Liberal and Conservative Representations of the Good Society: A (Social) Structural Topic Modeling Approach

Joanna Sterling, John Jost, Curtis D. Hardin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

What, in the 21st century, is our vision of the “good society,” and what are the obstacles to its realization? What is the ideal mix of equality and tradition, individual initiative and social welfare, economic prosperity and environmental responsibility, national unity and respect for diversity? Research suggests that liberals and conservatives differ considerably in the prioritization of these values, but nearly all of this research makes use of closed-ended responses to questionnaire items. To examine ideological similarities and dissimilarities in value expression and social representation when it comes to relatively open-ended communication in online social media networks, we used quantitative text-analytic methods to analyze more than 3.8 million messages sent by over 1 million Twitter users about what constitutes a good (vs. bad) society. Results revealed a fairly high degree of ideological divergence: Liberals were more likely to raise themes of social justice, global inequality, women’s rights, racism, criminal justice, health care, poverty, progress, social change, personal growth, and environmental sustainability, whereas conservatives were more likely to mention religion, social order, business, capitalism, national symbols, immigration, and terrorism, as well as individual authorities and news organizations. There were also some areas of convergence: Liberals, moderates, and conservatives were equally likely to prioritize economic prosperity, family, community, and the pursuit of health, happiness, and freedom.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalSAGE Open
Volume9
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1 2019

Fingerprint

prosperity
national unity
welfare economics
twitter
women's rights
social order
happiness
social media
social welfare
divergence
social justice
racism
Values
capitalist society
social change
equality
respect
symbol
terrorism
immigration

Keywords

  • communication
  • mass communication
  • media and society
  • political communication
  • political ideology
  • political polarization
  • social cognition
  • social sciences
  • values

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Arts and Humanities(all)
  • Social Sciences(all)

Cite this

Liberal and Conservative Representations of the Good Society : A (Social) Structural Topic Modeling Approach. / Sterling, Joanna; Jost, John; Hardin, Curtis D.

In: SAGE Open, Vol. 9, No. 2, 01.04.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{74a9d5b06c974efa961789f40c39f54d,
title = "Liberal and Conservative Representations of the Good Society: A (Social) Structural Topic Modeling Approach",
abstract = "What, in the 21st century, is our vision of the “good society,” and what are the obstacles to its realization? What is the ideal mix of equality and tradition, individual initiative and social welfare, economic prosperity and environmental responsibility, national unity and respect for diversity? Research suggests that liberals and conservatives differ considerably in the prioritization of these values, but nearly all of this research makes use of closed-ended responses to questionnaire items. To examine ideological similarities and dissimilarities in value expression and social representation when it comes to relatively open-ended communication in online social media networks, we used quantitative text-analytic methods to analyze more than 3.8 million messages sent by over 1 million Twitter users about what constitutes a good (vs. bad) society. Results revealed a fairly high degree of ideological divergence: Liberals were more likely to raise themes of social justice, global inequality, women’s rights, racism, criminal justice, health care, poverty, progress, social change, personal growth, and environmental sustainability, whereas conservatives were more likely to mention religion, social order, business, capitalism, national symbols, immigration, and terrorism, as well as individual authorities and news organizations. There were also some areas of convergence: Liberals, moderates, and conservatives were equally likely to prioritize economic prosperity, family, community, and the pursuit of health, happiness, and freedom.",
keywords = "communication, mass communication, media and society, political communication, political ideology, political polarization, social cognition, social sciences, values",
author = "Joanna Sterling and John Jost and Hardin, {Curtis D.}",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/2158244019846211",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "9",
journal = "SAGE Open",
issn = "2158-2440",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Liberal and Conservative Representations of the Good Society

T2 - A (Social) Structural Topic Modeling Approach

AU - Sterling, Joanna

AU - Jost, John

AU - Hardin, Curtis D.

PY - 2019/4/1

Y1 - 2019/4/1

N2 - What, in the 21st century, is our vision of the “good society,” and what are the obstacles to its realization? What is the ideal mix of equality and tradition, individual initiative and social welfare, economic prosperity and environmental responsibility, national unity and respect for diversity? Research suggests that liberals and conservatives differ considerably in the prioritization of these values, but nearly all of this research makes use of closed-ended responses to questionnaire items. To examine ideological similarities and dissimilarities in value expression and social representation when it comes to relatively open-ended communication in online social media networks, we used quantitative text-analytic methods to analyze more than 3.8 million messages sent by over 1 million Twitter users about what constitutes a good (vs. bad) society. Results revealed a fairly high degree of ideological divergence: Liberals were more likely to raise themes of social justice, global inequality, women’s rights, racism, criminal justice, health care, poverty, progress, social change, personal growth, and environmental sustainability, whereas conservatives were more likely to mention religion, social order, business, capitalism, national symbols, immigration, and terrorism, as well as individual authorities and news organizations. There were also some areas of convergence: Liberals, moderates, and conservatives were equally likely to prioritize economic prosperity, family, community, and the pursuit of health, happiness, and freedom.

AB - What, in the 21st century, is our vision of the “good society,” and what are the obstacles to its realization? What is the ideal mix of equality and tradition, individual initiative and social welfare, economic prosperity and environmental responsibility, national unity and respect for diversity? Research suggests that liberals and conservatives differ considerably in the prioritization of these values, but nearly all of this research makes use of closed-ended responses to questionnaire items. To examine ideological similarities and dissimilarities in value expression and social representation when it comes to relatively open-ended communication in online social media networks, we used quantitative text-analytic methods to analyze more than 3.8 million messages sent by over 1 million Twitter users about what constitutes a good (vs. bad) society. Results revealed a fairly high degree of ideological divergence: Liberals were more likely to raise themes of social justice, global inequality, women’s rights, racism, criminal justice, health care, poverty, progress, social change, personal growth, and environmental sustainability, whereas conservatives were more likely to mention religion, social order, business, capitalism, national symbols, immigration, and terrorism, as well as individual authorities and news organizations. There were also some areas of convergence: Liberals, moderates, and conservatives were equally likely to prioritize economic prosperity, family, community, and the pursuit of health, happiness, and freedom.

KW - communication

KW - mass communication

KW - media and society

KW - political communication

KW - political ideology

KW - political polarization

KW - social cognition

KW - social sciences

KW - values

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85065244446&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85065244446&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/2158244019846211

DO - 10.1177/2158244019846211

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85065244446

VL - 9

JO - SAGE Open

JF - SAGE Open

SN - 2158-2440

IS - 2

ER -