Catch-Up: A Rule That Makes Service Sports More Competitive

Steven Brams, Mehmet S. Ismail, D. Marc Kilgour, Walter Stromquist

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Service sports include two-player contests such as volleyball, badminton, and squash. We analyze four rules, including the Standard Rule (SR), in which a player continues to serve until he or she loses. The Catch-Up Rule (CR) gives the serve to the player who has lost the previous point—as opposed to the player who won the previous point, as under SR. We also consider two Trailing Rules that make the server the player who trails in total score. Surprisingly, compared with SR, only CR gives the players the same probability of winning a game while increasing its expected length, thereby making it more competitive and exciting to watch. Unlike one of the Trailing Rules, CR is strategy-proof. By contrast, the rules of tennis fix who serves and when; its tiebreaker, however, keeps play competitive by being fair—not favoring either the player who serves first or who serves second.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)771-796
    Number of pages26
    JournalAmerican Mathematical Monthly
    Volume125
    Issue number9
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Oct 21 2018

    Fingerprint

    Sports
    Expected Length
    Continue
    Server
    Game
    Standards
    Strategy

    Keywords

    • 91A20
    • MSC: Primary 60J20
    • Secondary 91A80

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Mathematics(all)

    Cite this

    Catch-Up : A Rule That Makes Service Sports More Competitive. / Brams, Steven; Ismail, Mehmet S.; Kilgour, D. Marc; Stromquist, Walter.

    In: American Mathematical Monthly, Vol. 125, No. 9, 21.10.2018, p. 771-796.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Brams, S, Ismail, MS, Kilgour, DM & Stromquist, W 2018, 'Catch-Up: A Rule That Makes Service Sports More Competitive', American Mathematical Monthly, vol. 125, no. 9, pp. 771-796. https://doi.org/10.1080/00029890.2018.1502544
    Brams, Steven ; Ismail, Mehmet S. ; Kilgour, D. Marc ; Stromquist, Walter. / Catch-Up : A Rule That Makes Service Sports More Competitive. In: American Mathematical Monthly. 2018 ; Vol. 125, No. 9. pp. 771-796.
    @article{4ce0e7ecc3f24bccbaf63a5c81e22706,
    title = "Catch-Up: A Rule That Makes Service Sports More Competitive",
    abstract = "Service sports include two-player contests such as volleyball, badminton, and squash. We analyze four rules, including the Standard Rule (SR), in which a player continues to serve until he or she loses. The Catch-Up Rule (CR) gives the serve to the player who has lost the previous point—as opposed to the player who won the previous point, as under SR. We also consider two Trailing Rules that make the server the player who trails in total score. Surprisingly, compared with SR, only CR gives the players the same probability of winning a game while increasing its expected length, thereby making it more competitive and exciting to watch. Unlike one of the Trailing Rules, CR is strategy-proof. By contrast, the rules of tennis fix who serves and when; its tiebreaker, however, keeps play competitive by being fair—not favoring either the player who serves first or who serves second.",
    keywords = "91A20, MSC: Primary 60J20, Secondary 91A80",
    author = "Steven Brams and Ismail, {Mehmet S.} and Kilgour, {D. Marc} and Walter Stromquist",
    year = "2018",
    month = "10",
    day = "21",
    doi = "10.1080/00029890.2018.1502544",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "125",
    pages = "771--796",
    journal = "American Mathematical Monthly",
    issn = "0002-9890",
    publisher = "Mathematical Association of America",
    number = "9",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Catch-Up

    T2 - A Rule That Makes Service Sports More Competitive

    AU - Brams, Steven

    AU - Ismail, Mehmet S.

    AU - Kilgour, D. Marc

    AU - Stromquist, Walter

    PY - 2018/10/21

    Y1 - 2018/10/21

    N2 - Service sports include two-player contests such as volleyball, badminton, and squash. We analyze four rules, including the Standard Rule (SR), in which a player continues to serve until he or she loses. The Catch-Up Rule (CR) gives the serve to the player who has lost the previous point—as opposed to the player who won the previous point, as under SR. We also consider two Trailing Rules that make the server the player who trails in total score. Surprisingly, compared with SR, only CR gives the players the same probability of winning a game while increasing its expected length, thereby making it more competitive and exciting to watch. Unlike one of the Trailing Rules, CR is strategy-proof. By contrast, the rules of tennis fix who serves and when; its tiebreaker, however, keeps play competitive by being fair—not favoring either the player who serves first or who serves second.

    AB - Service sports include two-player contests such as volleyball, badminton, and squash. We analyze four rules, including the Standard Rule (SR), in which a player continues to serve until he or she loses. The Catch-Up Rule (CR) gives the serve to the player who has lost the previous point—as opposed to the player who won the previous point, as under SR. We also consider two Trailing Rules that make the server the player who trails in total score. Surprisingly, compared with SR, only CR gives the players the same probability of winning a game while increasing its expected length, thereby making it more competitive and exciting to watch. Unlike one of the Trailing Rules, CR is strategy-proof. By contrast, the rules of tennis fix who serves and when; its tiebreaker, however, keeps play competitive by being fair—not favoring either the player who serves first or who serves second.

    KW - 91A20

    KW - MSC: Primary 60J20

    KW - Secondary 91A80

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85056143309&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85056143309&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1080/00029890.2018.1502544

    DO - 10.1080/00029890.2018.1502544

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:85056143309

    VL - 125

    SP - 771

    EP - 796

    JO - American Mathematical Monthly

    JF - American Mathematical Monthly

    SN - 0002-9890

    IS - 9

    ER -