Meta-stability of equilibrium statistical structures for prototype geophysical flows with damping and driving

Mark T. Dibattista, Andrew J. Majda, Marcus J. Grote

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The most-probable states of an equilibrium statistical theory, which consist of monopole vortices, dipole vortex streets, and zonal shear flows for various parameter regimes, are shown to be meta-stable with respect to damped and driven quasigeostrophic dynamics in a periodic β-plane channel. Through a series of numerical experiments that include (1) pure decay, (2) both damping and driving, and (3) both direct and inverse cascades of energy, we demonstrate that statistically most-probable states evolve into other most-probable states with high accuracy, even as the energy changes substantially and the flow undergoes topological transitions from vortex to shear flow, or vice versa. The predictions of the equilibrium statistical theory are calculated by an algorithm, which we call an "approximate dynamics", that constructs the most-probable states from the instantaneous values of a few quantities in the evolving flow. Qualitatively, the approximate dynamics predicts the correct topological structure -whether vortex flow or zonal shear - in the evolving flow. Quantitatively, the predictions are evaluated by measuring the relative errors between the velocity fields and vorticity fields of the evolving flow and the most-probable states. For evolving monopole vortices we find that errors in the velocity field are generally near 5% and errors in the potential vorticity field are generally near 15%. For evolving dipole vortex streets, the magnitude of the relative errors depends on the amplitude of the localized forcing. For pure decay, the errors in the velocity field are generally near 5% and errors in the vorticity field are generally near 12%; for runs in which the flow is strongly forced by small-scale vortices whose amplitude is nearly 3/10 the peak vorticity in the initial flow, the errors in the velocity field can rise to 20% and the errors in the vorticity field rise to 40%.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)271-304
Number of pages34
JournalPhysica D: Nonlinear Phenomena
Volume151
Issue number2-4
DOIs
StatePublished - May 1 2001

Fingerprint

Geophysical Flows
Metastability
Stability of Equilibria
metastable state
Vortex
Probable
Damping
Vorticity
damping
prototypes
Prototype
Vortex flow
Velocity Field
vorticity
vortices
velocity distribution
Monopole
vortex streets
Shear Flow
Relative Error

Keywords

  • Coherent structure
  • Equilibrium statistical theory
  • Meta-stability

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Applied Mathematics
  • Statistical and Nonlinear Physics

Cite this

Meta-stability of equilibrium statistical structures for prototype geophysical flows with damping and driving. / Dibattista, Mark T.; Majda, Andrew J.; Grote, Marcus J.

In: Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, Vol. 151, No. 2-4, 01.05.2001, p. 271-304.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e611c2214a2840be95281d38cda528b1,
title = "Meta-stability of equilibrium statistical structures for prototype geophysical flows with damping and driving",
abstract = "The most-probable states of an equilibrium statistical theory, which consist of monopole vortices, dipole vortex streets, and zonal shear flows for various parameter regimes, are shown to be meta-stable with respect to damped and driven quasigeostrophic dynamics in a periodic β-plane channel. Through a series of numerical experiments that include (1) pure decay, (2) both damping and driving, and (3) both direct and inverse cascades of energy, we demonstrate that statistically most-probable states evolve into other most-probable states with high accuracy, even as the energy changes substantially and the flow undergoes topological transitions from vortex to shear flow, or vice versa. The predictions of the equilibrium statistical theory are calculated by an algorithm, which we call an {"}approximate dynamics{"}, that constructs the most-probable states from the instantaneous values of a few quantities in the evolving flow. Qualitatively, the approximate dynamics predicts the correct topological structure -whether vortex flow or zonal shear - in the evolving flow. Quantitatively, the predictions are evaluated by measuring the relative errors between the velocity fields and vorticity fields of the evolving flow and the most-probable states. For evolving monopole vortices we find that errors in the velocity field are generally near 5{\%} and errors in the potential vorticity field are generally near 15{\%}. For evolving dipole vortex streets, the magnitude of the relative errors depends on the amplitude of the localized forcing. For pure decay, the errors in the velocity field are generally near 5{\%} and errors in the vorticity field are generally near 12{\%}; for runs in which the flow is strongly forced by small-scale vortices whose amplitude is nearly 3/10 the peak vorticity in the initial flow, the errors in the velocity field can rise to 20{\%} and the errors in the vorticity field rise to 40{\%}.",
keywords = "Coherent structure, Equilibrium statistical theory, Meta-stability",
author = "Dibattista, {Mark T.} and Majda, {Andrew J.} and Grote, {Marcus J.}",
year = "2001",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/S0167-2789(01)00230-5",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "151",
pages = "271--304",
journal = "Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena",
issn = "0167-2789",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "2-4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Meta-stability of equilibrium statistical structures for prototype geophysical flows with damping and driving

AU - Dibattista, Mark T.

