Citations of Norms and Lines of Flight in One Immigrant Boy's Performances of Masculinities and Reading Identities

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In this ethnographic case study, the author examined one immigrant adolescent's performances of masculinities through reading practices. The author analyzed how Omar (pseudonym), a Muslim boy from Libya, used reading practices to produce himself as a boy in one U.S. multilingual classroom. Extending the anti-essentialist scholarship on gender and reading, the author brought together Butler's queer feminism and Deleuze and Guattari's philosophy of becoming to further trouble gender and analyze the instability of Omar's masculinity performances in relation to reading practice. Through analyses of field notes, classroom interactions, and artifacts, this study showed that Omar discursively performed and negotiated multiple and seemingly conflicting reading identities across time and space. Although he was discursively positioned as a nonreader in classroom interactions, he also performed disengagement with reading to display a cool, nonschoolish masculinity aligned to the normative discourses of Arab masculinity to which he was subject. However, he also enacted reader identity and behaviors not traditionally associated with masculinity. Omar's identity negotiation, interactionally and socially situated, demonstrated the instability of masculinity performances, featuring repeated citation of gender norms fissured with lines of flight breaking away from normative ways of being. This analysis contributes to the anti-essentialist research on boys and literacies by shedding light on the regulations and ruptures in masculinity performances of a gendered subject. The study highlights the importance of situating analysis of gender and reading practices within the social and power relations in the discursive and interactional space. Addressing space allows a close reading of how gender hegemonies operate and fracture in micro movements of identity performance and how space can be shaped to open up opportunities for becoming-other.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalReading Research Quarterly
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Masculinity
masculinity
flight
Reading
immigrant
performance
gender
classroom
Anonyms and Pseudonyms
Libya
Feminism
Islam
Stress Fractures
disengagement
Negotiating
interaction
feminism
Artifacts
Rupture
Muslim

Keywords

  • 4-Adolescence
  • Case Studies
  • Classroom Discourse
  • Critical Discourse Analysis
  • Discourse Analysis
  • Discourse Processes
  • Ethnographic
  • Ethnography
  • Feminist Theory / Theories
  • Genre Studies
  • Identity
  • Interactional Sociolinguistics
  • Interactional Sociolinguistics
  • Language learners
  • Post-structuralism
  • Struggling learners
  • Theoretical perspectives

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology

Cite this

@article{745c0536a8ac4ebc9ce48c4462e11d7d,
title = "Citations of Norms and Lines of Flight in One Immigrant Boy's Performances of Masculinities and Reading Identities",
abstract = "In this ethnographic case study, the author examined one immigrant adolescent's performances of masculinities through reading practices. The author analyzed how Omar (pseudonym), a Muslim boy from Libya, used reading practices to produce himself as a boy in one U.S. multilingual classroom. Extending the anti-essentialist scholarship on gender and reading, the author brought together Butler's queer feminism and Deleuze and Guattari's philosophy of becoming to further trouble gender and analyze the instability of Omar's masculinity performances in relation to reading practice. Through analyses of field notes, classroom interactions, and artifacts, this study showed that Omar discursively performed and negotiated multiple and seemingly conflicting reading identities across time and space. Although he was discursively positioned as a nonreader in classroom interactions, he also performed disengagement with reading to display a cool, nonschoolish masculinity aligned to the normative discourses of Arab masculinity to which he was subject. However, he also enacted reader identity and behaviors not traditionally associated with masculinity. Omar's identity negotiation, interactionally and socially situated, demonstrated the instability of masculinity performances, featuring repeated citation of gender norms fissured with lines of flight breaking away from normative ways of being. This analysis contributes to the anti-essentialist research on boys and literacies by shedding light on the regulations and ruptures in masculinity performances of a gendered subject. The study highlights the importance of situating analysis of gender and reading practices within the social and power relations in the discursive and interactional space. Addressing space allows a close reading of how gender hegemonies operate and fracture in micro movements of identity performance and how space can be shaped to open up opportunities for becoming-other.",
keywords = "4-Adolescence, Case Studies, Classroom Discourse, Critical Discourse Analysis, Discourse Analysis, Discourse Processes, Ethnographic, Ethnography, Feminist Theory / Theories, Genre Studies, Identity, Interactional Sociolinguistics, Interactional Sociolinguistics, Language learners, Post-structuralism, Struggling learners, Theoretical perspectives",
author = "Kongji Qin",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/rrq.239",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Reading Research Quarterly",
issn = "0034-0553",
publisher = "International Reading Association",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Citations of Norms and Lines of Flight in One Immigrant Boy's Performances of Masculinities and Reading Identities

