Cleavage-based voting behavior in cross-national perspective

Evidence from six postwar democracies

Clem Brooks, Paul Nieuwbeerta, Jeffrey Manza

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    We investigate trends and cross-national variation in the impact of class, religious, and gender cleavages on voting behavior in six advanced capitalist democracies in the postwar period. Earlier research on cleavage voting has been criticized for utilizing outdated "two-class" models of class structure, simplistic left/right party distinctions, flawed statistical approaches, and incompatible and/ or limited of cross-national empirical evidence. We take such criticisms seriously and seek to overcome them. Using multinomial logistic regression models, we analyze data from a new dataset, the International Social Cleavages and Politics (ISCP) file, which contains comparable, over-time cross-national data from 112 nationally representative election surveys of voters in six Western democracies in the period 1964-1998. The six countries examined in the paper (Australia, Austria, Germany, Great Britain, the Netherlands, and the United States) are unique because of the existence of time series data available for all three cleavages. Our analyses examine the changing magnitude of the class, religion, and gender cleavages for up to five distinct party families for each country. Unskilled workers have become less distinctive in their partisan alignments over time, but other classes have experienced offsetting changes, yielding little evidence of a universal decline in the class cleavage. Further analyses suggest an important degree of stability in the aggregated effects of all social cleavages, while also revealing significant cross-national differences and trends in the magnitude of specific cleavages. These results refine debates concerning the possible decline of social cleavages; implications for research are discussed in conclusion.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)88-128
    Number of pages41
    JournalSocial Science Research
    Volume35
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Mar 2006

    Fingerprint

    voting behavior
    democracy
    unskilled worker
    evidence
    post-war period
    gender
    trend
    Austria
    time series
    voting
    Netherlands
    criticism
    election
    logistics
    Religion
    regression
    politics
    time

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Education
    • Sociology and Political Science

    Cite this

    Cleavage-based voting behavior in cross-national perspective : Evidence from six postwar democracies. / Brooks, Clem; Nieuwbeerta, Paul; Manza, Jeffrey.

    In: Social Science Research, Vol. 35, No. 1, 03.2006, p. 88-128.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Brooks, Clem ; Nieuwbeerta, Paul ; Manza, Jeffrey. / Cleavage-based voting behavior in cross-national perspective : Evidence from six postwar democracies. In: Social Science Research. 2006 ; Vol. 35, No. 1. pp. 88-128.
    @article{2536898d78fa40858cce8b1b03a06814,
    title = "Cleavage-based voting behavior in cross-national perspective: Evidence from six postwar democracies",
    abstract = "We investigate trends and cross-national variation in the impact of class, religious, and gender cleavages on voting behavior in six advanced capitalist democracies in the postwar period. Earlier research on cleavage voting has been criticized for utilizing outdated {"}two-class{"} models of class structure, simplistic left/right party distinctions, flawed statistical approaches, and incompatible and/ or limited of cross-national empirical evidence. We take such criticisms seriously and seek to overcome them. Using multinomial logistic regression models, we analyze data from a new dataset, the International Social Cleavages and Politics (ISCP) file, which contains comparable, over-time cross-national data from 112 nationally representative election surveys of voters in six Western democracies in the period 1964-1998. The six countries examined in the paper (Australia, Austria, Germany, Great Britain, the Netherlands, and the United States) are unique because of the existence of time series data available for all three cleavages. Our analyses examine the changing magnitude of the class, religion, and gender cleavages for up to five distinct party families for each country. Unskilled workers have become less distinctive in their partisan alignments over time, but other classes have experienced offsetting changes, yielding little evidence of a universal decline in the class cleavage. Further analyses suggest an important degree of stability in the aggregated effects of all social cleavages, while also revealing significant cross-national differences and trends in the magnitude of specific cleavages. These results refine debates concerning the possible decline of social cleavages; implications for research are discussed in conclusion.",
    author = "Clem Brooks and Paul Nieuwbeerta and Jeffrey Manza",
    year = "2006",
    month = "3",
    doi = "10.1016/j.ssresearch.2004.06.005",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "35",
    pages = "88--128",
    journal = "Social Science Research",
    issn = "0049-089X",
    publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
    number = "1",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Cleavage-based voting behavior in cross-national perspective

    T2 - Evidence from six postwar democracies

    AU - Brooks, Clem

    AU - Nieuwbeerta, Paul

    AU - Manza, Jeffrey

    PY - 2006/3

    Y1 - 2006/3

    N2 - We investigate trends and cross-national variation in the impact of class, religious, and gender cleavages on voting behavior in six advanced capitalist democracies in the postwar period. Earlier research on cleavage voting has been criticized for utilizing outdated "two-class" models of class structure, simplistic left/right party distinctions, flawed statistical approaches, and incompatible and/ or limited of cross-national empirical evidence. We take such criticisms seriously and seek to overcome them. Using multinomial logistic regression models, we analyze data from a new dataset, the International Social Cleavages and Politics (ISCP) file, which contains comparable, over-time cross-national data from 112 nationally representative election surveys of voters in six Western democracies in the period 1964-1998. The six countries examined in the paper (Australia, Austria, Germany, Great Britain, the Netherlands, and the United States) are unique because of the existence of time series data available for all three cleavages. Our analyses examine the changing magnitude of the class, religion, and gender cleavages for up to five distinct party families for each country. Unskilled workers have become less distinctive in their partisan alignments over time, but other classes have experienced offsetting changes, yielding little evidence of a universal decline in the class cleavage. Further analyses suggest an important degree of stability in the aggregated effects of all social cleavages, while also revealing significant cross-national differences and trends in the magnitude of specific cleavages. These results refine debates concerning the possible decline of social cleavages; implications for research are discussed in conclusion.

    AB - We investigate trends and cross-national variation in the impact of class, religious, and gender cleavages on voting behavior in six advanced capitalist democracies in the postwar period. Earlier research on cleavage voting has been criticized for utilizing outdated "two-class" models of class structure, simplistic left/right party distinctions, flawed statistical approaches, and incompatible and/ or limited of cross-national empirical evidence. We take such criticisms seriously and seek to overcome them. Using multinomial logistic regression models, we analyze data from a new dataset, the International Social Cleavages and Politics (ISCP) file, which contains comparable, over-time cross-national data from 112 nationally representative election surveys of voters in six Western democracies in the period 1964-1998. The six countries examined in the paper (Australia, Austria, Germany, Great Britain, the Netherlands, and the United States) are unique because of the existence of time series data available for all three cleavages. Our analyses examine the changing magnitude of the class, religion, and gender cleavages for up to five distinct party families for each country. Unskilled workers have become less distinctive in their partisan alignments over time, but other classes have experienced offsetting changes, yielding little evidence of a universal decline in the class cleavage. Further analyses suggest an important degree of stability in the aggregated effects of all social cleavages, while also revealing significant cross-national differences and trends in the magnitude of specific cleavages. These results refine debates concerning the possible decline of social cleavages; implications for research are discussed in conclusion.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=28844479736&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=28844479736&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2004.06.005

    DO - 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2004.06.005

    M3 - Article

    VL - 35

    SP - 88

    EP - 128

    JO - Social Science Research

    JF - Social Science Research

    SN - 0049-089X

    IS - 1

    ER -