Investigation of V s – based liquefaction charts using a heavily preshaken silty sand centrifuge deposit

Tarek Abdoun, W. El-Sekelly, R. Dobry

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Preshaking by previous seismic activity can significantly affect the liquefaction resistance of saturated sands. Field evidence, cyclic laboratory testing and centrifuge modeling show that: (i) earthquake events that build up excess pore pressures short of liquefaction strengthen the soil; and (ii) liquefying earthquakes may weaken the soil. The paper presents the results of a centrifuge test (Experiment 2), where a 6 m saturated loose silty sand deposit was subjected to 52 successive base shakings. Three types of shakings were used: preshaking Events A, with a shaking duration of 5 cycles, and stronger Events B and C having a duration of 15 cycles, with Events C having the largest input accelerations. A total of 35 Events A, 9 Events B, and 8 Events C were applied at the base of the model in an alternating sequence. All Events C liquefied the deposit, with the Events B inducing liquefaction at the beginning but not at the end of Experiment 2. Events A generally induced excess pore pressures but not liquefaction. In addition to the pore pressures, horizontal accelerations, settlement and densification, and the soil shear wave velocity, V s , were also monitored during the test. The results were compared with those of Experiment 1, reported in a previous publication, where a similar 6 m deposit of the same silty sand was subjected to a different sequence of shakings A and B which did not include any Event C. Conclusions are drawn on the effect of the strong Events C on the deposit's response. Events A, B and C of Experiment 2 are plotted on existing V s –based liquefaction charts. The charts predict well the liquefaction response of the deposit at the beginning of Experiment 2. On the other hand, for shakings near the end of the test, the charts predict liquefaction for the Events B, which by this time have stopped liquefying the deposit due to the previous history of shakings. This result is consistent with the field evidence including the presence of a number of “false positives” in the charts for silty sand sites in the Imperial Valley of California, an area of intense seismic activity.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)39-52
    Number of pages14
    JournalSoil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering
    Volume122
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Jul 1 2019

    Fingerprint

    centrifuges
    Centrifuges
    Liquefaction
    centrifuge
    liquefaction
    Sand
    Deposits
    sand
    Pore pressure
    pore pressure
    earthquakes
    Soils
    experiment
    Experiments
    testing
    Earthquakes
    duration
    centrifugal model test
    earthquake event
    soil

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Civil and Structural Engineering
    • Geotechnical Engineering and Engineering Geology
    • Soil Science

    Cite this

    Investigation of V s – based liquefaction charts using a heavily preshaken silty sand centrifuge deposit . / Abdoun, Tarek; El-Sekelly, W.; Dobry, R.

    In: Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, Vol. 122, 01.07.2019, p. 39-52.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    @article{d7148a9e66c24f588113170cd91f0d21,
    title = "Investigation of V s – based liquefaction charts using a heavily preshaken silty sand centrifuge deposit",
    abstract = "Preshaking by previous seismic activity can significantly affect the liquefaction resistance of saturated sands. Field evidence, cyclic laboratory testing and centrifuge modeling show that: (i) earthquake events that build up excess pore pressures short of liquefaction strengthen the soil; and (ii) liquefying earthquakes may weaken the soil. The paper presents the results of a centrifuge test (Experiment 2), where a 6 m saturated loose silty sand deposit was subjected to 52 successive base shakings. Three types of shakings were used: preshaking Events A, with a shaking duration of 5 cycles, and stronger Events B and C having a duration of 15 cycles, with Events C having the largest input accelerations. A total of 35 Events A, 9 Events B, and 8 Events C were applied at the base of the model in an alternating sequence. All Events C liquefied the deposit, with the Events B inducing liquefaction at the beginning but not at the end of Experiment 2. Events A generally induced excess pore pressures but not liquefaction. In addition to the pore pressures, horizontal accelerations, settlement and densification, and the soil shear wave velocity, V s , were also monitored during the test. The results were compared with those of Experiment 1, reported in a previous publication, where a similar 6 m deposit of the same silty sand was subjected to a different sequence of shakings A and B which did not include any Event C. Conclusions are drawn on the effect of the strong Events C on the deposit's response. Events A, B and C of Experiment 2 are plotted on existing V s –based liquefaction charts. The charts predict well the liquefaction response of the deposit at the beginning of Experiment 2. On the other hand, for shakings near the end of the test, the charts predict liquefaction for the Events B, which by this time have stopped liquefying the deposit due to the previous history of shakings. This result is consistent with the field evidence including the presence of a number of “false positives” in the charts for silty sand sites in the Imperial Valley of California, an area of intense seismic activity.",
    author = "Tarek Abdoun and W. El-Sekelly and R. Dobry",
    year = "2019",
    month = "7",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1016/j.soildyn.2019.03.030",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "122",
    pages = "39--52",
    journal = "Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering",
    issn = "0267-7261",
    publisher = "Elsevier BV",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Investigation of V s – based liquefaction charts using a heavily preshaken silty sand centrifuge deposit

    AU - Abdoun, Tarek

    AU - El-Sekelly, W.

