Maternal longevity and the sex of offspring in pre-industrial Sweden

David Cesarini, Erik Lindqvist, Björn Wallace

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Background: Helle et al. (2000. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science, 296, 1085) argued that giving birth to sons reduced maternal longevity in pre-industrial societies due to higher physiological costs of bearing sons and the elevated testosterone levels observed in mothers carrying male foetuses. Aim: The present study examined this hypothesis using a more comprehensive dataset and evaluated the merits of the statistical approach used in previous studies to identify the cost of giving birth to sons in terms of maternal old-age longevity. Subjects and methods: The analysis in Helle et al. (2002. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science 296, 1085) was extended by using a considerably larger dataset of pre-industrial Swedish women, and with careful consideration paid to methodological problems of sample selection and omitted variable bias. We argue that the previous literature has underestimated the difficulties in quantifying the trade-off between parity and longevity due to unobserved heterogeneity in health. However, under less restrictive assumptions, one can estimate the marginal impact of a son for a fixed family size. Results: No evidence was found of a negative relative impact of sons. Neither was any evidence found in favour of the male-biased intra-household resource competition hypothesis proposed elsewhere in the literature, despite the poverty of the study population. These results are robust to a wide range of specifications tested. Conclusion: The failure to reproduce earlier findings and the fact that studies in this area of research seem to continue to yield conflicting results warrant much caution in discussing and evaluating results. It is likely that the negative effect of sons, if it existed, only manifested itself under conditions that are not yet fully understood. We also argue that the previous literature on this topic has not fully acknowledged the inference problems associated with omitted variable bias and sample selection.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)535-546
    Number of pages12
    JournalAnnals of Human Biology
    Volume34
    Issue number5
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Sep 2007

    Fingerprint

    Nuclear Family
    Sweden
    Mothers
    Parturition
    Costs and Cost Analysis
    Selection Bias
    Maternal Age
    Poverty
    Parity
    Testosterone
    Fetus
    Health
    Research
    Population

    Keywords

    • Demography
    • Maternal longevity
    • Sons

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Epidemiology
    • Physiology
    • Aging
    • Genetics
    • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

    Cite this

    Maternal longevity and the sex of offspring in pre-industrial Sweden. / Cesarini, David; Lindqvist, Erik; Wallace, Björn.

    In: Annals of Human Biology, Vol. 34, No. 5, 09.2007, p. 535-546.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Cesarini, David ; Lindqvist, Erik ; Wallace, Björn. / Maternal longevity and the sex of offspring in pre-industrial Sweden. In: Annals of Human Biology. 2007 ; Vol. 34, No. 5. pp. 535-546.
    @article{1241cc9d7c1e47fab8961fd4daa5ade5,
    title = "Maternal longevity and the sex of offspring in pre-industrial Sweden",
    abstract = "Background: Helle et al. (2000. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science, 296, 1085) argued that giving birth to sons reduced maternal longevity in pre-industrial societies due to higher physiological costs of bearing sons and the elevated testosterone levels observed in mothers carrying male foetuses. Aim: The present study examined this hypothesis using a more comprehensive dataset and evaluated the merits of the statistical approach used in previous studies to identify the cost of giving birth to sons in terms of maternal old-age longevity. Subjects and methods: The analysis in Helle et al. (2002. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science 296, 1085) was extended by using a considerably larger dataset of pre-industrial Swedish women, and with careful consideration paid to methodological problems of sample selection and omitted variable bias. We argue that the previous literature has underestimated the difficulties in quantifying the trade-off between parity and longevity due to unobserved heterogeneity in health. However, under less restrictive assumptions, one can estimate the marginal impact of a son for a fixed family size. Results: No evidence was found of a negative relative impact of sons. Neither was any evidence found in favour of the male-biased intra-household resource competition hypothesis proposed elsewhere in the literature, despite the poverty of the study population. These results are robust to a wide range of specifications tested. Conclusion: The failure to reproduce earlier findings and the fact that studies in this area of research seem to continue to yield conflicting results warrant much caution in discussing and evaluating results. It is likely that the negative effect of sons, if it existed, only manifested itself under conditions that are not yet fully understood. We also argue that the previous literature on this topic has not fully acknowledged the inference problems associated with omitted variable bias and sample selection.",
    keywords = "Demography, Maternal longevity, Sons",
    author = "David Cesarini and Erik Lindqvist and Bj{\"o}rn Wallace",
    year = "2007",
    month = "9",
    doi = "10.1080/03014460701517215",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "34",
    pages = "535--546",
    journal = "Annals of Human Biology",
    issn = "0301-4460",
    publisher = "Informa Healthcare",
    number = "5",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Maternal longevity and the sex of offspring in pre-industrial Sweden

