Nihao – XVIII. Origin of the MOND phenomenology of galactic rotation curves in a CDM universe

Aaron A. Dutton, Andrea Maccio, Aura Obreja, Tobias Buck

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The phenomenological basis for Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) is the radial acceleration relation (RAR) between the observed acceleration, a = V rot 2 (r)/r, and the acceleration accounted for by the observed baryons (stars and cold gas), a bar = V bar 2 (r)/r. We show that the RAR arises naturally in the NIHAO sample of 89 high-resolution CDM cosmological galaxy formation simulations. The overall scatter from NIHAO is just 0.079 dex, consistent with observational constraints. However, we show that the scatter depends on stellar mass. At high masses (10 9 M star 10 11 M) the simulated scatter is just 0.04 dex, increasing to 0.11 dex at low masses (10 7 M star 10 9 M). Observations show a similar dependence for the intrinsic scatter. At high masses the intrinsic scatter is consistent with the zero scatter assumed by MOND, but at low masses the intrinsic scatter is non-zero, strongly disfavouring MOND. Applying MOND to our simulations yields remarkably good fits to most of the circular velocity profiles. In cases of mild disagreement the stellar mass-to-light ratio and/or ‘distance’ can be tuned to yield acceptable fits, as is often done in observational mass models. In dwarf galaxies with M star ∼ 10 6 M MOND breaks down, predicting lower accelerations than observed and in our CDM simulations. The assumptions that MOND is based on (e.g. asymptotically flat rotation curves, zero intrinsic scatter in the RAR) are only approximately true in CDM. Thus if one wishes to go beyond Newtonian dynamics there is more freedom in the observed RAR than assumed by MOND.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1886-1899
Number of pages14
JournalMonthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Volume485
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 15 2019

Fingerprint

galactic rotation
phenomenology
universe
curves
M stars
stellar mass
simulation
mass to light ratios
cold gas
velocity profile
galactic evolution
dwarf galaxies
baryons
velocity distribution
breakdown
stars
high resolution
gas

Keywords

  • Dark matter
  • Galaxies: fundamental parameters
  • Galaxies: haloes
  • Galaxies: kinematics and dynamics
  • Methods: numerical

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Nihao – XVIII. Origin of the MOND phenomenology of galactic rotation curves in a CDM universe. / Dutton, Aaron A.; Maccio, Andrea; Obreja, Aura; Buck, Tobias.

In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 485, No. 2, 15.02.2019, p. 1886-1899.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9df0d9dde43e4e7bb20c903fa8afe2b9,
title = "Nihao – XVIII. Origin of the MOND phenomenology of galactic rotation curves in a CDM universe",
abstract = "The phenomenological basis for Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) is the radial acceleration relation (RAR) between the observed acceleration, a = V rot 2 (r)/r, and the acceleration accounted for by the observed baryons (stars and cold gas), a bar = V bar 2 (r)/r. We show that the RAR arises naturally in the NIHAO sample of 89 high-resolution CDM cosmological galaxy formation simulations. The overall scatter from NIHAO is just 0.079 dex, consistent with observational constraints. However, we show that the scatter depends on stellar mass. At high masses (10 9 M star 10 11 M) the simulated scatter is just 0.04 dex, increasing to 0.11 dex at low masses (10 7 M star 10 9 M). Observations show a similar dependence for the intrinsic scatter. At high masses the intrinsic scatter is consistent with the zero scatter assumed by MOND, but at low masses the intrinsic scatter is non-zero, strongly disfavouring MOND. Applying MOND to our simulations yields remarkably good fits to most of the circular velocity profiles. In cases of mild disagreement the stellar mass-to-light ratio and/or ‘distance’ can be tuned to yield acceptable fits, as is often done in observational mass models. In dwarf galaxies with M star ∼ 10 6 M MOND breaks down, predicting lower accelerations than observed and in our CDM simulations. The assumptions that MOND is based on (e.g. asymptotically flat rotation curves, zero intrinsic scatter in the RAR) are only approximately true in CDM. Thus if one wishes to go beyond Newtonian dynamics there is more freedom in the observed RAR than assumed by MOND.",
keywords = "Dark matter, Galaxies: fundamental parameters, Galaxies: haloes, Galaxies: kinematics and dynamics, Methods: numerical",
author = "Dutton, {Aaron A.} and Andrea Maccio and Aura Obreja and Tobias Buck",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1093/mnras/stz531",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "485",
pages = "1886--1899",
journal = "Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society",
issn = "0035-8711",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nihao – XVIII. Origin of the MOND phenomenology of galactic rotation curves in a CDM universe

AU - Dutton, Aaron A.

