Reliability and fatigue failure modes of implant-supported aluminum-oxide fixed dental prostheses

Christian F J Stappert, Marta Baldassarri, Yu Zhang, Felix Hänssler, Elizabeth D. Rekow, Van P. Thompson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objectives: To investigate failure modes and reliability of implant-supported aluminum-oxide three-unit fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) using two different veneering porcelains. Material and methods: Thirty-six aluminum-oxide FDP frameworks were computer-aided designed and computer-aided manufactured and either hand-veneered(n = 18) or over-pressed(n = 18). All FDPs were adhesively luted to custom-made zirconium-oxide-abutments attached to dental implant fixtures (regular platform 4 × 13 mm). Specimens were stored in water before mechanical testing. A step-stress accelerated life test (SSALT) with three load/cycles varying profiles was developed based on initial single-load-to-failure testing. Failure was defined by veneer chipping or chipping in combination with framework fracture. SSALT was performed on each FDP inclined 30° with respect to the applied load direction. For all specimens, failure modes were analyzed using polarized reflected light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Reliability was computed using Weibull analysis software (Reliasoft). Results: The dominant failure mode for the over-pressed FDPs was buccal chipping of the porcelain in the loading area of the pontic, while hand-veneered specimens failed mainly by combined failure modes in the veneering porcelain, framework, and abutments. Chipping of the porcelain occurred earlier in the over-pressed specimens (350 N/85 k, load/cycles) than in the hand-veneered ones (600 N/110 k) (profile I). Given a mission at 300 N load and 100 or 200 k cycles, the computed Weibull reliability (two-sided at 90% confidence bounds) was 0.99(1/0.98) and 0.99(1/0.98) for hand-veneered FDPs and 0.45(0.76/0.10) and 0.05(0.63/0) for over-pressed FDPs, respectively. Conclusions: In the range of average clinical loads (300-700 N), hand-veneered aluminum-oxide FDPs showed significantly less failure by chipping of the veneer than the over-pressed. Hand-veneered FDPs under fatigue loading failed at loads ≥600 N.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1173-1180
Number of pages8
JournalClinical Oral Implants Research
Volume23
Issue number10
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 2012

Fingerprint

Dental Prosthesis
Aluminum Oxide
Fatigue
Dental Porcelain
Hand
Psychological Stress
Polarization Microscopy
Fixed Partial Denture
Dental Implants
Cheek
Electron Scanning Microscopy
Software

Keywords

  • Aluminum-oxide
  • Bridge
  • Ceramic
  • Chewing simulation
  • Chipping
  • Fatigue
  • Fixed-partial-denture
  • Fracture
  • Veneering porcelain
  • Weibull-reliability

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Oral Surgery

Cite this

Reliability and fatigue failure modes of implant-supported aluminum-oxide fixed dental prostheses. / Stappert, Christian F J; Baldassarri, Marta; Zhang, Yu; Hänssler, Felix; Rekow, Elizabeth D.; Thompson, Van P.

In: Clinical Oral Implants Research, Vol. 23, No. 10, 10.2012, p. 1173-1180.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Stappert, Christian F J ; Baldassarri, Marta ; Zhang, Yu ; Hänssler, Felix ; Rekow, Elizabeth D. ; Thompson, Van P. / Reliability and fatigue failure modes of implant-supported aluminum-oxide fixed dental prostheses. In: Clinical Oral Implants Research. 2012 ; Vol. 23, No. 10. pp. 1173-1180.
@article{162f9e9c94b041e980be451d514e27ea,
title = "Reliability and fatigue failure modes of implant-supported aluminum-oxide fixed dental prostheses",
abstract = "Objectives: To investigate failure modes and reliability of implant-supported aluminum-oxide three-unit fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) using two different veneering porcelains. Material and methods: Thirty-six aluminum-oxide FDP frameworks were computer-aided designed and computer-aided manufactured and either hand-veneered(n = 18) or over-pressed(n = 18). All FDPs were adhesively luted to custom-made zirconium-oxide-abutments attached to dental implant fixtures (regular platform 4 × 13 mm). Specimens were stored in water before mechanical testing. A step-stress accelerated life test (SSALT) with three load/cycles varying profiles was developed based on initial single-load-to-failure testing. Failure was defined by veneer chipping or chipping in combination with framework fracture. SSALT was performed on each FDP inclined 30° with respect to the applied load direction. For all specimens, failure modes were analyzed using polarized reflected light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Reliability was computed using Weibull analysis software (Reliasoft). Results: The dominant failure mode for the over-pressed FDPs was buccal chipping of the porcelain in the loading area of the pontic, while hand-veneered specimens failed mainly by combined failure modes in the veneering porcelain, framework, and abutments. Chipping of the porcelain occurred earlier in the over-pressed specimens (350 N/85 k, load/cycles) than in the hand-veneered ones (600 N/110 k) (profile I). Given a mission at 300 N load and 100 or 200 k cycles, the computed Weibull reliability (two-sided at 90{\%} confidence bounds) was 0.99(1/0.98) and 0.99(1/0.98) for hand-veneered FDPs and 0.45(0.76/0.10) and 0.05(0.63/0) for over-pressed FDPs, respectively. Conclusions: In the range of average clinical loads (300-700 N), hand-veneered aluminum-oxide FDPs showed significantly less failure by chipping of the veneer than the over-pressed. Hand-veneered FDPs under fatigue loading failed at loads ≥600 N.",
keywords = "Aluminum-oxide, Bridge, Ceramic, Chewing simulation, Chipping, Fatigue, Fixed-partial-denture, Fracture, Veneering porcelain, Weibull-reliability",
author = "Stappert, {Christian F J} and Marta Baldassarri and Yu Zhang and Felix H{\"a}nssler and Rekow, {Elizabeth D.} and Thompson, {Van P.}",
year = "2012",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1111/j.1600-0501.2011.02281.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "23",
pages = "1173--1180",
journal = "Clinical Oral Implants Research",
issn = "0905-7161",
publisher = "Blackwell Munksgaard",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reliability and fatigue failure modes of implant-supported aluminum-oxide fixed dental prostheses

