Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design

Fabio C. Lorenzoni, Leandro M. Martins, Nelson R F A Silva, Paulo Coelho, Petra C. Guess, Estevam A. Bonfante, Van P. Thompson, Gerson Bonfante

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objectives: To evaluate the effect of framework design on the fatigue life and failure modes of metal ceramic (MC, Ni-Cr alloy core, VMK 95 porcelain veneer), glass-infiltrated alumina (ICA, In-Ceram Alumina/VM7), and veneered yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystals (Y-TZP, IPSe.max ZirCAD/IPS e.max,) crowns. Methods: Sixty composite resin tooth replicas of a prepared maxillary first molar were produced to receive crowns systems of a standard (MCs, ICAs, and Y-TZPs, n = 10 each) or a modified framework design (MCm, ICAm, and Y-TZPm, n = 10 each). Fatigue loading was delivered with a spherical steel indenter (3.18 mm radius) on the center of the occlusal surface using r-ratio fatigue (30-300 N) until completion of 106 cycles or failure. Fatigue was interrupted every 125,000 cycles for damage evaluation. Weibull distribution fits and contour plots were used for examining differences between groups. Failure mode was evaluated by light polarized and SEM microscopy. Results: Weibull analysis showed the highest fatigue life for MC crowns regardless of framework design. No significant difference (confidence bound overlaps) was observed between ICA and Y-TZP with or without framework design modification. Y-TZPm crowns presented fatigue life in the range of MC crowns. No porcelain veneer fracture was observed in the MC groups, whereas ICAs presented bulk fracture and ICAm failed mainly through the veneer. Y-TZP crowns failed through chipping within the veneer, without core fractures. Conclusions: Framework design modification did not improve the fatigue life of the crown systems investigated. Y-TZPm crowns showed comparable fatigue life to MC groups. Failure mode varied according to crown system.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)626-634
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Dentistry
Volume38
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 2010

Fingerprint

Crowns
Fatigue
Dental Porcelain
Polarization Microscopy
Aluminum Oxide
Composite Resins
Steel
Ceramics
Glass
Tooth
Metals

Keywords

  • All-ceramic
  • Crown
  • Fatigue life
  • Framework design
  • Glass-infiltrated
  • Metal ceramic
  • Y-TZP

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dentistry(all)
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Lorenzoni, F. C., Martins, L. M., Silva, N. R. F. A., Coelho, P., Guess, P. C., Bonfante, E. A., ... Bonfante, G. (2010). Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design. Journal of Dentistry, 38(8), 626-634. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2010.04.011

Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design. / Lorenzoni, Fabio C.; Martins, Leandro M.; Silva, Nelson R F A; Coelho, Paulo; Guess, Petra C.; Bonfante, Estevam A.; Thompson, Van P.; Bonfante, Gerson.

In: Journal of Dentistry, Vol. 38, No. 8, 08.2010, p. 626-634.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lorenzoni, FC, Martins, LM, Silva, NRFA, Coelho, P, Guess, PC, Bonfante, EA, Thompson, VP & Bonfante, G 2010, 'Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design', Journal of Dentistry, vol. 38, no. 8, pp. 626-634. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2010.04.011
Lorenzoni, Fabio C. ; Martins, Leandro M. ; Silva, Nelson R F A ; Coelho, Paulo ; Guess, Petra C. ; Bonfante, Estevam A. ; Thompson, Van P. ; Bonfante, Gerson. / Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design. In: Journal of Dentistry. 2010 ; Vol. 38, No. 8. pp. 626-634.
@article{b06be96d86084493814a07b1a776d7c6,
title = "Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design",
abstract = "Objectives: To evaluate the effect of framework design on the fatigue life and failure modes of metal ceramic (MC, Ni-Cr alloy core, VMK 95 porcelain veneer), glass-infiltrated alumina (ICA, In-Ceram Alumina/VM7), and veneered yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystals (Y-TZP, IPSe.max ZirCAD/IPS e.max,) crowns. Methods: Sixty composite resin tooth replicas of a prepared maxillary first molar were produced to receive crowns systems of a standard (MCs, ICAs, and Y-TZPs, n = 10 each) or a modified framework design (MCm, ICAm, and Y-TZPm, n = 10 each). Fatigue loading was delivered with a spherical steel indenter (3.18 mm radius) on the center of the occlusal surface using r-ratio fatigue (30-300 N) until completion of 106 cycles or failure. Fatigue was interrupted every 125,000 cycles for damage evaluation. Weibull distribution fits and contour plots were used for examining differences between groups. Failure mode was evaluated by light polarized and SEM microscopy. Results: Weibull analysis showed the highest fatigue life for MC crowns regardless of framework design. No significant difference (confidence bound overlaps) was observed between ICA and Y-TZP with or without framework design modification. Y-TZPm crowns presented fatigue life in the range of MC crowns. No porcelain veneer fracture was observed in the MC groups, whereas ICAs presented bulk fracture and ICAm failed mainly through the veneer. Y-TZP crowns failed through chipping within the veneer, without core fractures. Conclusions: Framework design modification did not improve the fatigue life of the crown systems investigated. Y-TZPm crowns showed comparable fatigue life to MC groups. Failure mode varied according to crown system.",
keywords = "All-ceramic, Crown, Fatigue life, Framework design, Glass-infiltrated, Metal ceramic, Y-TZP",
author = "Lorenzoni, {Fabio C.} and Martins, {Leandro M.} and Silva, {Nelson R F A} and Paulo Coelho and Guess, {Petra C.} and Bonfante, {Estevam A.} and Thompson, {Van P.} and Gerson Bonfante",
year = "2010",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1016/j.jdent.2010.04.011",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "38",
pages = "626--634",
journal = "Journal of Dentistry",
issn = "0300-5712",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Fatigue life and failure modes of crowns systems with a modified framework design

