Primary bone microanatomy records developmental aspects of life history in catarrhine primates

Shannon C. McFarlin, Carl J. Terranova, Adrienne L. Zihlman, Timothy Bromage

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

A central challenge in human origins research is to understand how evolution has shaped modern human life history. As fossilized remains of our ancestors provide the only direct evidence for life history evolution, efforts to reconstruct life history in paleontological contexts have focused on hard tissues, particularly on dental development. However, among investigators of other vertebrate groups, there is a long tradition of examining primary bone microstructure to decipher growth rates and maturational timing, based on an empirical relationship between the microanatomy of primary bone and the rate at which it is deposited. We examined ontogenetic variation in primary bone microstructure at the midshaft femur of Chlorocebus aethiops, Hylobates lar, and Pan troglodytes to test whether tissue type proportions vary in accordance with predictions based on body mass growth patterns described previously. In all taxa, younger age classes were characterized by significantly higher percent areas of fibro-lamellar and/or parallel-fibered tissues, while older age classes showed significantly higher proportions of lamellar bone. In prior experimental studies, fibro-lamellar and parallel-fibered tissue types have been associated with faster depositional rates than lamellar bone. Principal components analysis revealed differences among taxa in the timing of this transition, and in the particular tissue types observed among individuals of similar dental emergence status. Among M1 and M2 age classes, higher proportions of parallel-fibered and fibro-lamellar tissues were observed in those taxa characterized by reportedly faster body mass growth rates. Further, persistence of fibro-lamellar tissue throughout DECID, M1 and M2 age classes in chimpanzees contrasts with the pattern reported previously for modern humans. Despite the necessary limitations of our cross-sectional study design and the secondary remodeling of bone in primates, large areas of primary bone remain intact and represent a valuable and independent source of information about the evolution of growth and development in the fossil record.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)60-79
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Human Evolution
Volume92
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2016

Fingerprint

primate
bone
Primates
life history
bones
age class
age structure
Pan troglodytes
body mass
microstructure
cross-sectional study
source of information
teeth
persistence
Cercopithecus aethiops
information sources
tissues
tissue
Life History
femur

Keywords

  • Apes
  • Bone histology
  • Growth and development
  • Life history
  • Old World monkeys

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)
  • Education

Cite this

Primary bone microanatomy records developmental aspects of life history in catarrhine primates. / McFarlin, Shannon C.; Terranova, Carl J.; Zihlman, Adrienne L.; Bromage, Timothy.

In: Journal of Human Evolution, Vol. 92, 01.03.2016, p. 60-79.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

McFarlin, Shannon C. ; Terranova, Carl J. ; Zihlman, Adrienne L. ; Bromage, Timothy. / Primary bone microanatomy records developmental aspects of life history in catarrhine primates. In: Journal of Human Evolution. 2016 ; Vol. 92. pp. 60-79.
@article{b3a5ba21cb4d421890015de5839797e6,
title = "Primary bone microanatomy records developmental aspects of life history in catarrhine primates",
abstract = "A central challenge in human origins research is to understand how evolution has shaped modern human life history. As fossilized remains of our ancestors provide the only direct evidence for life history evolution, efforts to reconstruct life history in paleontological contexts have focused on hard tissues, particularly on dental development. However, among investigators of other vertebrate groups, there is a long tradition of examining primary bone microstructure to decipher growth rates and maturational timing, based on an empirical relationship between the microanatomy of primary bone and the rate at which it is deposited. We examined ontogenetic variation in primary bone microstructure at the midshaft femur of Chlorocebus aethiops, Hylobates lar, and Pan troglodytes to test whether tissue type proportions vary in accordance with predictions based on body mass growth patterns described previously. In all taxa, younger age classes were characterized by significantly higher percent areas of fibro-lamellar and/or parallel-fibered tissues, while older age classes showed significantly higher proportions of lamellar bone. In prior experimental studies, fibro-lamellar and parallel-fibered tissue types have been associated with faster depositional rates than lamellar bone. Principal components analysis revealed differences among taxa in the timing of this transition, and in the particular tissue types observed among individuals of similar dental emergence status. Among M1 and M2 age classes, higher proportions of parallel-fibered and fibro-lamellar tissues were observed in those taxa characterized by reportedly faster body mass growth rates. Further, persistence of fibro-lamellar tissue throughout DECID, M1 and M2 age classes in chimpanzees contrasts with the pattern reported previously for modern humans. Despite the necessary limitations of our cross-sectional study design and the secondary remodeling of bone in primates, large areas of primary bone remain intact and represent a valuable and independent source of information about the evolution of growth and development in the fossil record.",
keywords = "Apes, Bone histology, Growth and development, Life history, Old World monkeys",
author = "McFarlin, {Shannon C.} and Terranova, {Carl J.} and Zihlman, {Adrienne L.} and Timothy Bromage",
year = "2016",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jhevol.2015.12.004",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "92",
pages = "60--79",
journal = "Journal of Human Evolution",
issn = "0047-2484",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Primary bone microanatomy records developmental aspects of life history in catarrhine primates

AU - McFarlin, Shannon C.

