Effectiveness of dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening, a meta-analysis

Richard Niederman, Maggie C. Tantraphol, Patricia Slinin, Catherine Hayes, Suzy Conway

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Introduction. Common clinical experience suggests that tooth whitening agents are 100% effective. This study uses meta-analysis of data from published randomized controlled clinical trials to determine the efficacy of tooth whitening agents. Methods. A MEDLINE search strategy was developed and implemented to systematically identify clinical trials on dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening agents, using 10% carbamide peroxide, published between 1989-1999. Inclusion criteria (e.g., in English, human clinical trials) and exclusion criteria (e.g., not placebo controlled) were established and clinical trials that met these criteria were critically appraised for validity and clinical applicability. Meta-analysis was then used to quantitatively integrate the findings. Results. Seven studies were identified that met the inclusion and validity criteria. These studies indicated that: Whitening results in a significant mean change of 6 4 shade guide units (p < 0.01), while the placebo control group exhibited little change (0.7 0.6, p > 0.05). 93% of the bleached patients exhibited 2 shade guide unit change, while 20% of the placebo control group exhibited this change. The brand of bleaching agent had a significant effect on tooth whitening, but the daily application time and duration of treatment did not. Whitening is maintained for 6 months for 1/2 of the people treated. Neither gingival indices nor plaque indices were adversely or favorably affected by bleaching. Clinical Applicability. The data from the reviewed studies indicate that rather than being 100% effective, on average: 73% (93% for bleached group minus 20% placebo group) of people who whiten their teeth will exhibit a whitening that is 2 shade guide units greater than the placebo. 20% of the people who use dentist-prescribed, home-applied bleaching will achieve a mean whitening effect of 5 shade guide units. Re-treatment for 50% of people may be necessary to maintain this effect longer than 6 months. The methods used here are Internet applicable for other clinical topics.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)13-28
Number of pages16
JournalThe journal of contemporary dental practice
Volume1
Issue number4
StatePublished - Sep 2000

Fingerprint

Tooth Bleaching
Tooth Bleaching Agents
Dentists
Meta-Analysis
Placebos
Clinical Trials
Bleaching Agents
Periodontal Index
MEDLINE
Internet
Randomized Controlled Trials
Control Groups
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Dental bleaching
  • Tooth bleaching
  • Tooth bleaching effectiveness
  • Tooth whitening

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dentistry(all)

Cite this

Effectiveness of dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening, a meta-analysis. / Niederman, Richard; Tantraphol, Maggie C.; Slinin, Patricia; Hayes, Catherine; Conway, Suzy.

In: The journal of contemporary dental practice, Vol. 1, No. 4, 09.2000, p. 13-28.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Niederman, Richard ; Tantraphol, Maggie C. ; Slinin, Patricia ; Hayes, Catherine ; Conway, Suzy. / Effectiveness of dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening, a meta-analysis. In: The journal of contemporary dental practice. 2000 ; Vol. 1, No. 4. pp. 13-28.
@article{f3ac066cea244b92885c5c2d73150ee8,
title = "Effectiveness of dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening, a meta-analysis",
abstract = "Introduction. Common clinical experience suggests that tooth whitening agents are 100{\%} effective. This study uses meta-analysis of data from published randomized controlled clinical trials to determine the efficacy of tooth whitening agents. Methods. A MEDLINE search strategy was developed and implemented to systematically identify clinical trials on dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening agents, using 10{\%} carbamide peroxide, published between 1989-1999. Inclusion criteria (e.g., in English, human clinical trials) and exclusion criteria (e.g., not placebo controlled) were established and clinical trials that met these criteria were critically appraised for validity and clinical applicability. Meta-analysis was then used to quantitatively integrate the findings. Results. Seven studies were identified that met the inclusion and validity criteria. These studies indicated that: Whitening results in a significant mean change of 6 4 shade guide units (p < 0.01), while the placebo control group exhibited little change (0.7 0.6, p > 0.05). 93{\%} of the bleached patients exhibited 2 shade guide unit change, while 20{\%} of the placebo control group exhibited this change. The brand of bleaching agent had a significant effect on tooth whitening, but the daily application time and duration of treatment did not. Whitening is maintained for 6 months for 1/2 of the people treated. Neither gingival indices nor plaque indices were adversely or favorably affected by bleaching. Clinical Applicability. The data from the reviewed studies indicate that rather than being 100{\%} effective, on average: 73{\%} (93{\%} for bleached group minus 20{\%} placebo group) of people who whiten their teeth will exhibit a whitening that is 2 shade guide units greater than the placebo. 20{\%} of the people who use dentist-prescribed, home-applied bleaching will achieve a mean whitening effect of 5 shade guide units. Re-treatment for 50{\%} of people may be necessary to maintain this effect longer than 6 months. The methods used here are Internet applicable for other clinical topics.",
keywords = "Dental bleaching, Tooth bleaching, Tooth bleaching effectiveness, Tooth whitening",
author = "Richard Niederman and Tantraphol, {Maggie C.} and Patricia Slinin and Catherine Hayes and Suzy Conway",
year = "2000",
month = "9",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "1",
pages = "13--28",
journal = "Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice",
issn = "1526-3711",
publisher = "Procter & Gamble Co.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effectiveness of dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening, a meta-analysis

