Outcome in place of an expected threat diminishes recovery of defensive responses

Joseph E. Dunsmoor, Vinn D. Campese, Ahmet O. Ceceli, Joseph E. LeDoux, Elizabeth A. Phelps

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Experimental extinction serves as a model for psychiatric treatments based on associative learning. However, the effects of extinction are often transient, as evidenced by postextinction return of defensive behaviors. From a therapeutic perspective, an inherent problem with extinction may be that mere omission of threat is not sufficient to reduce future threat uncertainty. The current study tested an augmented form of extinction that replaced, rather than merely omitted, expected threat outcomes with novel nonthreat outcomes, with the goal of reducing postextinction return of defensive behaviors. METHODS: Thirty-two healthy male Sprague-Dawley rats and 47 human adults underwent threat conditioning to a conditioned stimulus paired with an electrical shock. Subjects then underwent a standard extinction protocol with shock omitted or an augmented extinction protocol wherein the shock was replaced by a surprising tone. Tests of postextinction recovery occurred 24 hours later in the absence of the tone. RESULTS: Replacing the shock with a novel nonthreat outcome, as compared with shock omission, reduced postextinction recovery (freezing in rats and anticipatory skin conductance responses in humans) when tested 24 hours later. Self-reported intolerance of uncertainty was positively correlated with recovery following standard extinction in humans, providing new evidence that postextinction recovery is related to sensitivity to future threat uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide cross-species evidence of a novel strategy to enhance extinction that may have broad implications for how to override associative learning that has become maladaptive and offer a simple technique that could be straightforwardly adapted and implemented in clinical situations.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)203-209
Number of pages7
JournalBiological Psychiatry
Volume78
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Shock
Uncertainty
Learning
Psychological Extinction
Freezing
Sprague Dawley Rats
Psychiatry
Skin
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Anxiety
  • Arousal
  • Electrodermal
  • Fear
  • Pavlovian
  • Regulation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biological Psychiatry

Cite this

Outcome in place of an expected threat diminishes recovery of defensive responses. / Dunsmoor, Joseph E.; Campese, Vinn D.; Ceceli, Ahmet O.; LeDoux, Joseph E.; Phelps, Elizabeth A.

In: Biological Psychiatry, Vol. 78, No. 3, 2015, p. 203-209.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dunsmoor, Joseph E. ; Campese, Vinn D. ; Ceceli, Ahmet O. ; LeDoux, Joseph E. ; Phelps, Elizabeth A. / Outcome in place of an expected threat diminishes recovery of defensive responses. In: Biological Psychiatry. 2015 ; Vol. 78, No. 3. pp. 203-209.
@article{68c56d87eb7848e5bd8fb3c8f551669f,
title = "Outcome in place of an expected threat diminishes recovery of defensive responses",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Experimental extinction serves as a model for psychiatric treatments based on associative learning. However, the effects of extinction are often transient, as evidenced by postextinction return of defensive behaviors. From a therapeutic perspective, an inherent problem with extinction may be that mere omission of threat is not sufficient to reduce future threat uncertainty. The current study tested an augmented form of extinction that replaced, rather than merely omitted, expected threat outcomes with novel nonthreat outcomes, with the goal of reducing postextinction return of defensive behaviors. METHODS: Thirty-two healthy male Sprague-Dawley rats and 47 human adults underwent threat conditioning to a conditioned stimulus paired with an electrical shock. Subjects then underwent a standard extinction protocol with shock omitted or an augmented extinction protocol wherein the shock was replaced by a surprising tone. Tests of postextinction recovery occurred 24 hours later in the absence of the tone. RESULTS: Replacing the shock with a novel nonthreat outcome, as compared with shock omission, reduced postextinction recovery (freezing in rats and anticipatory skin conductance responses in humans) when tested 24 hours later. Self-reported intolerance of uncertainty was positively correlated with recovery following standard extinction in humans, providing new evidence that postextinction recovery is related to sensitivity to future threat uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide cross-species evidence of a novel strategy to enhance extinction that may have broad implications for how to override associative learning that has become maladaptive and offer a simple technique that could be straightforwardly adapted and implemented in clinical situations.",
keywords = "Anxiety, Arousal, Electrodermal, Fear, Pavlovian, Regulation",
author = "Dunsmoor, {Joseph E.} and Campese, {Vinn D.} and Ceceli, {Ahmet O.} and LeDoux, {Joseph E.} and Phelps, {Elizabeth A.}",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1016/j.biopsych.2014.12.008",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "78",
pages = "203--209",
journal = "Biological Psychiatry",
issn = "0006-3223",
publisher = "Elsevier USA",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Outcome in place of an expected threat diminishes recovery of defensive responses

