Dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions selected to receive operative treatment

Findings from the Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network

Maryann Lehmann, Analia Veitz-Keenan, Abigail G. Matthews, Donald Vena, Ashley Grill, Ronald Craig, Frederick A. Curro, Van P. Thompson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Members of the practice-based research network Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network investigated the dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions and its relationship to patient age, preoperative tooth sensitivity and radiographic appearance, as well as its influence on preparation depth and volume. Methods: PEARL Network practitioner-investigators (P-Is) (n = 45), general dentists who were trained but whose methods were not calibrated, conducted a study regarding postoperative hypersensitivity in resin-based composite restorations. The P-Is enrolled as study participants 613 patients with occlusal carious lesions that, in the P-Is' clinical judgment, required restoration. The P-Is used baseline radiographs to assess the depth and extent of the lesions. Data for 671 restorations included baseline sensitivity; ranking of dentin caries activity on the opening of the enamel; radiographic visibility (n = 652); and measurements of preparation depth, width and length. Results: P-Is found rapidly progressing dentin caries in 38.5 percent (258 of 671) of lesions and slowly progressing (and potentially inactive dentin) caries in the remainder of the lesions. Rapidly progressing caries was not related to the participant's age or participantreported preoperative hypersensitivity but was related to the lesion depth as seen radiographically (P <.001) and depth (P <.001) and volume (P <.001) of the preparation. Molars had slightly higher but not statistically significant levels of caries activity. Conclusion: Rapidly progressing dentin caries, while present in only 38.5 percent of lesions, was related to the lesion's radiographic appearance but not to the participant's age or the study tooth's preoperative sensitivity. Clinical Implications: On the basis of the low level of rapidly progressing dentin caries in this study population and the fact that slowly progressing caries can be inactive or remineralizing, the authors advise sealing versus operative treatment of early or shallow occlusal lesions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)377-385
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of the American Dental Association
Volume143
Issue number4
StatePublished - Apr 2012

Fingerprint

Dentin
Learning
Research Personnel
Dentin Sensitivity
Research
Hypersensitivity
Therapeutics
Composite Resins
Dental Enamel
Dentists
Population

Keywords

  • Dentin caries
  • Hypersensitivity
  • Occlusal caries
  • Radiographic appearance
  • Resin-based composite restoration

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dentistry(all)

Cite this

Dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions selected to receive operative treatment : Findings from the Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network. / Lehmann, Maryann; Veitz-Keenan, Analia; Matthews, Abigail G.; Vena, Donald; Grill, Ashley; Craig, Ronald; Curro, Frederick A.; Thompson, Van P.

In: Journal of the American Dental Association, Vol. 143, No. 4, 04.2012, p. 377-385.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lehmann, Maryann ; Veitz-Keenan, Analia ; Matthews, Abigail G. ; Vena, Donald ; Grill, Ashley ; Craig, Ronald ; Curro, Frederick A. ; Thompson, Van P. / Dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions selected to receive operative treatment : Findings from the Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network. In: Journal of the American Dental Association. 2012 ; Vol. 143, No. 4. pp. 377-385.
@article{9cde66becd4f4ae7b4e7281be88413db,
title = "Dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions selected to receive operative treatment: Findings from the Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network",
abstract = "Background: Members of the practice-based research network Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network investigated the dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions and its relationship to patient age, preoperative tooth sensitivity and radiographic appearance, as well as its influence on preparation depth and volume. Methods: PEARL Network practitioner-investigators (P-Is) (n = 45), general dentists who were trained but whose methods were not calibrated, conducted a study regarding postoperative hypersensitivity in resin-based composite restorations. The P-Is enrolled as study participants 613 patients with occlusal carious lesions that, in the P-Is' clinical judgment, required restoration. The P-Is used baseline radiographs to assess the depth and extent of the lesions. Data for 671 restorations included baseline sensitivity; ranking of dentin caries activity on the opening of the enamel; radiographic visibility (n = 652); and measurements of preparation depth, width and length. Results: P-Is found rapidly progressing dentin caries in 38.5 percent (258 of 671) of lesions and slowly progressing (and potentially inactive dentin) caries in the remainder of the lesions. Rapidly progressing caries was not related to the participant's age or participantreported preoperative hypersensitivity but was related to the lesion depth as seen radiographically (P <.001) and depth (P <.001) and volume (P <.001) of the preparation. Molars had slightly higher but not statistically significant levels of caries activity. Conclusion: Rapidly progressing dentin caries, while present in only 38.5 percent of lesions, was related to the lesion's radiographic appearance but not to the participant's age or the study tooth's preoperative sensitivity. Clinical Implications: On the basis of the low level of rapidly progressing dentin caries in this study population and the fact that slowly progressing caries can be inactive or remineralizing, the authors advise sealing versus operative treatment of early or shallow occlusal lesions.",
keywords = "Dentin caries, Hypersensitivity, Occlusal caries, Radiographic appearance, Resin-based composite restoration",
author = "Maryann Lehmann and Analia Veitz-Keenan and Matthews, {Abigail G.} and Donald Vena and Ashley Grill and Ronald Craig and Curro, {Frederick A.} and Thompson, {Van P.}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "143",
pages = "377--385",
journal = "Journal of the American Dental Association",
issn = "0002-8177",
publisher = "American Dental Association",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions selected to receive operative treatment

