Perceptual similarity in input-output mappings: A computational/experimental study of non-native speech production

Jason A. Shaw, Lisa Davidson

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    This paper takes a computational/experimental approach to investigating faithfulness in input-output phonological mappings. We seek to explain the results of a speech production experiment recently reported in Davidson (2010). In that experiment, native English speakers were asked to produce phonotactically unattested consonant clusters. We argue that modifications of the target consonant clusters are best understood by considering both unfaithful phonological mappings and imprecision in the speech production mechanism. To account for the pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings, we consider an extension of the P-map hypothesis (Steriade, 2008) to the production of phonotactically unattested target sequences. Predictions of the P-map for this data were established by a perception experiment in which participants were asked to discriminate between unattested consonant clusters, CC, and attested modifications, including epenthesis, prothesis, C1 change and C1 deletion. To evaluate the effects of motor noise on consonant cluster production, we constructed a computational model that allowed us to simulate consonant cluster productions under different levels of noise. Simulations reveal that, first, a large proportion of cases involving vocoid insertion, CC, are better accounted for by noisy implementation of the target timing than by phonological epenthesis and, second, that differences in insertion patterns between stop-initial clusters and fricative-initial clusters are due to the internal temporal properties of stops and fricatives. Factoring these cases into the analysis isolates a pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings used to evaluate the P-map hypothesis. On the basis of considerable mismatches between patterns of perceptual similarity and unfaithful input-output mappings, we argue that the P-map theory of faithfulness is too restrictive to extend to the production of non-native speech.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)1344-1358
    Number of pages15
    JournalLingua
    Volume121
    Issue number8
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Jun 2011

    Fingerprint

    experiment
    factoring
    mismatch
    Speech Production
    Consonant Clusters
    Experimental Study
    Computational
    simulation
    Experiment
    Faithfulness
    Fricatives
    Insertion
    Epenthesis
    English Speakers
    Proportion
    Simulation
    Computational Model
    Prediction
    Vocoid
    Imprecision

    Keywords

    • Cross-language speech perception/production
    • Faithfulness
    • Motor coordination
    • P-map hypothesis
    • Perceptual epenthesis
    • Phonetics-phonology interface
    • Phonotactics
    • Stochastic modeling

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Language and Linguistics
    • Linguistics and Language

    Cite this

    Perceptual similarity in input-output mappings : A computational/experimental study of non-native speech production. / Shaw, Jason A.; Davidson, Lisa.

    In: Lingua, Vol. 121, No. 8, 06.2011, p. 1344-1358.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Shaw, Jason A. ; Davidson, Lisa. / Perceptual similarity in input-output mappings : A computational/experimental study of non-native speech production. In: Lingua. 2011 ; Vol. 121, No. 8. pp. 1344-1358.
    @article{de7ecf3d5dd140138a055fae633b86a0,
    title = "Perceptual similarity in input-output mappings: A computational/experimental study of non-native speech production",
    abstract = "This paper takes a computational/experimental approach to investigating faithfulness in input-output phonological mappings. We seek to explain the results of a speech production experiment recently reported in Davidson (2010). In that experiment, native English speakers were asked to produce phonotactically unattested consonant clusters. We argue that modifications of the target consonant clusters are best understood by considering both unfaithful phonological mappings and imprecision in the speech production mechanism. To account for the pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings, we consider an extension of the P-map hypothesis (Steriade, 2008) to the production of phonotactically unattested target sequences. Predictions of the P-map for this data were established by a perception experiment in which participants were asked to discriminate between unattested consonant clusters, CC, and attested modifications, including epenthesis, prothesis, C1 change and C1 deletion. To evaluate the effects of motor noise on consonant cluster production, we constructed a computational model that allowed us to simulate consonant cluster productions under different levels of noise. Simulations reveal that, first, a large proportion of cases involving vocoid insertion, CC, are better accounted for by noisy implementation of the target timing than by phonological epenthesis and, second, that differences in insertion patterns between stop-initial clusters and fricative-initial clusters are due to the internal temporal properties of stops and fricatives. Factoring these cases into the analysis isolates a pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings used to evaluate the P-map hypothesis. On the basis of considerable mismatches between patterns of perceptual similarity and unfaithful input-output mappings, we argue that the P-map theory of faithfulness is too restrictive to extend to the production of non-native speech.",
    keywords = "Cross-language speech perception/production, Faithfulness, Motor coordination, P-map hypothesis, Perceptual epenthesis, Phonetics-phonology interface, Phonotactics, Stochastic modeling",
    author = "Shaw, {Jason A.} and Lisa Davidson",
    year = "2011",
    month = "6",
    doi = "10.1016/j.lingua.2011.03.003",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "121",
    pages = "1344--1358",
    journal = "Lingua",
    issn = "0024-3841",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "8",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Perceptual similarity in input-output mappings