AU - Majda, Andrew J.

AU - Grote, Marcus J.

PY - 2001/5/1

Y1 - 2001/5/1

N2 - The most-probable states of an equilibrium statistical theory, which consist of monopole vortices, dipole vortex streets, and zonal shear flows for various parameter regimes, are shown to be meta-stable with respect to damped and driven quasigeostrophic dynamics in a periodic β-plane channel. Through a series of numerical experiments that include (1) pure decay, (2) both damping and driving, and (3) both direct and inverse cascades of energy, we demonstrate that statistically most-probable states evolve into other most-probable states with high accuracy, even as the energy changes substantially and the flow undergoes topological transitions from vortex to shear flow, or vice versa. The predictions of the equilibrium statistical theory are calculated by an algorithm, which we call an "approximate dynamics", that constructs the most-probable states from the instantaneous values of a few quantities in the evolving flow. Qualitatively, the approximate dynamics predicts the correct topological structure -whether vortex flow or zonal shear - in the evolving flow. Quantitatively, the predictions are evaluated by measuring the relative errors between the velocity fields and vorticity fields of the evolving flow and the most-probable states. For evolving monopole vortices we find that errors in the velocity field are generally near 5% and errors in the potential vorticity field are generally near 15%. For evolving dipole vortex streets, the magnitude of the relative errors depends on the amplitude of the localized forcing. For pure decay, the errors in the velocity field are generally near 5% and errors in the vorticity field are generally near 12%; for runs in which the flow is strongly forced by small-scale vortices whose amplitude is nearly 3/10 the peak vorticity in the initial flow, the errors in the velocity field can rise to 20% and the errors in the vorticity field rise to 40%.

AB - The most-probable states of an equilibrium statistical theory, which consist of monopole vortices, dipole vortex streets, and zonal shear flows for various parameter regimes, are shown to be meta-stable with respect to damped and driven quasigeostrophic dynamics in a periodic β-plane channel. Through a series of numerical experiments that include (1) pure decay, (2) both damping and driving, and (3) both direct and inverse cascades of energy, we demonstrate that statistically most-probable states evolve into other most-probable states with high accuracy, even as the energy changes substantially and the flow undergoes topological transitions from vortex to shear flow, or vice versa. The predictions of the equilibrium statistical theory are calculated by an algorithm, which we call an "approximate dynamics", that constructs the most-probable states from the instantaneous values of a few quantities in the evolving flow. Qualitatively, the approximate dynamics predicts the correct topological structure -whether vortex flow or zonal shear - in the evolving flow. Quantitatively, the predictions are evaluated by measuring the relative errors between the velocity fields and vorticity fields of the evolving flow and the most-probable states. For evolving monopole vortices we find that errors in the velocity field are generally near 5% and errors in the potential vorticity field are generally near 15%. For evolving dipole vortex streets, the magnitude of the relative errors depends on the amplitude of the localized forcing. For pure decay, the errors in the velocity field are generally near 5% and errors in the vorticity field are generally near 12%; for runs in which the flow is strongly forced by small-scale vortices whose amplitude is nearly 3/10 the peak vorticity in the initial flow, the errors in the velocity field can rise to 20% and the errors in the vorticity field rise to 40%.

KW - Coherent structure

KW - Equilibrium statistical theory

KW - Meta-stability

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0035339034&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0035339034&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/S0167-2789(01)00230-5

DO - 10.1016/S0167-2789(01)00230-5

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0035339034

VL - 151

SP - 271

EP - 304

JO - Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena

JF - Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena

SN - 0167-2789

IS - 2-4

ER -