Race and gender differences in attitudes toward help seeking among marginalized young adults with mood disorders: A mixed-methods investigation

Sarah C. Narendorf, Michelle Munson, Shelly Ben-David, Andrea R. Cole, Lionel D. Scott

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective: Race and gender differences in help seeking are well-established; however, reasons for these differences are less clear. This study examined race and gender differences in two potential contributors- perceptions of illness and attitudes toward treatment-in a sample of marginalized young adults. Method: Interviews were conducted with young adults (age 18-25) with prior involvement in public systems of care and mood disorder diagnoses (n = 60). A quantitative interview assessed illness perceptions and attitudes followed by a qualitative interview focused on perceptions of mental illness and treatment. Analyses examined quantitative differences across four race/gender subgroups-White women (n = 13), White men (n = 6), women of color (n = 27), and men of color (n = 14), then qualitative results were reviewed for a subset of cases (n = 30) to understand differences revealed in the quantitative analyses. Results: Women of color had lower scores on illness understanding compared to other groups and men of color had lower scores on chronicity. Attitudes including propensity toward help seeking and stigma resistance were lowest in men of color, followed by women of color. Qualitative findings supported that men of color viewed their symptoms as less chronic and managed symptoms by changing their mindset rather than formal treatments. White participants talked more about their illnesses as chronic conditions and spoke more positively of treatment. Conclusion and Implications for Practice: Race/gender differences were identified, particularly in relation to views of mental illness and stigma. Messaging that highlights independence and strength in relation to managing symptoms may be particularly important for young people of color.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)277-289
Number of pages13
JournalPsychiatric Rehabilitation Journal
Volume41
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2018

Fingerprint

Mood Disorders
Young Adult
Color
Interviews
Therapeutics
Chronic Disease

Keywords

  • Gender differences
  • Mental health
  • Racial differences
  • Young adult

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Professions (miscellaneous)
  • Rehabilitation
  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

Race and gender differences in attitudes toward help seeking among marginalized young adults with mood disorders : A mixed-methods investigation. / Narendorf, Sarah C.; Munson, Michelle; Ben-David, Shelly; Cole, Andrea R.; Scott, Lionel D.

In: Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, Vol. 41, No. 4, 01.12.2018, p. 277-289.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{2ed6cdfd203a47fdb297ede39567bd48,
title = "Race and gender differences in attitudes toward help seeking among marginalized young adults with mood disorders: A mixed-methods investigation",
abstract = "Objective: Race and gender differences in help seeking are well-established; however, reasons for these differences are less clear. This study examined race and gender differences in two potential contributors- perceptions of illness and attitudes toward treatment-in a sample of marginalized young adults. Method: Interviews were conducted with young adults (age 18-25) with prior involvement in public systems of care and mood disorder diagnoses (n = 60). A quantitative interview assessed illness perceptions and attitudes followed by a qualitative interview focused on perceptions of mental illness and treatment. Analyses examined quantitative differences across four race/gender subgroups-White women (n = 13), White men (n = 6), women of color (n = 27), and men of color (n = 14), then qualitative results were reviewed for a subset of cases (n = 30) to understand differences revealed in the quantitative analyses. Results: Women of color had lower scores on illness understanding compared to other groups and men of color had lower scores on chronicity. Attitudes including propensity toward help seeking and stigma resistance were lowest in men of color, followed by women of color. Qualitative findings supported that men of color viewed their symptoms as less chronic and managed symptoms by changing their mindset rather than formal treatments. White participants talked more about their illnesses as chronic conditions and spoke more positively of treatment. Conclusion and Implications for Practice: Race/gender differences were identified, particularly in relation to views of mental illness and stigma. Messaging that highlights independence and strength in relation to managing symptoms may be particularly important for young people of color.",
keywords = "Gender differences, Mental health, Racial differences, Young adult",
author = "Narendorf, {Sarah C.} and Michelle Munson and Shelly Ben-David and Cole, {Andrea R.} and Scott, {Lionel D.}",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1037/prj0000312",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "41",
pages = "277--289",
journal = "Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal",
issn = "1095-158X",
publisher = "Boston University",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Race and gender differences in attitudes toward help seeking among marginalized young adults with mood disorders

T2 - A mixed-methods investigation

AU - Narendorf, Sarah C.

AU - Munson, Michelle

AU - Ben-David, Shelly

AU - Cole, Andrea R.

AU - Scott, Lionel D.

PY - 2018/12/1

Y1 - 2018/12/1

N2 - Objective: Race and gender differences in help seeking are well-established; however, reasons for these differences are less clear. This study examined race and gender differences in two potential contributors- perceptions of illness and attitudes toward treatment-in a sample of marginalized young adults. Method: Interviews were conducted with young adults (age 18-25) with prior involvement in public systems of care and mood disorder diagnoses (n = 60). A quantitative interview assessed illness perceptions and attitudes followed by a qualitative interview focused on perceptions of mental illness and treatment. Analyses examined quantitative differences across four race/gender subgroups-White women (n = 13), White men (n = 6), women of color (n = 27), and men of color (n = 14), then qualitative results were reviewed for a subset of cases (n = 30) to understand differences revealed in the quantitative analyses. Results: Women of color had lower scores on illness understanding compared to other groups and men of color had lower scores on chronicity. Attitudes including propensity toward help seeking and stigma resistance were lowest in men of color, followed by women of color. Qualitative findings supported that men of color viewed their symptoms as less chronic and managed symptoms by changing their mindset rather than formal treatments. White participants talked more about their illnesses as chronic conditions and spoke more positively of treatment. Conclusion and Implications for Practice: Race/gender differences were identified, particularly in relation to views of mental illness and stigma. Messaging that highlights independence and strength in relation to managing symptoms may be particularly important for young people of color.

AB - Objective: Race and gender differences in help seeking are well-established; however, reasons for these differences are less clear. This study examined race and gender differences in two potential contributors- perceptions of illness and attitudes toward treatment-in a sample of marginalized young adults. Method: Interviews were conducted with young adults (age 18-25) with prior involvement in public systems of care and mood disorder diagnoses (n = 60). A quantitative interview assessed illness perceptions and attitudes followed by a qualitative interview focused on perceptions of mental illness and treatment. Analyses examined quantitative differences across four race/gender subgroups-White women (n = 13), White men (n = 6), women of color (n = 27), and men of color (n = 14), then qualitative results were reviewed for a subset of cases (n = 30) to understand differences revealed in the quantitative analyses. Results: Women of color had lower scores on illness understanding compared to other groups and men of color had lower scores on chronicity. Attitudes including propensity toward help seeking and stigma resistance were lowest in men of color, followed by women of color. Qualitative findings supported that men of color viewed their symptoms as less chronic and managed symptoms by changing their mindset rather than formal treatments. White participants talked more about their illnesses as chronic conditions and spoke more positively of treatment. Conclusion and Implications for Practice: Race/gender differences were identified, particularly in relation to views of mental illness and stigma. Messaging that highlights independence and strength in relation to managing symptoms may be particularly important for young people of color.

KW - Gender differences

KW - Mental health

KW - Racial differences

KW - Young adult

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85057791118&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85057791118&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1037/prj0000312

DO - 10.1037/prj0000312

M3 - Article

C2 - 30507242

AN - SCOPUS:85057791118

VL - 41

SP - 277

EP - 289

JO - Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal

JF - Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal

SN - 1095-158X

IS - 4

ER -