    T2 - A computational/experimental study of non-native speech production

    AU - Shaw, Jason A.

    AU - Davidson, Lisa

    PY - 2011/6

    Y1 - 2011/6

    N2 - This paper takes a computational/experimental approach to investigating faithfulness in input-output phonological mappings. We seek to explain the results of a speech production experiment recently reported in Davidson (2010). In that experiment, native English speakers were asked to produce phonotactically unattested consonant clusters. We argue that modifications of the target consonant clusters are best understood by considering both unfaithful phonological mappings and imprecision in the speech production mechanism. To account for the pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings, we consider an extension of the P-map hypothesis (Steriade, 2008) to the production of phonotactically unattested target sequences. Predictions of the P-map for this data were established by a perception experiment in which participants were asked to discriminate between unattested consonant clusters, CC, and attested modifications, including epenthesis, prothesis, C1 change and C1 deletion. To evaluate the effects of motor noise on consonant cluster production, we constructed a computational model that allowed us to simulate consonant cluster productions under different levels of noise. Simulations reveal that, first, a large proportion of cases involving vocoid insertion, CC, are better accounted for by noisy implementation of the target timing than by phonological epenthesis and, second, that differences in insertion patterns between stop-initial clusters and fricative-initial clusters are due to the internal temporal properties of stops and fricatives. Factoring these cases into the analysis isolates a pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings used to evaluate the P-map hypothesis. On the basis of considerable mismatches between patterns of perceptual similarity and unfaithful input-output mappings, we argue that the P-map theory of faithfulness is too restrictive to extend to the production of non-native speech.

    AB - This paper takes a computational/experimental approach to investigating faithfulness in input-output phonological mappings. We seek to explain the results of a speech production experiment recently reported in Davidson (2010). In that experiment, native English speakers were asked to produce phonotactically unattested consonant clusters. We argue that modifications of the target consonant clusters are best understood by considering both unfaithful phonological mappings and imprecision in the speech production mechanism. To account for the pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings, we consider an extension of the P-map hypothesis (Steriade, 2008) to the production of phonotactically unattested target sequences. Predictions of the P-map for this data were established by a perception experiment in which participants were asked to discriminate between unattested consonant clusters, CC, and attested modifications, including epenthesis, prothesis, C1 change and C1 deletion. To evaluate the effects of motor noise on consonant cluster production, we constructed a computational model that allowed us to simulate consonant cluster productions under different levels of noise. Simulations reveal that, first, a large proportion of cases involving vocoid insertion, CC, are better accounted for by noisy implementation of the target timing than by phonological epenthesis and, second, that differences in insertion patterns between stop-initial clusters and fricative-initial clusters are due to the internal temporal properties of stops and fricatives. Factoring these cases into the analysis isolates a pattern of unfaithful input-output mappings used to evaluate the P-map hypothesis. On the basis of considerable mismatches between patterns of perceptual similarity and unfaithful input-output mappings, we argue that the P-map theory of faithfulness is too restrictive to extend to the production of non-native speech.

    KW - Cross-language speech perception/production

    KW - Faithfulness

    KW - Motor coordination

    KW - P-map hypothesis

    KW - Perceptual epenthesis

    KW - Phonetics-phonology interface

    KW - Phonotactics

    KW - Stochastic modeling

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79955979023&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79955979023&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.lingua.2011.03.003

    DO - 10.1016/j.lingua.2011.03.003

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:79955979023

    VL - 121

    SP - 1344

    EP - 1358

    JO - Lingua

    JF - Lingua

    SN - 0024-3841

    IS - 8

    ER -