Married Fathers and Caring Daddies: Welfare Reform and the Discursive Politics of Paternity

Lynne Haney, Miranda March

    Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

    Abstract

    This article analyzes the paternal politics underlying contemporary welfare reform in the United States. Current research on U.S. welfare reform tends to focus on the redefinition of women's responsibilities and social conceptions of motherhood. We contribute to this scholarship by explicating the ways in which reform politics also advance powerful conceptions of fatherhood. Through a discourse analysis of national-level policy debates surrounding new fatherhood legislation, we deconstruct policymakers' views on what constitutes fatherhood. We then compare their discourses to those articulated in interviews with 51 low-income, African American women. From the comparison, we argue that these groups' conceptions of fatherhood diverged in critical ways. Policy-makers' constructions prioritized the form of men's paternal relations over the content of those relations - Defining fatherhood in terms of men's biological, institutional, or financial connection to their children. By contrast, the low-income women we interviewed prioritized the content of men's paternal relations over their form - Conceptualizing fatherhood in terms of men's identification with and participation in paternal activities. By juxtaposing these discourses of fatherhood, our analysis complements feminist research on how ideologies of motherhood influence welfare policies. And by theorizing the differences between these groups' conceptions of fatherhood, we hypothesize about the policy implications of this conceptual divergence.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)461-481
    Number of pages21
    JournalSocial Problems
    Volume50
    Issue number4
    StatePublished - Nov 2003

    Fingerprint

    fatherhood
    father
    welfare
    reform
    politics
    motherhood
    low income
    discourse
    discourse analysis
    divergence
    Ideologies
    social policy
    Group
    legislation
    responsibility
    participation
    interview

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Sociology and Political Science

    Cite this

    Married Fathers and Caring Daddies : Welfare Reform and the Discursive Politics of Paternity. / Haney, Lynne; March, Miranda.

    In: Social Problems, Vol. 50, No. 4, 11.2003, p. 461-481.

    Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

    Haney, Lynne ; March, Miranda. / Married Fathers and Caring Daddies : Welfare Reform and the Discursive Politics of Paternity. In: Social Problems. 2003 ; Vol. 50, No. 4. pp. 461-481.
    @article{7aeace4d1db140299f8667a1bd62f2e5,
    title = "Married Fathers and Caring Daddies: Welfare Reform and the Discursive Politics of Paternity",
    abstract = "This article analyzes the paternal politics underlying contemporary welfare reform in the United States. Current research on U.S. welfare reform tends to focus on the redefinition of women's responsibilities and social conceptions of motherhood. We contribute to this scholarship by explicating the ways in which reform politics also advance powerful conceptions of fatherhood. Through a discourse analysis of national-level policy debates surrounding new fatherhood legislation, we deconstruct policymakers' views on what constitutes fatherhood. We then compare their discourses to those articulated in interviews with 51 low-income, African American women. From the comparison, we argue that these groups' conceptions of fatherhood diverged in critical ways. Policy-makers' constructions prioritized the form of men's paternal relations over the content of those relations - Defining fatherhood in terms of men's biological, institutional, or financial connection to their children. By contrast, the low-income women we interviewed prioritized the content of men's paternal relations over their form - Conceptualizing fatherhood in terms of men's identification with and participation in paternal activities. By juxtaposing these discourses of fatherhood, our analysis complements feminist research on how ideologies of motherhood influence welfare policies. And by theorizing the differences between these groups' conceptions of fatherhood, we hypothesize about the policy implications of this conceptual divergence.",
    author = "Lynne Haney and Miranda March",
    year = "2003",
    month = "11",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "50",
    pages = "461--481",
    journal = "Social Problems",
    issn = "0037-7791",
    publisher = "University of California Press",
    number = "4",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Married Fathers and Caring Daddies

    T2 - Welfare Reform and the Discursive Politics of Paternity

    AU - Haney, Lynne

    AU - March, Miranda

    PY - 2003/11

    Y1 - 2003/11

    N2 - This article analyzes the paternal politics underlying contemporary welfare reform in the United States. Current research on U.S. welfare reform tends to focus on the redefinition of women's responsibilities and social conceptions of motherhood. We contribute to this scholarship by explicating the ways in which reform politics also advance powerful conceptions of fatherhood. Through a discourse analysis of national-level policy debates surrounding new fatherhood legislation, we deconstruct policymakers' views on what constitutes fatherhood. We then compare their discourses to those articulated in interviews with 51 low-income, African American women. From the comparison, we argue that these groups' conceptions of fatherhood diverged in critical ways. Policy-makers' constructions prioritized the form of men's paternal relations over the content of those relations - Defining fatherhood in terms of men's biological, institutional, or financial connection to their children. By contrast, the low-income women we interviewed prioritized the content of men's paternal relations over their form - Conceptualizing fatherhood in terms of men's identification with and participation in paternal activities. By juxtaposing these discourses of fatherhood, our analysis complements feminist research on how ideologies of motherhood influence welfare policies. And by theorizing the differences between these groups' conceptions of fatherhood, we hypothesize about the policy implications of this conceptual divergence.

    AB - This article analyzes the paternal politics underlying contemporary welfare reform in the United States. Current research on U.S. welfare reform tends to focus on the redefinition of women's responsibilities and social conceptions of motherhood. We contribute to this scholarship by explicating the ways in which reform politics also advance powerful conceptions of fatherhood. Through a discourse analysis of national-level policy debates surrounding new fatherhood legislation, we deconstruct policymakers' views on what constitutes fatherhood. We then compare their discourses to those articulated in interviews with 51 low-income, African American women. From the comparison, we argue that these groups' conceptions of fatherhood diverged in critical ways. Policy-makers' constructions prioritized the form of men's paternal relations over the content of those relations - Defining fatherhood in terms of men's biological, institutional, or financial connection to their children. By contrast, the low-income women we interviewed prioritized the content of men's paternal relations over their form - Conceptualizing fatherhood in terms of men's identification with and participation in paternal activities. By juxtaposing these discourses of fatherhood, our analysis complements feminist research on how ideologies of motherhood influence welfare policies. And by theorizing the differences between these groups' conceptions of fatherhood, we hypothesize about the policy implications of this conceptual divergence.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0346474185&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0346474185&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    M3 - Review article

    AN - SCOPUS:0346474185

    VL - 50

    SP - 461

    EP - 481

    JO - Social Problems

    JF - Social Problems

    SN - 0037-7791

    IS - 4

    ER -