study uses propensity score methods and a national data set to estimate the effect of first- or second-grade retention on academic achievement and psychosocial outcomes six or seven years later. By comparing students who were retained to students who were similar on observed characteristics but otherwise promoted, we generate causal estimates that show a statistically significant negative effect of retention on reading achievement. Significant and robust effects were not consistently detected for other academic or psychosocial outcomes. As grade retention is a widely used educational intervention, implications for its effectiveness from a policy and practice perspective are discussed.

KW - adolescence

KW - grade retention

KW - propensity score

KW - psychosocial

KW - reading

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85060083218&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85060083218&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/19345747.2018.1496500

DO - 10.1080/19345747.2018.1496500

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85060083218

VL - 11

SP - 559

EP - 587

JO - Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness

JF - Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness

SN - 1934-5747

IS - 4

ER -