Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing

Chao Liu, Robert Carrera, Vittoria Flamini, Lena Kenny, Pamela Cabahug-Zuckerman, Benson M. George, Daniel Hunter, Bo Liu, Gurpreet Singh, Philipp Leucht, Kenneth A. Mann, Jill A. Helms, Alesha Castillo

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Mechanical loading is an important aspect of post-surgical fracture care. The timing of load application relative to the injury event may differentially regulate repair depending on the stage of healing. Here, we used a novel mechanobiological model of cortical defect repair that offers several advantages including its technical simplicity and spatially confined repair program, making effects of both physical and biological interventions more easily assessed. Using this model, we showed that daily loading (5 N peak load, 2 Hz, 60 cycles, 4 consecutive days) during hematoma consolidation and inflammation disrupted the injury site and activated cartilage formation on the periosteal surface adjacent to the defect. We also showed that daily loading during the matrix deposition phase enhanced both bone and cartilage formation at the defect site, while loading during the remodeling phase resulted in an enlarged woven bone regenerate. All loading regimens resulted in abundant cellular proliferation throughout the regenerate and fibrous tissue formation directly above the defect demonstrating that all phases of cortical defect healing are sensitive to physical stimulation. Stress was concentrated at the edges of the defect during exogenous loading, and finite element (FE)-modeled longitudinal strain (εzz) values along the anterior and posterior borders of the defect (~ 2200 με) was an order of magnitude larger than strain values on the proximal and distal borders (~ 50–100 με). It is concluded that loading during the early stages of repair may impede stabilization of the injury site important for early bone matrix deposition, whereas loading while matrix deposition and remodeling are ongoing may enhance stabilization through the formation of additional cartilage and bone.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)145-155
Number of pages11
JournalBone
Volume108
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2018

Fingerprint

Cartilage
Bone and Bones
Wounds and Injuries
Physical Stimulation
Bone Matrix
Osteogenesis
Hematoma
Cell Proliferation
Inflammation

Keywords

  • Bone repair
  • Cortical defect
  • Mechanical loading
  • Mechanobiology
  • Mouse tibia

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Endocrinology, Diabetes and Metabolism
  • Physiology
  • Histology

Cite this

Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing. / Liu, Chao; Carrera, Robert; Flamini, Vittoria; Kenny, Lena; Cabahug-Zuckerman, Pamela; George, Benson M.; Hunter, Daniel; Liu, Bo; Singh, Gurpreet; Leucht, Philipp; Mann, Kenneth A.; Helms, Jill A.; Castillo, Alesha.

In: Bone, Vol. 108, 01.03.2018, p. 145-155.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Liu, C, Carrera, R, Flamini, V, Kenny, L, Cabahug-Zuckerman, P, George, BM, Hunter, D, Liu, B, Singh, G, Leucht, P, Mann, KA, Helms, JA & Castillo, A 2018, 'Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing', Bone, vol. 108, pp. 145-155. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bone.2017.12.027
Liu C, Carrera R, Flamini V, Kenny L, Cabahug-Zuckerman P, George BM et al. Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing. Bone. 2018 Mar 1;108:145-155. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bone.2017.12.027
Liu, Chao ; Carrera, Robert ; Flamini, Vittoria ; Kenny, Lena ; Cabahug-Zuckerman, Pamela ; George, Benson M. ; Hunter, Daniel ; Liu, Bo ; Singh, Gurpreet ; Leucht, Philipp ; Mann, Kenneth A. ; Helms, Jill A. ; Castillo, Alesha. / Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing. In: Bone. 2018 ; Vol. 108. pp. 145-155.
@article{2213ef25969d418ba194cc5f5be8827f,
title = "Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing",
abstract = "Mechanical loading is an important aspect of post-surgical fracture care. The timing of load application relative to the injury event may differentially regulate repair depending on the stage of healing. Here, we used a novel mechanobiological model of cortical defect repair that offers several advantages including its technical simplicity and spatially confined repair program, making effects of both physical and biological interventions more easily assessed. Using this model, we showed that daily loading (5 N peak load, 2 Hz, 60 cycles, 4 consecutive days) during hematoma consolidation and inflammation disrupted the injury site and activated cartilage formation on the periosteal surface adjacent to the defect. We also showed that daily loading during the matrix deposition phase enhanced both bone and cartilage formation at the defect site, while loading during the remodeling phase resulted in an enlarged woven bone regenerate. All loading regimens resulted in abundant cellular proliferation throughout the regenerate and fibrous tissue formation directly above the defect demonstrating that all phases of cortical defect healing are sensitive to physical stimulation. Stress was concentrated at the edges of the defect during exogenous loading, and finite element (FE)-modeled longitudinal strain (εzz) values along the anterior and posterior borders of the defect (~ 2200 με) was an order of magnitude larger than strain values on the proximal and distal borders (~ 50–100 με). It is concluded that loading during the early stages of repair may impede stabilization of the injury site important for early bone matrix deposition, whereas loading while matrix deposition and remodeling are ongoing may enhance stabilization through the formation of additional cartilage and bone.",
keywords = "Bone repair, Cortical defect, Mechanical loading, Mechanobiology, Mouse tibia",
author = "Chao Liu and Robert Carrera and Vittoria Flamini and Lena Kenny and Pamela Cabahug-Zuckerman and George, {Benson M.} and Daniel Hunter and Bo Liu and Gurpreet Singh and Philipp Leucht and Mann, {Kenneth A.} and Helms, {Jill A.} and Alesha Castillo",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.bone.2017.12.027",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "108",
pages = "145--155",
journal = "Bone",
issn = "8756-3282",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of mechanical loading on cortical defect repair using a novel mechanobiological model of bone healing

