Pathologizing poverty: New forms of diagnosis, disability, and structural stigma under welfare reform

Helena Hansen, Philippe Bourgois, Ernest Drucker

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    In 1996 the U.S. severely restricted public support for low income people, ending "welfare as we know it." This led to dramatic increases in medicalized forms of support for indigent people, who increasingly rely on disability benefits justified by psychiatric diagnoses of chronic mental illness. We present case studies drawn from ethnographic data involving daily participant-observation between 2005 and 2012 in public clinics and impoverished neighborhoods in New York City, to describe the subjective experience of structural stigma imposed by the increasing medicalization of public support for the poor through a diagnosis of permanent mental disability. In some cases, disability benefits enable recipients to fulfill important social roles (sustaining a vulnerable household and promoting stable parenting). The status of family members who receive a monthly disability check improves within their kin and neighborhood-based networks, counterbalancing the felt stigma of being identified by doctors as "crazy". When a diagnosis of mental pathology becomes a valuable survival strategy constituting the basis for fulfillment of household responsibilities, stigmatizing processes are structurally altered. Through the decades, the stigmatized labels applied to the poor have shifted: from being a symptom of racial weakness, to the culture of poverty, and now to permanent medical pathology. The neoliberal bureaucratic requirement that the poor must repeatedly prove their "disabled" status through therapy and psychotropic medication appears to be generating a national and policy-maker discourse condemning SSI malingerers, resurrecting the 16th century specter of the "unworthy poor".

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)76-83
    Number of pages8
    JournalSocial Science and Medicine
    Volume103
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Feb 2014

    Fingerprint

    Poverty
    welfare
    disability
    Medicalization
    public support
    poverty
    Pathology
    pathology
    reform
    Parenting
    Administrative Personnel
    Mental Disorders
    mental disability
    medicalization
    survival strategy
    Chronic Disease
    Observation
    Social Role
    participant observation
    mental illness

    Keywords

    • Addiction
    • Disability
    • Mental illness
    • Poverty
    • Stigma
    • Structure
    • U.S.A.
    • Welfare reform

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Health(social science)
    • History and Philosophy of Science

    Cite this

    Pathologizing poverty : New forms of diagnosis, disability, and structural stigma under welfare reform. / Hansen, Helena; Bourgois, Philippe; Drucker, Ernest.

    In: Social Science and Medicine, Vol. 103, 02.2014, p. 76-83.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Hansen, Helena ; Bourgois, Philippe ; Drucker, Ernest. / Pathologizing poverty : New forms of diagnosis, disability, and structural stigma under welfare reform. In: Social Science and Medicine. 2014 ; Vol. 103. pp. 76-83.
    @article{79132ae7be7e40c08f4bcdf4d5deaf9a,
    title = "Pathologizing poverty: New forms of diagnosis, disability, and structural stigma under welfare reform",
    abstract = "In 1996 the U.S. severely restricted public support for low income people, ending {"}welfare as we know it.{"} This led to dramatic increases in medicalized forms of support for indigent people, who increasingly rely on disability benefits justified by psychiatric diagnoses of chronic mental illness. We present case studies drawn from ethnographic data involving daily participant-observation between 2005 and 2012 in public clinics and impoverished neighborhoods in New York City, to describe the subjective experience of structural stigma imposed by the increasing medicalization of public support for the poor through a diagnosis of permanent mental disability. In some cases, disability benefits enable recipients to fulfill important social roles (sustaining a vulnerable household and promoting stable parenting). The status of family members who receive a monthly disability check improves within their kin and neighborhood-based networks, counterbalancing the felt stigma of being identified by doctors as {"}crazy{"}. When a diagnosis of mental pathology becomes a valuable survival strategy constituting the basis for fulfillment of household responsibilities, stigmatizing processes are structurally altered. Through the decades, the stigmatized labels applied to the poor have shifted: from being a symptom of racial weakness, to the culture of poverty, and now to permanent medical pathology. The neoliberal bureaucratic requirement that the poor must repeatedly prove their {"}disabled{"} status through therapy and psychotropic medication appears to be generating a national and policy-maker discourse condemning SSI malingerers, resurrecting the 16th century specter of the {"}unworthy poor{"}.",
    keywords = "Addiction, Disability, Mental illness, Poverty, Stigma, Structure, U.S.A., Welfare reform",
    author = "Helena Hansen and Philippe Bourgois and Ernest Drucker",
    year = "2014",
    month = "2",
    doi = "10.1016/j.socscimed.2013.06.033",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "103",
    pages = "76--83",
    journal = "Social Science and Medicine",
    issn = "0277-9536",
    publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Pathologizing poverty