AU - Dunsmoor, Joseph E.

AU - Campese, Vinn D.

AU - Ceceli, Ahmet O.

AU - LeDoux, Joseph E.

AU - Phelps, Elizabeth A.

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - BACKGROUND: Experimental extinction serves as a model for psychiatric treatments based on associative learning. However, the effects of extinction are often transient, as evidenced by postextinction return of defensive behaviors. From a therapeutic perspective, an inherent problem with extinction may be that mere omission of threat is not sufficient to reduce future threat uncertainty. The current study tested an augmented form of extinction that replaced, rather than merely omitted, expected threat outcomes with novel nonthreat outcomes, with the goal of reducing postextinction return of defensive behaviors. METHODS: Thirty-two healthy male Sprague-Dawley rats and 47 human adults underwent threat conditioning to a conditioned stimulus paired with an electrical shock. Subjects then underwent a standard extinction protocol with shock omitted or an augmented extinction protocol wherein the shock was replaced by a surprising tone. Tests of postextinction recovery occurred 24 hours later in the absence of the tone. RESULTS: Replacing the shock with a novel nonthreat outcome, as compared with shock omission, reduced postextinction recovery (freezing in rats and anticipatory skin conductance responses in humans) when tested 24 hours later. Self-reported intolerance of uncertainty was positively correlated with recovery following standard extinction in humans, providing new evidence that postextinction recovery is related to sensitivity to future threat uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide cross-species evidence of a novel strategy to enhance extinction that may have broad implications for how to override associative learning that has become maladaptive and offer a simple technique that could be straightforwardly adapted and implemented in clinical situations.

AB - BACKGROUND: Experimental extinction serves as a model for psychiatric treatments based on associative learning. However, the effects of extinction are often transient, as evidenced by postextinction return of defensive behaviors. From a therapeutic perspective, an inherent problem with extinction may be that mere omission of threat is not sufficient to reduce future threat uncertainty. The current study tested an augmented form of extinction that replaced, rather than merely omitted, expected threat outcomes with novel nonthreat outcomes, with the goal of reducing postextinction return of defensive behaviors. METHODS: Thirty-two healthy male Sprague-Dawley rats and 47 human adults underwent threat conditioning to a conditioned stimulus paired with an electrical shock. Subjects then underwent a standard extinction protocol with shock omitted or an augmented extinction protocol wherein the shock was replaced by a surprising tone. Tests of postextinction recovery occurred 24 hours later in the absence of the tone. RESULTS: Replacing the shock with a novel nonthreat outcome, as compared with shock omission, reduced postextinction recovery (freezing in rats and anticipatory skin conductance responses in humans) when tested 24 hours later. Self-reported intolerance of uncertainty was positively correlated with recovery following standard extinction in humans, providing new evidence that postextinction recovery is related to sensitivity to future threat uncertainty. CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide cross-species evidence of a novel strategy to enhance extinction that may have broad implications for how to override associative learning that has become maladaptive and offer a simple technique that could be straightforwardly adapted and implemented in clinical situations.

KW - Anxiety

KW - Arousal

KW - Electrodermal

KW - Fear

KW - Pavlovian

KW - Regulation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84936986586&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84936986586&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.biopsych.2014.12.008

DO - 10.1016/j.biopsych.2014.12.008

M3 - Article

C2 - 25636175

AN - SCOPUS:84936986586

VL - 78

SP - 203

EP - 209

JO - Biological Psychiatry

JF - Biological Psychiatry

SN - 0006-3223

IS - 3

ER -