AU - Lorenzoni, Fabio C.

AU - Martins, Leandro M.

AU - Silva, Nelson R F A

AU - Coelho, Paulo

AU - Guess, Petra C.

AU - Bonfante, Estevam A.

AU - Thompson, Van P.

AU - Bonfante, Gerson

PY - 2010/8

Y1 - 2010/8

N2 - Objectives: To evaluate the effect of framework design on the fatigue life and failure modes of metal ceramic (MC, Ni-Cr alloy core, VMK 95 porcelain veneer), glass-infiltrated alumina (ICA, In-Ceram Alumina/VM7), and veneered yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystals (Y-TZP, IPSe.max ZirCAD/IPS e.max,) crowns. Methods: Sixty composite resin tooth replicas of a prepared maxillary first molar were produced to receive crowns systems of a standard (MCs, ICAs, and Y-TZPs, n = 10 each) or a modified framework design (MCm, ICAm, and Y-TZPm, n = 10 each). Fatigue loading was delivered with a spherical steel indenter (3.18 mm radius) on the center of the occlusal surface using r-ratio fatigue (30-300 N) until completion of 106 cycles or failure. Fatigue was interrupted every 125,000 cycles for damage evaluation. Weibull distribution fits and contour plots were used for examining differences between groups. Failure mode was evaluated by light polarized and SEM microscopy. Results: Weibull analysis showed the highest fatigue life for MC crowns regardless of framework design. No significant difference (confidence bound overlaps) was observed between ICA and Y-TZP with or without framework design modification. Y-TZPm crowns presented fatigue life in the range of MC crowns. No porcelain veneer fracture was observed in the MC groups, whereas ICAs presented bulk fracture and ICAm failed mainly through the veneer. Y-TZP crowns failed through chipping within the veneer, without core fractures. Conclusions: Framework design modification did not improve the fatigue life of the crown systems investigated. Y-TZPm crowns showed comparable fatigue life to MC groups. Failure mode varied according to crown system.

AB - Objectives: To evaluate the effect of framework design on the fatigue life and failure modes of metal ceramic (MC, Ni-Cr alloy core, VMK 95 porcelain veneer), glass-infiltrated alumina (ICA, In-Ceram Alumina/VM7), and veneered yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystals (Y-TZP, IPSe.max ZirCAD/IPS e.max,) crowns. Methods: Sixty composite resin tooth replicas of a prepared maxillary first molar were produced to receive crowns systems of a standard (MCs, ICAs, and Y-TZPs, n = 10 each) or a modified framework design (MCm, ICAm, and Y-TZPm, n = 10 each). Fatigue loading was delivered with a spherical steel indenter (3.18 mm radius) on the center of the occlusal surface using r-ratio fatigue (30-300 N) until completion of 106 cycles or failure. Fatigue was interrupted every 125,000 cycles for damage evaluation. Weibull distribution fits and contour plots were used for examining differences between groups. Failure mode was evaluated by light polarized and SEM microscopy. Results: Weibull analysis showed the highest fatigue life for MC crowns regardless of framework design. No significant difference (confidence bound overlaps) was observed between ICA and Y-TZP with or without framework design modification. Y-TZPm crowns presented fatigue life in the range of MC crowns. No porcelain veneer fracture was observed in the MC groups, whereas ICAs presented bulk fracture and ICAm failed mainly through the veneer. Y-TZP crowns failed through chipping within the veneer, without core fractures. Conclusions: Framework design modification did not improve the fatigue life of the crown systems investigated. Y-TZPm crowns showed comparable fatigue life to MC groups. Failure mode varied according to crown system.

KW - All-ceramic

KW - Crown

KW - Fatigue life

KW - Framework design

KW - Glass-infiltrated

KW - Metal ceramic

KW - Y-TZP

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77953702890&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77953702890&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jdent.2010.04.011

DO - 10.1016/j.jdent.2010.04.011

M3 - Article

VL - 38

SP - 626

EP - 634

JO - Journal of Dentistry

JF - Journal of Dentistry

SN - 0300-5712

IS - 8

ER -