AU - Terranova, Carl J.

AU - Zihlman, Adrienne L.

AU - Bromage, Timothy

PY - 2016/3/1

Y1 - 2016/3/1

N2 - A central challenge in human origins research is to understand how evolution has shaped modern human life history. As fossilized remains of our ancestors provide the only direct evidence for life history evolution, efforts to reconstruct life history in paleontological contexts have focused on hard tissues, particularly on dental development. However, among investigators of other vertebrate groups, there is a long tradition of examining primary bone microstructure to decipher growth rates and maturational timing, based on an empirical relationship between the microanatomy of primary bone and the rate at which it is deposited. We examined ontogenetic variation in primary bone microstructure at the midshaft femur of Chlorocebus aethiops, Hylobates lar, and Pan troglodytes to test whether tissue type proportions vary in accordance with predictions based on body mass growth patterns described previously. In all taxa, younger age classes were characterized by significantly higher percent areas of fibro-lamellar and/or parallel-fibered tissues, while older age classes showed significantly higher proportions of lamellar bone. In prior experimental studies, fibro-lamellar and parallel-fibered tissue types have been associated with faster depositional rates than lamellar bone. Principal components analysis revealed differences among taxa in the timing of this transition, and in the particular tissue types observed among individuals of similar dental emergence status. Among M1 and M2 age classes, higher proportions of parallel-fibered and fibro-lamellar tissues were observed in those taxa characterized by reportedly faster body mass growth rates. Further, persistence of fibro-lamellar tissue throughout DECID, M1 and M2 age classes in chimpanzees contrasts with the pattern reported previously for modern humans. Despite the necessary limitations of our cross-sectional study design and the secondary remodeling of bone in primates, large areas of primary bone remain intact and represent a valuable and independent source of information about the evolution of growth and development in the fossil record.

AB - A central challenge in human origins research is to understand how evolution has shaped modern human life history. As fossilized remains of our ancestors provide the only direct evidence for life history evolution, efforts to reconstruct life history in paleontological contexts have focused on hard tissues, particularly on dental development. However, among investigators of other vertebrate groups, there is a long tradition of examining primary bone microstructure to decipher growth rates and maturational timing, based on an empirical relationship between the microanatomy of primary bone and the rate at which it is deposited. We examined ontogenetic variation in primary bone microstructure at the midshaft femur of Chlorocebus aethiops, Hylobates lar, and Pan troglodytes to test whether tissue type proportions vary in accordance with predictions based on body mass growth patterns described previously. In all taxa, younger age classes were characterized by significantly higher percent areas of fibro-lamellar and/or parallel-fibered tissues, while older age classes showed significantly higher proportions of lamellar bone. In prior experimental studies, fibro-lamellar and parallel-fibered tissue types have been associated with faster depositional rates than lamellar bone. Principal components analysis revealed differences among taxa in the timing of this transition, and in the particular tissue types observed among individuals of similar dental emergence status. Among M1 and M2 age classes, higher proportions of parallel-fibered and fibro-lamellar tissues were observed in those taxa characterized by reportedly faster body mass growth rates. Further, persistence of fibro-lamellar tissue throughout DECID, M1 and M2 age classes in chimpanzees contrasts with the pattern reported previously for modern humans. Despite the necessary limitations of our cross-sectional study design and the secondary remodeling of bone in primates, large areas of primary bone remain intact and represent a valuable and independent source of information about the evolution of growth and development in the fossil record.

KW - Apes

KW - Bone histology

KW - Growth and development

KW - Life history

KW - Old World monkeys

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84960158410&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84960158410&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jhevol.2015.12.004

DO - 10.1016/j.jhevol.2015.12.004

M3 - Article

C2 - 26989017

AN - SCOPUS:84960158410

VL - 92

SP - 60

EP - 79

JO - Journal of Human Evolution

JF - Journal of Human Evolution

SN - 0047-2484

ER -