    AU - Cesarini, David

    AU - Lindqvist, Erik

    AU - Wallace, Björn

    PY - 2007/9

    Y1 - 2007/9

    N2 - Background: Helle et al. (2000. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science, 296, 1085) argued that giving birth to sons reduced maternal longevity in pre-industrial societies due to higher physiological costs of bearing sons and the elevated testosterone levels observed in mothers carrying male foetuses. Aim: The present study examined this hypothesis using a more comprehensive dataset and evaluated the merits of the statistical approach used in previous studies to identify the cost of giving birth to sons in terms of maternal old-age longevity. Subjects and methods: The analysis in Helle et al. (2002. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science 296, 1085) was extended by using a considerably larger dataset of pre-industrial Swedish women, and with careful consideration paid to methodological problems of sample selection and omitted variable bias. We argue that the previous literature has underestimated the difficulties in quantifying the trade-off between parity and longevity due to unobserved heterogeneity in health. However, under less restrictive assumptions, one can estimate the marginal impact of a son for a fixed family size. Results: No evidence was found of a negative relative impact of sons. Neither was any evidence found in favour of the male-biased intra-household resource competition hypothesis proposed elsewhere in the literature, despite the poverty of the study population. These results are robust to a wide range of specifications tested. Conclusion: The failure to reproduce earlier findings and the fact that studies in this area of research seem to continue to yield conflicting results warrant much caution in discussing and evaluating results. It is likely that the negative effect of sons, if it existed, only manifested itself under conditions that are not yet fully understood. We also argue that the previous literature on this topic has not fully acknowledged the inference problems associated with omitted variable bias and sample selection.

    AB - Background: Helle et al. (2000. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science, 296, 1085) argued that giving birth to sons reduced maternal longevity in pre-industrial societies due to higher physiological costs of bearing sons and the elevated testosterone levels observed in mothers carrying male foetuses. Aim: The present study examined this hypothesis using a more comprehensive dataset and evaluated the merits of the statistical approach used in previous studies to identify the cost of giving birth to sons in terms of maternal old-age longevity. Subjects and methods: The analysis in Helle et al. (2002. Sons reduced maternal longevity in preindustrial humans. Science 296, 1085) was extended by using a considerably larger dataset of pre-industrial Swedish women, and with careful consideration paid to methodological problems of sample selection and omitted variable bias. We argue that the previous literature has underestimated the difficulties in quantifying the trade-off between parity and longevity due to unobserved heterogeneity in health. However, under less restrictive assumptions, one can estimate the marginal impact of a son for a fixed family size. Results: No evidence was found of a negative relative impact of sons. Neither was any evidence found in favour of the male-biased intra-household resource competition hypothesis proposed elsewhere in the literature, despite the poverty of the study population. These results are robust to a wide range of specifications tested. Conclusion: The failure to reproduce earlier findings and the fact that studies in this area of research seem to continue to yield conflicting results warrant much caution in discussing and evaluating results. It is likely that the negative effect of sons, if it existed, only manifested itself under conditions that are not yet fully understood. We also argue that the previous literature on this topic has not fully acknowledged the inference problems associated with omitted variable bias and sample selection.

    KW - Demography

    KW - Maternal longevity

    KW - Sons

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34548442954&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34548442954&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/03014460701517215

    DO - 10.1080/03014460701517215

    M3 - Article

    VL - 34

    SP - 535

    EP - 546

    JO - Annals of Human Biology

    JF - Annals of Human Biology

    SN - 0301-4460

    IS - 5

    ER -