AU - Maccio, Andrea

AU - Obreja, Aura

AU - Buck, Tobias

PY - 2019/2/15

Y1 - 2019/2/15

N2 - The phenomenological basis for Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) is the radial acceleration relation (RAR) between the observed acceleration, a = V rot 2 (r)/r, and the acceleration accounted for by the observed baryons (stars and cold gas), a bar = V bar 2 (r)/r. We show that the RAR arises naturally in the NIHAO sample of 89 high-resolution CDM cosmological galaxy formation simulations. The overall scatter from NIHAO is just 0.079 dex, consistent with observational constraints. However, we show that the scatter depends on stellar mass. At high masses (10 9 M star 10 11 M) the simulated scatter is just 0.04 dex, increasing to 0.11 dex at low masses (10 7 M star 10 9 M). Observations show a similar dependence for the intrinsic scatter. At high masses the intrinsic scatter is consistent with the zero scatter assumed by MOND, but at low masses the intrinsic scatter is non-zero, strongly disfavouring MOND. Applying MOND to our simulations yields remarkably good fits to most of the circular velocity profiles. In cases of mild disagreement the stellar mass-to-light ratio and/or ‘distance’ can be tuned to yield acceptable fits, as is often done in observational mass models. In dwarf galaxies with M star ∼ 10 6 M MOND breaks down, predicting lower accelerations than observed and in our CDM simulations. The assumptions that MOND is based on (e.g. asymptotically flat rotation curves, zero intrinsic scatter in the RAR) are only approximately true in CDM. Thus if one wishes to go beyond Newtonian dynamics there is more freedom in the observed RAR than assumed by MOND.

AB - The phenomenological basis for Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) is the radial acceleration relation (RAR) between the observed acceleration, a = V rot 2 (r)/r, and the acceleration accounted for by the observed baryons (stars and cold gas), a bar = V bar 2 (r)/r. We show that the RAR arises naturally in the NIHAO sample of 89 high-resolution CDM cosmological galaxy formation simulations. The overall scatter from NIHAO is just 0.079 dex, consistent with observational constraints. However, we show that the scatter depends on stellar mass. At high masses (10 9 M star 10 11 M) the simulated scatter is just 0.04 dex, increasing to 0.11 dex at low masses (10 7 M star 10 9 M). Observations show a similar dependence for the intrinsic scatter. At high masses the intrinsic scatter is consistent with the zero scatter assumed by MOND, but at low masses the intrinsic scatter is non-zero, strongly disfavouring MOND. Applying MOND to our simulations yields remarkably good fits to most of the circular velocity profiles. In cases of mild disagreement the stellar mass-to-light ratio and/or ‘distance’ can be tuned to yield acceptable fits, as is often done in observational mass models. In dwarf galaxies with M star ∼ 10 6 M MOND breaks down, predicting lower accelerations than observed and in our CDM simulations. The assumptions that MOND is based on (e.g. asymptotically flat rotation curves, zero intrinsic scatter in the RAR) are only approximately true in CDM. Thus if one wishes to go beyond Newtonian dynamics there is more freedom in the observed RAR than assumed by MOND.

KW - Dark matter

KW - Galaxies: fundamental parameters

KW - Galaxies: haloes

KW - Galaxies: kinematics and dynamics

KW - Methods: numerical

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85062892604&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85062892604&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/mnras/stz531

DO - 10.1093/mnras/stz531

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85062892604

VL - 485

SP - 1886

EP - 1899

JO - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

JF - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

SN - 0035-8711

IS - 2

ER -