Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946

Translated title of the contribution: Empire, rights, and citizenship, 212 to 1946

Jane Burbank, Frederick Cooper

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    In 1946, when France's Assemblée Nationale Constituante was debating articles on France's overseas empire for a new constitution, a deputy cited a precedent: in 212 the Roman Emperor Caracalla extended Roman citizenship to all male, non-slave subjects of the empire. The example, it was argued, showed that people could be citizens of an empire without giving up 'local civilizations'. This article explores different meanings of citizenship and rights in empires, emphasizing two different models - Roman and a Eurasian one - and focusing on the contrasting examples of imperial Russia, the USSR, and 20 th century France. The discussion moves beyond the common association of citizenship with the nation-state and rights with democracy. Building and sustaining an empire, we argue, entailed balancing the incorporation of diverse people into a political unit and the maintenance of distinction and hierarchy. That a 20 th century republic could look to a classical precedent suggests the continued importance of imperial imaginaries and structures; the polity was not characterized by a binary distinction between a core and a subordinate periphery but rather was a multiplex combination of different territories and people that could be governed differently. The article calls for recognition of the wide range of ways in which political belonging, cultural difference, and rights can be analyzed, envisioned, and understood.

    Original languageFrench
    JournalAnnales
    Volume63
    Issue number3
    StatePublished - 2008

    Fingerprint

    citizenship
    France
    cultural difference
    civilization
    overseas
    nation state
    USSR
    republic
    constitution
    Russia
    democracy
    citizen
    Citizenship

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • History
    • Social Sciences(all)

    Cite this

    Burbank, J., & Cooper, F. (2008). Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946. Annales, 63(3).

    Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946. / Burbank, Jane; Cooper, Frederick.

    In: Annales, Vol. 63, No. 3, 2008.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Burbank, J & Cooper, F 2008, 'Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946', Annales, vol. 63, no. 3.
    Burbank J, Cooper F. Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946. Annales. 2008;63(3).
    Burbank, Jane ; Cooper, Frederick. / Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946. In: Annales. 2008 ; Vol. 63, No. 3.
    @article{774e7d31f2d74a1b9107d3e003f5b500,
    title = "Empire, droits et citoyennet{\'e}, de 212 {\`a} 1946",
    abstract = "In 1946, when France's Assembl{\'e}e Nationale Constituante was debating articles on France's overseas empire for a new constitution, a deputy cited a precedent: in 212 the Roman Emperor Caracalla extended Roman citizenship to all male, non-slave subjects of the empire. The example, it was argued, showed that people could be citizens of an empire without giving up 'local civilizations'. This article explores different meanings of citizenship and rights in empires, emphasizing two different models - Roman and a Eurasian one - and focusing on the contrasting examples of imperial Russia, the USSR, and 20 th century France. The discussion moves beyond the common association of citizenship with the nation-state and rights with democracy. Building and sustaining an empire, we argue, entailed balancing the incorporation of diverse people into a political unit and the maintenance of distinction and hierarchy. That a 20 th century republic could look to a classical precedent suggests the continued importance of imperial imaginaries and structures; the polity was not characterized by a binary distinction between a core and a subordinate periphery but rather was a multiplex combination of different territories and people that could be governed differently. The article calls for recognition of the wide range of ways in which political belonging, cultural difference, and rights can be analyzed, envisioned, and understood.",
    author = "Jane Burbank and Frederick Cooper",
    year = "2008",
    language = "French",
    volume = "63",
    journal = "Annales: Economies, Societies, Civilsations",
    issn = "0395-2649",
    publisher = "Armand Colin Paris",
    number = "3",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Empire, droits et citoyenneté, de 212 à 1946

    AU - Burbank, Jane

    AU - Cooper, Frederick

    PY - 2008

    Y1 - 2008

    N2 - In 1946, when France's Assemblée Nationale Constituante was debating articles on France's overseas empire for a new constitution, a deputy cited a precedent: in 212 the Roman Emperor Caracalla extended Roman citizenship to all male, non-slave subjects of the empire. The example, it was argued, showed that people could be citizens of an empire without giving up 'local civilizations'. This article explores different meanings of citizenship and rights in empires, emphasizing two different models - Roman and a Eurasian one - and focusing on the contrasting examples of imperial Russia, the USSR, and 20 th century France. The discussion moves beyond the common association of citizenship with the nation-state and rights with democracy. Building and sustaining an empire, we argue, entailed balancing the incorporation of diverse people into a political unit and the maintenance of distinction and hierarchy. That a 20 th century republic could look to a classical precedent suggests the continued importance of imperial imaginaries and structures; the polity was not characterized by a binary distinction between a core and a subordinate periphery but rather was a multiplex combination of different territories and people that could be governed differently. The article calls for recognition of the wide range of ways in which political belonging, cultural difference, and rights can be analyzed, envisioned, and understood.

    AB - In 1946, when France's Assemblée Nationale Constituante was debating articles on France's overseas empire for a new constitution, a deputy cited a precedent: in 212 the Roman Emperor Caracalla extended Roman citizenship to all male, non-slave subjects of the empire. The example, it was argued, showed that people could be citizens of an empire without giving up 'local civilizations'. This article explores different meanings of citizenship and rights in empires, emphasizing two different models - Roman and a Eurasian one - and focusing on the contrasting examples of imperial Russia, the USSR, and 20 th century France. The discussion moves beyond the common association of citizenship with the nation-state and rights with democracy. Building and sustaining an empire, we argue, entailed balancing the incorporation of diverse people into a political unit and the maintenance of distinction and hierarchy. That a 20 th century republic could look to a classical precedent suggests the continued importance of imperial imaginaries and structures; the polity was not characterized by a binary distinction between a core and a subordinate periphery but rather was a multiplex combination of different territories and people that could be governed differently. The article calls for recognition of the wide range of ways in which political belonging, cultural difference, and rights can be analyzed, envisioned, and understood.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=60950168765&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=60950168765&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    M3 - Article

    VL - 63

    JO - Annales: Economies, Societies, Civilsations

    JF - Annales: Economies, Societies, Civilsations

    SN - 0395-2649

    IS - 3

    ER -