Independence is elusive

Set size effects on encoding precision in visual search

Helga Mazyar, Ronald van den Berg, Robert L. Seilheimer, Wei Ji Ma

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Looking for a target in a visual scene becomes more difficult as the number of stimuli increases. In a signal detection theory view, this is due to the cumulative effect of noise in the encoding of the distractors, and potentially on top of that, to an increase of the noise (i.e., a decrease of precision) per stimulus with set size, reflecting divided attention. It has long been argued that human visual search behavior can be accounted for by the first factor alone. While such an account seems to be adequate for search tasks in which all distractors have the same, known feature value (i.e., are maximally predictable), we recently found a clear effect of set size on encoding precision when distractors are drawn from a uniform distribution (i.e., when they are maximally unpredictable). Here we interpolate between these two extreme cases to examine which of both conclusions holds more generally as distractor statistics are varied. In one experiment, we vary the level of distractor heterogeneity; in another we dissociate distractor homogeneity from predictability. In all conditions in both experiments, we found a strong decrease of precision with increasing set size, suggesting that precision being independent of set size is the exception rather than the rule.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number8
JournalJournal of vision
Volume13
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Noise
Psychological Signal Detection

Keywords

  • Bayesian inference
  • Capacity limitations
  • Precision
  • Visual attention
  • Visual search

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ophthalmology
  • Sensory Systems

Cite this

Independence is elusive : Set size effects on encoding precision in visual search. / Mazyar, Helga; van den Berg, Ronald; Seilheimer, Robert L.; Ma, Wei Ji.

In: Journal of vision, Vol. 13, No. 5, 8, 2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Mazyar, Helga ; van den Berg, Ronald ; Seilheimer, Robert L. ; Ma, Wei Ji. / Independence is elusive : Set size effects on encoding precision in visual search. In: Journal of vision. 2013 ; Vol. 13, No. 5.
@article{347ccffa591e4077a573219c4c08ae52,
title = "Independence is elusive: Set size effects on encoding precision in visual search",
abstract = "Looking for a target in a visual scene becomes more difficult as the number of stimuli increases. In a signal detection theory view, this is due to the cumulative effect of noise in the encoding of the distractors, and potentially on top of that, to an increase of the noise (i.e., a decrease of precision) per stimulus with set size, reflecting divided attention. It has long been argued that human visual search behavior can be accounted for by the first factor alone. While such an account seems to be adequate for search tasks in which all distractors have the same, known feature value (i.e., are maximally predictable), we recently found a clear effect of set size on encoding precision when distractors are drawn from a uniform distribution (i.e., when they are maximally unpredictable). Here we interpolate between these two extreme cases to examine which of both conclusions holds more generally as distractor statistics are varied. In one experiment, we vary the level of distractor heterogeneity; in another we dissociate distractor homogeneity from predictability. In all conditions in both experiments, we found a strong decrease of precision with increasing set size, suggesting that precision being independent of set size is the exception rather than the rule.",
keywords = "Bayesian inference, Capacity limitations, Precision, Visual attention, Visual search",
author = "Helga Mazyar and {van den Berg}, Ronald and Seilheimer, {Robert L.} and Ma, {Wei Ji}",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1167/13.5.8",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "13",
journal = "Journal of vision",
issn = "1534-7362",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Independence is elusive

T2 - Set size effects on encoding precision in visual search

AU - Mazyar, Helga

AU - van den Berg, Ronald

AU - Seilheimer, Robert L.

AU - Ma, Wei Ji

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Looking for a target in a visual scene becomes more difficult as the number of stimuli increases. In a signal detection theory view, this is due to the cumulative effect of noise in the encoding of the distractors, and potentially on top of that, to an increase of the noise (i.e., a decrease of precision) per stimulus with set size, reflecting divided attention. It has long been argued that human visual search behavior can be accounted for by the first factor alone. While such an account seems to be adequate for search tasks in which all distractors have the same, known feature value (i.e., are maximally predictable), we recently found a clear effect of set size on encoding precision when distractors are drawn from a uniform distribution (i.e., when they are maximally unpredictable). Here we interpolate between these two extreme cases to examine which of both conclusions holds more generally as distractor statistics are varied. In one experiment, we vary the level of distractor heterogeneity; in another we dissociate distractor homogeneity from predictability. In all conditions in both experiments, we found a strong decrease of precision with increasing set size, suggesting that precision being independent of set size is the exception rather than the rule.

AB - Looking for a target in a visual scene becomes more difficult as the number of stimuli increases. In a signal detection theory view, this is due to the cumulative effect of noise in the encoding of the distractors, and potentially on top of that, to an increase of the noise (i.e., a decrease of precision) per stimulus with set size, reflecting divided attention. It has long been argued that human visual search behavior can be accounted for by the first factor alone. While such an account seems to be adequate for search tasks in which all distractors have the same, known feature value (i.e., are maximally predictable), we recently found a clear effect of set size on encoding precision when distractors are drawn from a uniform distribution (i.e., when they are maximally unpredictable). Here we interpolate between these two extreme cases to examine which of both conclusions holds more generally as distractor statistics are varied. In one experiment, we vary the level of distractor heterogeneity; in another we dissociate distractor homogeneity from predictability. In all conditions in both experiments, we found a strong decrease of precision with increasing set size, suggesting that precision being independent of set size is the exception rather than the rule.

KW - Bayesian inference

KW - Capacity limitations

KW - Precision

KW - Visual attention

KW - Visual search

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84878369662&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84878369662&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1167/13.5.8

DO - 10.1167/13.5.8

M3 - Article

VL - 13

JO - Journal of vision

JF - Journal of vision

SN - 1534-7362

IS - 5

M1 - 8

ER -