    T2 - New forms of diagnosis, disability, and structural stigma under welfare reform

    AU - Hansen, Helena

    AU - Bourgois, Philippe

    AU - Drucker, Ernest

    PY - 2014/2

    Y1 - 2014/2

    N2 - In 1996 the U.S. severely restricted public support for low income people, ending "welfare as we know it." This led to dramatic increases in medicalized forms of support for indigent people, who increasingly rely on disability benefits justified by psychiatric diagnoses of chronic mental illness. We present case studies drawn from ethnographic data involving daily participant-observation between 2005 and 2012 in public clinics and impoverished neighborhoods in New York City, to describe the subjective experience of structural stigma imposed by the increasing medicalization of public support for the poor through a diagnosis of permanent mental disability. In some cases, disability benefits enable recipients to fulfill important social roles (sustaining a vulnerable household and promoting stable parenting). The status of family members who receive a monthly disability check improves within their kin and neighborhood-based networks, counterbalancing the felt stigma of being identified by doctors as "crazy". When a diagnosis of mental pathology becomes a valuable survival strategy constituting the basis for fulfillment of household responsibilities, stigmatizing processes are structurally altered. Through the decades, the stigmatized labels applied to the poor have shifted: from being a symptom of racial weakness, to the culture of poverty, and now to permanent medical pathology. The neoliberal bureaucratic requirement that the poor must repeatedly prove their "disabled" status through therapy and psychotropic medication appears to be generating a national and policy-maker discourse condemning SSI malingerers, resurrecting the 16th century specter of the "unworthy poor".

    AB - In 1996 the U.S. severely restricted public support for low income people, ending "welfare as we know it." This led to dramatic increases in medicalized forms of support for indigent people, who increasingly rely on disability benefits justified by psychiatric diagnoses of chronic mental illness. We present case studies drawn from ethnographic data involving daily participant-observation between 2005 and 2012 in public clinics and impoverished neighborhoods in New York City, to describe the subjective experience of structural stigma imposed by the increasing medicalization of public support for the poor through a diagnosis of permanent mental disability. In some cases, disability benefits enable recipients to fulfill important social roles (sustaining a vulnerable household and promoting stable parenting). The status of family members who receive a monthly disability check improves within their kin and neighborhood-based networks, counterbalancing the felt stigma of being identified by doctors as "crazy". When a diagnosis of mental pathology becomes a valuable survival strategy constituting the basis for fulfillment of household responsibilities, stigmatizing processes are structurally altered. Through the decades, the stigmatized labels applied to the poor have shifted: from being a symptom of racial weakness, to the culture of poverty, and now to permanent medical pathology. The neoliberal bureaucratic requirement that the poor must repeatedly prove their "disabled" status through therapy and psychotropic medication appears to be generating a national and policy-maker discourse condemning SSI malingerers, resurrecting the 16th century specter of the "unworthy poor".

    KW - Addiction

    KW - Disability

    KW - Mental illness

    KW - Poverty

    KW - Stigma

    KW - Structure

    KW - U.S.A.

    KW - Welfare reform

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84893494821&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84893494821&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.socscimed.2013.06.033

    DO - 10.1016/j.socscimed.2013.06.033

    M3 - Article

    C2 - 24507913

    AN - SCOPUS:84893494821

    VL - 103

    SP - 76

    EP - 83

    JO - Social Science and Medicine

    JF - Social Science and Medicine

    SN - 0277-9536

    ER -