AU - Liu, Chao

AU - Carrera, Robert

AU - Flamini, Vittoria

AU - Kenny, Lena

AU - Cabahug-Zuckerman, Pamela

AU - George, Benson M.

AU - Hunter, Daniel

AU - Liu, Bo

AU - Singh, Gurpreet

AU - Leucht, Philipp

AU - Mann, Kenneth A.

AU - Helms, Jill A.

AU - Castillo, Alesha

PY - 2018/3/1

Y1 - 2018/3/1

N2 - Mechanical loading is an important aspect of post-surgical fracture care. The timing of load application relative to the injury event may differentially regulate repair depending on the stage of healing. Here, we used a novel mechanobiological model of cortical defect repair that offers several advantages including its technical simplicity and spatially confined repair program, making effects of both physical and biological interventions more easily assessed. Using this model, we showed that daily loading (5 N peak load, 2 Hz, 60 cycles, 4 consecutive days) during hematoma consolidation and inflammation disrupted the injury site and activated cartilage formation on the periosteal surface adjacent to the defect. We also showed that daily loading during the matrix deposition phase enhanced both bone and cartilage formation at the defect site, while loading during the remodeling phase resulted in an enlarged woven bone regenerate. All loading regimens resulted in abundant cellular proliferation throughout the regenerate and fibrous tissue formation directly above the defect demonstrating that all phases of cortical defect healing are sensitive to physical stimulation. Stress was concentrated at the edges of the defect during exogenous loading, and finite element (FE)-modeled longitudinal strain (εzz) values along the anterior and posterior borders of the defect (~ 2200 με) was an order of magnitude larger than strain values on the proximal and distal borders (~ 50–100 με). It is concluded that loading during the early stages of repair may impede stabilization of the injury site important for early bone matrix deposition, whereas loading while matrix deposition and remodeling are ongoing may enhance stabilization through the formation of additional cartilage and bone.

AB - Mechanical loading is an important aspect of post-surgical fracture care. The timing of load application relative to the injury event may differentially regulate repair depending on the stage of healing. Here, we used a novel mechanobiological model of cortical defect repair that offers several advantages including its technical simplicity and spatially confined repair program, making effects of both physical and biological interventions more easily assessed. Using this model, we showed that daily loading (5 N peak load, 2 Hz, 60 cycles, 4 consecutive days) during hematoma consolidation and inflammation disrupted the injury site and activated cartilage formation on the periosteal surface adjacent to the defect. We also showed that daily loading during the matrix deposition phase enhanced both bone and cartilage formation at the defect site, while loading during the remodeling phase resulted in an enlarged woven bone regenerate. All loading regimens resulted in abundant cellular proliferation throughout the regenerate and fibrous tissue formation directly above the defect demonstrating that all phases of cortical defect healing are sensitive to physical stimulation. Stress was concentrated at the edges of the defect during exogenous loading, and finite element (FE)-modeled longitudinal strain (εzz) values along the anterior and posterior borders of the defect (~ 2200 με) was an order of magnitude larger than strain values on the proximal and distal borders (~ 50–100 με). It is concluded that loading during the early stages of repair may impede stabilization of the injury site important for early bone matrix deposition, whereas loading while matrix deposition and remodeling are ongoing may enhance stabilization through the formation of additional cartilage and bone.

KW - Bone repair

KW - Cortical defect

KW - Mechanical loading

KW - Mechanobiology

KW - Mouse tibia

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85040333391&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85040333391&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.bone.2017.12.027

DO - 10.1016/j.bone.2017.12.027

M3 - Article

C2 - 29305998

AN - SCOPUS:85040333391

VL - 108

SP - 145

EP - 155

JO - Bone

JF - Bone

SN - 8756-3282

ER -