AU - Stappert, Christian F J

AU - Baldassarri, Marta

AU - Zhang, Yu

AU - Hänssler, Felix

AU - Rekow, Elizabeth D.

AU - Thompson, Van P.

PY - 2012/10

Y1 - 2012/10

N2 - Objectives: To investigate failure modes and reliability of implant-supported aluminum-oxide three-unit fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) using two different veneering porcelains. Material and methods: Thirty-six aluminum-oxide FDP frameworks were computer-aided designed and computer-aided manufactured and either hand-veneered(n = 18) or over-pressed(n = 18). All FDPs were adhesively luted to custom-made zirconium-oxide-abutments attached to dental implant fixtures (regular platform 4 × 13 mm). Specimens were stored in water before mechanical testing. A step-stress accelerated life test (SSALT) with three load/cycles varying profiles was developed based on initial single-load-to-failure testing. Failure was defined by veneer chipping or chipping in combination with framework fracture. SSALT was performed on each FDP inclined 30° with respect to the applied load direction. For all specimens, failure modes were analyzed using polarized reflected light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Reliability was computed using Weibull analysis software (Reliasoft). Results: The dominant failure mode for the over-pressed FDPs was buccal chipping of the porcelain in the loading area of the pontic, while hand-veneered specimens failed mainly by combined failure modes in the veneering porcelain, framework, and abutments. Chipping of the porcelain occurred earlier in the over-pressed specimens (350 N/85 k, load/cycles) than in the hand-veneered ones (600 N/110 k) (profile I). Given a mission at 300 N load and 100 or 200 k cycles, the computed Weibull reliability (two-sided at 90% confidence bounds) was 0.99(1/0.98) and 0.99(1/0.98) for hand-veneered FDPs and 0.45(0.76/0.10) and 0.05(0.63/0) for over-pressed FDPs, respectively. Conclusions: In the range of average clinical loads (300-700 N), hand-veneered aluminum-oxide FDPs showed significantly less failure by chipping of the veneer than the over-pressed. Hand-veneered FDPs under fatigue loading failed at loads ≥600 N.

AB - Objectives: To investigate failure modes and reliability of implant-supported aluminum-oxide three-unit fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) using two different veneering porcelains. Material and methods: Thirty-six aluminum-oxide FDP frameworks were computer-aided designed and computer-aided manufactured and either hand-veneered(n = 18) or over-pressed(n = 18). All FDPs were adhesively luted to custom-made zirconium-oxide-abutments attached to dental implant fixtures (regular platform 4 × 13 mm). Specimens were stored in water before mechanical testing. A step-stress accelerated life test (SSALT) with three load/cycles varying profiles was developed based on initial single-load-to-failure testing. Failure was defined by veneer chipping or chipping in combination with framework fracture. SSALT was performed on each FDP inclined 30° with respect to the applied load direction. For all specimens, failure modes were analyzed using polarized reflected light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Reliability was computed using Weibull analysis software (Reliasoft). Results: The dominant failure mode for the over-pressed FDPs was buccal chipping of the porcelain in the loading area of the pontic, while hand-veneered specimens failed mainly by combined failure modes in the veneering porcelain, framework, and abutments. Chipping of the porcelain occurred earlier in the over-pressed specimens (350 N/85 k, load/cycles) than in the hand-veneered ones (600 N/110 k) (profile I). Given a mission at 300 N load and 100 or 200 k cycles, the computed Weibull reliability (two-sided at 90% confidence bounds) was 0.99(1/0.98) and 0.99(1/0.98) for hand-veneered FDPs and 0.45(0.76/0.10) and 0.05(0.63/0) for over-pressed FDPs, respectively. Conclusions: In the range of average clinical loads (300-700 N), hand-veneered aluminum-oxide FDPs showed significantly less failure by chipping of the veneer than the over-pressed. Hand-veneered FDPs under fatigue loading failed at loads ≥600 N.

KW - Aluminum-oxide

KW - Bridge

KW - Ceramic

KW - Chewing simulation

KW - Chipping

KW - Fatigue

KW - Fixed-partial-denture

KW - Fracture

KW - Veneering porcelain

KW - Weibull-reliability

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84866496088&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84866496088&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1600-0501.2011.02281.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1600-0501.2011.02281.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 22093019

AN - SCOPUS:84866496088

VL - 23

SP - 1173

EP - 1180

JO - Clinical Oral Implants Research

JF - Clinical Oral Implants Research

SN - 0905-7161

IS - 10

ER -