    AU - Dobry, R.

    PY - 2019/7/1

    Y1 - 2019/7/1

    N2 - Preshaking by previous seismic activity can significantly affect the liquefaction resistance of saturated sands. Field evidence, cyclic laboratory testing and centrifuge modeling show that: (i) earthquake events that build up excess pore pressures short of liquefaction strengthen the soil; and (ii) liquefying earthquakes may weaken the soil. The paper presents the results of a centrifuge test (Experiment 2), where a 6 m saturated loose silty sand deposit was subjected to 52 successive base shakings. Three types of shakings were used: preshaking Events A, with a shaking duration of 5 cycles, and stronger Events B and C having a duration of 15 cycles, with Events C having the largest input accelerations. A total of 35 Events A, 9 Events B, and 8 Events C were applied at the base of the model in an alternating sequence. All Events C liquefied the deposit, with the Events B inducing liquefaction at the beginning but not at the end of Experiment 2. Events A generally induced excess pore pressures but not liquefaction. In addition to the pore pressures, horizontal accelerations, settlement and densification, and the soil shear wave velocity, V s , were also monitored during the test. The results were compared with those of Experiment 1, reported in a previous publication, where a similar 6 m deposit of the same silty sand was subjected to a different sequence of shakings A and B which did not include any Event C. Conclusions are drawn on the effect of the strong Events C on the deposit's response. Events A, B and C of Experiment 2 are plotted on existing V s –based liquefaction charts. The charts predict well the liquefaction response of the deposit at the beginning of Experiment 2. On the other hand, for shakings near the end of the test, the charts predict liquefaction for the Events B, which by this time have stopped liquefying the deposit due to the previous history of shakings. This result is consistent with the field evidence including the presence of a number of “false positives” in the charts for silty sand sites in the Imperial Valley of California, an area of intense seismic activity.

    AB - Preshaking by previous seismic activity can significantly affect the liquefaction resistance of saturated sands. Field evidence, cyclic laboratory testing and centrifuge modeling show that: (i) earthquake events that build up excess pore pressures short of liquefaction strengthen the soil; and (ii) liquefying earthquakes may weaken the soil. The paper presents the results of a centrifuge test (Experiment 2), where a 6 m saturated loose silty sand deposit was subjected to 52 successive base shakings. Three types of shakings were used: preshaking Events A, with a shaking duration of 5 cycles, and stronger Events B and C having a duration of 15 cycles, with Events C having the largest input accelerations. A total of 35 Events A, 9 Events B, and 8 Events C were applied at the base of the model in an alternating sequence. All Events C liquefied the deposit, with the Events B inducing liquefaction at the beginning but not at the end of Experiment 2. Events A generally induced excess pore pressures but not liquefaction. In addition to the pore pressures, horizontal accelerations, settlement and densification, and the soil shear wave velocity, V s , were also monitored during the test. The results were compared with those of Experiment 1, reported in a previous publication, where a similar 6 m deposit of the same silty sand was subjected to a different sequence of shakings A and B which did not include any Event C. Conclusions are drawn on the effect of the strong Events C on the deposit's response. Events A, B and C of Experiment 2 are plotted on existing V s –based liquefaction charts. The charts predict well the liquefaction response of the deposit at the beginning of Experiment 2. On the other hand, for shakings near the end of the test, the charts predict liquefaction for the Events B, which by this time have stopped liquefying the deposit due to the previous history of shakings. This result is consistent with the field evidence including the presence of a number of “false positives” in the charts for silty sand sites in the Imperial Valley of California, an area of intense seismic activity.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063992543&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85063992543&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.soildyn.2019.03.030

    DO - 10.1016/j.soildyn.2019.03.030

    M3 - Article

    VL - 122

    SP - 39

    EP - 52

    JO - Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering

    JF - Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering

    SN - 0267-7261

    ER -