Comparison of experienced and novice cost estimator behaviors in information pull and push methods

Semiha Ergan, Burcu Akinci, Cleotilde Gonzalez

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Construction cost estimators mainly use analogy-based decision-making processes while estimating activity production rates in new bids. They need to search information items that will help them in understanding the differences and similarities between the current and previously completed projects to select appropriate production rates and make necessary adjustments to the selected production rates. The objective of the study is to understand the effect of information pull-push methods on the behaviors of cost estimators when they refer to information items from historical sources in structuring their decisions. Eleven experienced estimators and 11 novice civil engineering candidates participated in an experiment involving card games, which simulated the information pull method, and in another experiment involving a prototype system, which simulated the information push method. Results showed that novices can behave like experienced estimators when information relevant to a decision is pushed to them. This result has implications for the design of information systems. Results show that it is possible to improve the estimates of novice estimators by providing them with decision support tools designed with the right information delivery method for their level of experience.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)290-301
Number of pages12
JournalCanadian Journal of Civil Engineering
Volume37
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 2010

Fingerprint

cost
Costs
Civil engineering
Information systems
Decision making
Experiments
civil engineering
comparison
method
information system
experiment
decision making
decision
rate

Keywords

  • Construction cost estimating
  • Expert-novice comparison
  • Historical data
  • Information push and pull
  • Menu-driven information delivery
  • Project histories

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering

Cite this

Comparison of experienced and novice cost estimator behaviors in information pull and push methods. / Ergan, Semiha; Akinci, Burcu; Gonzalez, Cleotilde.

In: Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, Vol. 37, No. 2, 02.2010, p. 290-301.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1ee1e2d843f3440f8c45f32219971e0e,
title = "Comparison of experienced and novice cost estimator behaviors in information pull and push methods",
abstract = "Construction cost estimators mainly use analogy-based decision-making processes while estimating activity production rates in new bids. They need to search information items that will help them in understanding the differences and similarities between the current and previously completed projects to select appropriate production rates and make necessary adjustments to the selected production rates. The objective of the study is to understand the effect of information pull-push methods on the behaviors of cost estimators when they refer to information items from historical sources in structuring their decisions. Eleven experienced estimators and 11 novice civil engineering candidates participated in an experiment involving card games, which simulated the information pull method, and in another experiment involving a prototype system, which simulated the information push method. Results showed that novices can behave like experienced estimators when information relevant to a decision is pushed to them. This result has implications for the design of information systems. Results show that it is possible to improve the estimates of novice estimators by providing them with decision support tools designed with the right information delivery method for their level of experience.",
keywords = "Construction cost estimating, Expert-novice comparison, Historical data, Information push and pull, Menu-driven information delivery, Project histories",
author = "Semiha Ergan and Burcu Akinci and Cleotilde Gonzalez",
year = "2010",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1139/L09-152",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "37",
pages = "290--301",
journal = "Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering",
issn = "0315-1468",
publisher = "National Research Council of Canada",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of experienced and novice cost estimator behaviors in information pull and push methods

AU - Ergan, Semiha

AU - Akinci, Burcu

AU - Gonzalez, Cleotilde

PY - 2010/2

Y1 - 2010/2

N2 - Construction cost estimators mainly use analogy-based decision-making processes while estimating activity production rates in new bids. They need to search information items that will help them in understanding the differences and similarities between the current and previously completed projects to select appropriate production rates and make necessary adjustments to the selected production rates. The objective of the study is to understand the effect of information pull-push methods on the behaviors of cost estimators when they refer to information items from historical sources in structuring their decisions. Eleven experienced estimators and 11 novice civil engineering candidates participated in an experiment involving card games, which simulated the information pull method, and in another experiment involving a prototype system, which simulated the information push method. Results showed that novices can behave like experienced estimators when information relevant to a decision is pushed to them. This result has implications for the design of information systems. Results show that it is possible to improve the estimates of novice estimators by providing them with decision support tools designed with the right information delivery method for their level of experience.

AB - Construction cost estimators mainly use analogy-based decision-making processes while estimating activity production rates in new bids. They need to search information items that will help them in understanding the differences and similarities between the current and previously completed projects to select appropriate production rates and make necessary adjustments to the selected production rates. The objective of the study is to understand the effect of information pull-push methods on the behaviors of cost estimators when they refer to information items from historical sources in structuring their decisions. Eleven experienced estimators and 11 novice civil engineering candidates participated in an experiment involving card games, which simulated the information pull method, and in another experiment involving a prototype system, which simulated the information push method. Results showed that novices can behave like experienced estimators when information relevant to a decision is pushed to them. This result has implications for the design of information systems. Results show that it is possible to improve the estimates of novice estimators by providing them with decision support tools designed with the right information delivery method for their level of experience.

KW - Construction cost estimating

KW - Expert-novice comparison

KW - Historical data

KW - Information push and pull

KW - Menu-driven information delivery

KW - Project histories

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77649147786&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77649147786&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1139/L09-152

DO - 10.1139/L09-152

M3 - Article

VL - 37

SP - 290

EP - 301

JO - Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering

JF - Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering

SN - 0315-1468

IS - 2

ER -