T2 - Findings from the Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network

AU - Lehmann, Maryann

AU - Veitz-Keenan, Analia

AU - Matthews, Abigail G.

AU - Vena, Donald

AU - Grill, Ashley

AU - Craig, Ronald

AU - Curro, Frederick A.

AU - Thompson, Van P.

PY - 2012/4

Y1 - 2012/4

N2 - Background: Members of the practice-based research network Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network investigated the dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions and its relationship to patient age, preoperative tooth sensitivity and radiographic appearance, as well as its influence on preparation depth and volume. Methods: PEARL Network practitioner-investigators (P-Is) (n = 45), general dentists who were trained but whose methods were not calibrated, conducted a study regarding postoperative hypersensitivity in resin-based composite restorations. The P-Is enrolled as study participants 613 patients with occlusal carious lesions that, in the P-Is' clinical judgment, required restoration. The P-Is used baseline radiographs to assess the depth and extent of the lesions. Data for 671 restorations included baseline sensitivity; ranking of dentin caries activity on the opening of the enamel; radiographic visibility (n = 652); and measurements of preparation depth, width and length. Results: P-Is found rapidly progressing dentin caries in 38.5 percent (258 of 671) of lesions and slowly progressing (and potentially inactive dentin) caries in the remainder of the lesions. Rapidly progressing caries was not related to the participant's age or participantreported preoperative hypersensitivity but was related to the lesion depth as seen radiographically (P <.001) and depth (P <.001) and volume (P <.001) of the preparation. Molars had slightly higher but not statistically significant levels of caries activity. Conclusion: Rapidly progressing dentin caries, while present in only 38.5 percent of lesions, was related to the lesion's radiographic appearance but not to the participant's age or the study tooth's preoperative sensitivity. Clinical Implications: On the basis of the low level of rapidly progressing dentin caries in this study population and the fact that slowly progressing caries can be inactive or remineralizing, the authors advise sealing versus operative treatment of early or shallow occlusal lesions.

AB - Background: Members of the practice-based research network Practitioners Engaged in Applied Research and Learning (PEARL) Network investigated the dentin caries activity in early occlusal lesions and its relationship to patient age, preoperative tooth sensitivity and radiographic appearance, as well as its influence on preparation depth and volume. Methods: PEARL Network practitioner-investigators (P-Is) (n = 45), general dentists who were trained but whose methods were not calibrated, conducted a study regarding postoperative hypersensitivity in resin-based composite restorations. The P-Is enrolled as study participants 613 patients with occlusal carious lesions that, in the P-Is' clinical judgment, required restoration. The P-Is used baseline radiographs to assess the depth and extent of the lesions. Data for 671 restorations included baseline sensitivity; ranking of dentin caries activity on the opening of the enamel; radiographic visibility (n = 652); and measurements of preparation depth, width and length. Results: P-Is found rapidly progressing dentin caries in 38.5 percent (258 of 671) of lesions and slowly progressing (and potentially inactive dentin) caries in the remainder of the lesions. Rapidly progressing caries was not related to the participant's age or participantreported preoperative hypersensitivity but was related to the lesion depth as seen radiographically (P <.001) and depth (P <.001) and volume (P <.001) of the preparation. Molars had slightly higher but not statistically significant levels of caries activity. Conclusion: Rapidly progressing dentin caries, while present in only 38.5 percent of lesions, was related to the lesion's radiographic appearance but not to the participant's age or the study tooth's preoperative sensitivity. Clinical Implications: On the basis of the low level of rapidly progressing dentin caries in this study population and the fact that slowly progressing caries can be inactive or remineralizing, the authors advise sealing versus operative treatment of early or shallow occlusal lesions.

KW - Dentin caries

KW - Hypersensitivity

KW - Occlusal caries

KW - Radiographic appearance

KW - Resin-based composite restoration

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84860425078&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84860425078&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 143

SP - 377

EP - 385

JO - Journal of the American Dental Association

JF - Journal of the American Dental Association

SN - 0002-8177

IS - 4

ER -