AU - Qin, Kongji

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - In this ethnographic case study, the author examined one immigrant adolescent's performances of masculinities through reading practices. The author analyzed how Omar (pseudonym), a Muslim boy from Libya, used reading practices to produce himself as a boy in one U.S. multilingual classroom. Extending the anti-essentialist scholarship on gender and reading, the author brought together Butler's queer feminism and Deleuze and Guattari's philosophy of becoming to further trouble gender and analyze the instability of Omar's masculinity performances in relation to reading practice. Through analyses of field notes, classroom interactions, and artifacts, this study showed that Omar discursively performed and negotiated multiple and seemingly conflicting reading identities across time and space. Although he was discursively positioned as a nonreader in classroom interactions, he also performed disengagement with reading to display a cool, nonschoolish masculinity aligned to the normative discourses of Arab masculinity to which he was subject. However, he also enacted reader identity and behaviors not traditionally associated with masculinity. Omar's identity negotiation, interactionally and socially situated, demonstrated the instability of masculinity performances, featuring repeated citation of gender norms fissured with lines of flight breaking away from normative ways of being. This analysis contributes to the anti-essentialist research on boys and literacies by shedding light on the regulations and ruptures in masculinity performances of a gendered subject. The study highlights the importance of situating analysis of gender and reading practices within the social and power relations in the discursive and interactional space. Addressing space allows a close reading of how gender hegemonies operate and fracture in micro movements of identity performance and how space can be shaped to open up opportunities for becoming-other.

AB - In this ethnographic case study, the author examined one immigrant adolescent's performances of masculinities through reading practices. The author analyzed how Omar (pseudonym), a Muslim boy from Libya, used reading practices to produce himself as a boy in one U.S. multilingual classroom. Extending the anti-essentialist scholarship on gender and reading, the author brought together Butler's queer feminism and Deleuze and Guattari's philosophy of becoming to further trouble gender and analyze the instability of Omar's masculinity performances in relation to reading practice. Through analyses of field notes, classroom interactions, and artifacts, this study showed that Omar discursively performed and negotiated multiple and seemingly conflicting reading identities across time and space. Although he was discursively positioned as a nonreader in classroom interactions, he also performed disengagement with reading to display a cool, nonschoolish masculinity aligned to the normative discourses of Arab masculinity to which he was subject. However, he also enacted reader identity and behaviors not traditionally associated with masculinity. Omar's identity negotiation, interactionally and socially situated, demonstrated the instability of masculinity performances, featuring repeated citation of gender norms fissured with lines of flight breaking away from normative ways of being. This analysis contributes to the anti-essentialist research on boys and literacies by shedding light on the regulations and ruptures in masculinity performances of a gendered subject. The study highlights the importance of situating analysis of gender and reading practices within the social and power relations in the discursive and interactional space. Addressing space allows a close reading of how gender hegemonies operate and fracture in micro movements of identity performance and how space can be shaped to open up opportunities for becoming-other.

KW - 4-Adolescence

KW - Case Studies

KW - Classroom Discourse

KW - Critical Discourse Analysis

KW - Discourse Analysis

KW - Discourse Processes

KW - Ethnographic

KW - Ethnography

KW - Feminist Theory / Theories

KW - Genre Studies

KW - Identity

KW - Interactional Sociolinguistics

KW - Interactional Sociolinguistics

KW - Language learners

KW - Post-structuralism

KW - Struggling learners

KW - Theoretical perspectives

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85060337980&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85060337980&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/rrq.239

DO - 10.1002/rrq.239

M3 - Article

JO - Reading Research Quarterly

JF - Reading Research Quarterly

SN - 0034-0553

ER -