AU - Niederman, Richard

AU - Tantraphol, Maggie C.

AU - Slinin, Patricia

AU - Hayes, Catherine

AU - Conway, Suzy

PY - 2000/9

Y1 - 2000/9

N2 - Introduction. Common clinical experience suggests that tooth whitening agents are 100% effective. This study uses meta-analysis of data from published randomized controlled clinical trials to determine the efficacy of tooth whitening agents. Methods. A MEDLINE search strategy was developed and implemented to systematically identify clinical trials on dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening agents, using 10% carbamide peroxide, published between 1989-1999. Inclusion criteria (e.g., in English, human clinical trials) and exclusion criteria (e.g., not placebo controlled) were established and clinical trials that met these criteria were critically appraised for validity and clinical applicability. Meta-analysis was then used to quantitatively integrate the findings. Results. Seven studies were identified that met the inclusion and validity criteria. These studies indicated that: Whitening results in a significant mean change of 6 4 shade guide units (p < 0.01), while the placebo control group exhibited little change (0.7 0.6, p > 0.05). 93% of the bleached patients exhibited 2 shade guide unit change, while 20% of the placebo control group exhibited this change. The brand of bleaching agent had a significant effect on tooth whitening, but the daily application time and duration of treatment did not. Whitening is maintained for 6 months for 1/2 of the people treated. Neither gingival indices nor plaque indices were adversely or favorably affected by bleaching. Clinical Applicability. The data from the reviewed studies indicate that rather than being 100% effective, on average: 73% (93% for bleached group minus 20% placebo group) of people who whiten their teeth will exhibit a whitening that is 2 shade guide units greater than the placebo. 20% of the people who use dentist-prescribed, home-applied bleaching will achieve a mean whitening effect of 5 shade guide units. Re-treatment for 50% of people may be necessary to maintain this effect longer than 6 months. The methods used here are Internet applicable for other clinical topics.

AB - Introduction. Common clinical experience suggests that tooth whitening agents are 100% effective. This study uses meta-analysis of data from published randomized controlled clinical trials to determine the efficacy of tooth whitening agents. Methods. A MEDLINE search strategy was developed and implemented to systematically identify clinical trials on dentist-prescribed, home-applied tooth whitening agents, using 10% carbamide peroxide, published between 1989-1999. Inclusion criteria (e.g., in English, human clinical trials) and exclusion criteria (e.g., not placebo controlled) were established and clinical trials that met these criteria were critically appraised for validity and clinical applicability. Meta-analysis was then used to quantitatively integrate the findings. Results. Seven studies were identified that met the inclusion and validity criteria. These studies indicated that: Whitening results in a significant mean change of 6 4 shade guide units (p < 0.01), while the placebo control group exhibited little change (0.7 0.6, p > 0.05). 93% of the bleached patients exhibited 2 shade guide unit change, while 20% of the placebo control group exhibited this change. The brand of bleaching agent had a significant effect on tooth whitening, but the daily application time and duration of treatment did not. Whitening is maintained for 6 months for 1/2 of the people treated. Neither gingival indices nor plaque indices were adversely or favorably affected by bleaching. Clinical Applicability. The data from the reviewed studies indicate that rather than being 100% effective, on average: 73% (93% for bleached group minus 20% placebo group) of people who whiten their teeth will exhibit a whitening that is 2 shade guide units greater than the placebo. 20% of the people who use dentist-prescribed, home-applied bleaching will achieve a mean whitening effect of 5 shade guide units. Re-treatment for 50% of people may be necessary to maintain this effect longer than 6 months. The methods used here are Internet applicable for other clinical topics.

KW - Dental bleaching

KW - Tooth bleaching

KW - Tooth bleaching effectiveness

KW - Tooth whitening

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=3242710422&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=3242710422&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 12167948

AN - SCOPUS:3242710422

VL - 1

SP - 13

EP - 28

JO - Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice

JF - Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice

SN - 1526-3711

IS - 4

ER -