Blackshot

An unexpected dimension of human sensitivity to contrast

Michael S. Landy, Charles Chubb, John Econopouly

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose. We studied the perceptual segregation of texture pairs consisting of a grid of uniform, square texture elements, differing only in the distribution of intensities across those elements. If two textures differ in mean intensity ("lightness") or in the variance of intensity ("contrast"), then they are easily segregated. Chubb, Econopouly & Landy (JOSA A, 11, 2350, 1994) demonstrated the existence of a 3rd mechanism B (in addition to mechanisms L and C, coding lightness and contrast respectively) that was solely responsible for the segregation of textures equated for mean and contrast. Here, we determine the sensitivity of B to textures differing in mean or variance, thus fully specifying its (highly nonlinear) contrast response function. Method. Two textures have gray-level histograms H1 and H2 chosen so as to equate both mean and variance so that B alone discriminates them. The magnitude of the difference D=H1-H2 was varied to find a segregation threshold t*D. Then, D was perturbed (e.g., D'=t*D+P) so that the two textures differed in mean or variance, and segregation performance was assessed. Results. Differences in texture mean and in texture variance traded off linearly with changes in D. This implies that even when the textures differ slightly in mean or variance, it is still B alone that discriminates between them. The slopes of the lines relating changes in mean and variance to changes in the amplitude of D reflect the sensitivity of B to texture mean and variance. Combining these findings with our previous results reveals that B is (i) highly sensitive to texture elements of the lowest contrast (near -1), and (ii) has a response that saturates by a contrast of -3/4 (dark gray). That is, this "blackshot mechanism" discriminates textures by comparing the number of the blackest pixels in each.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalJournal of vision
Volume3
Issue number9
DOIs
StatePublished - 2003

Fingerprint

Contrast Sensitivity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ophthalmology

Cite this

Blackshot : An unexpected dimension of human sensitivity to contrast. / Landy, Michael S.; Chubb, Charles; Econopouly, John.

In: Journal of vision, Vol. 3, No. 9, 2003.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Landy, Michael S. ; Chubb, Charles ; Econopouly, John. / Blackshot : An unexpected dimension of human sensitivity to contrast. In: Journal of vision. 2003 ; Vol. 3, No. 9.
@article{810a309e28b74d84bc84eb5c9cb8ae88,
title = "Blackshot: An unexpected dimension of human sensitivity to contrast",
abstract = "Purpose. We studied the perceptual segregation of texture pairs consisting of a grid of uniform, square texture elements, differing only in the distribution of intensities across those elements. If two textures differ in mean intensity ({"}lightness{"}) or in the variance of intensity ({"}contrast{"}), then they are easily segregated. Chubb, Econopouly & Landy (JOSA A, 11, 2350, 1994) demonstrated the existence of a 3rd mechanism B (in addition to mechanisms L and C, coding lightness and contrast respectively) that was solely responsible for the segregation of textures equated for mean and contrast. Here, we determine the sensitivity of B to textures differing in mean or variance, thus fully specifying its (highly nonlinear) contrast response function. Method. Two textures have gray-level histograms H1 and H2 chosen so as to equate both mean and variance so that B alone discriminates them. The magnitude of the difference D=H1-H2 was varied to find a segregation threshold t*D. Then, D was perturbed (e.g., D'=t*D+P) so that the two textures differed in mean or variance, and segregation performance was assessed. Results. Differences in texture mean and in texture variance traded off linearly with changes in D. This implies that even when the textures differ slightly in mean or variance, it is still B alone that discriminates between them. The slopes of the lines relating changes in mean and variance to changes in the amplitude of D reflect the sensitivity of B to texture mean and variance. Combining these findings with our previous results reveals that B is (i) highly sensitive to texture elements of the lowest contrast (near -1), and (ii) has a response that saturates by a contrast of -3/4 (dark gray). That is, this {"}blackshot mechanism{"} discriminates textures by comparing the number of the blackest pixels in each.",
author = "Landy, {Michael S.} and Charles Chubb and John Econopouly",
year = "2003",
doi = "10.1167/3.9.60",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "3",
journal = "Journal of vision",
issn = "1534-7362",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Blackshot

T2 - An unexpected dimension of human sensitivity to contrast

AU - Landy, Michael S.

AU - Chubb, Charles

AU - Econopouly, John

PY - 2003

Y1 - 2003

N2 - Purpose. We studied the perceptual segregation of texture pairs consisting of a grid of uniform, square texture elements, differing only in the distribution of intensities across those elements. If two textures differ in mean intensity ("lightness") or in the variance of intensity ("contrast"), then they are easily segregated. Chubb, Econopouly & Landy (JOSA A, 11, 2350, 1994) demonstrated the existence of a 3rd mechanism B (in addition to mechanisms L and C, coding lightness and contrast respectively) that was solely responsible for the segregation of textures equated for mean and contrast. Here, we determine the sensitivity of B to textures differing in mean or variance, thus fully specifying its (highly nonlinear) contrast response function. Method. Two textures have gray-level histograms H1 and H2 chosen so as to equate both mean and variance so that B alone discriminates them. The magnitude of the difference D=H1-H2 was varied to find a segregation threshold t*D. Then, D was perturbed (e.g., D'=t*D+P) so that the two textures differed in mean or variance, and segregation performance was assessed. Results. Differences in texture mean and in texture variance traded off linearly with changes in D. This implies that even when the textures differ slightly in mean or variance, it is still B alone that discriminates between them. The slopes of the lines relating changes in mean and variance to changes in the amplitude of D reflect the sensitivity of B to texture mean and variance. Combining these findings with our previous results reveals that B is (i) highly sensitive to texture elements of the lowest contrast (near -1), and (ii) has a response that saturates by a contrast of -3/4 (dark gray). That is, this "blackshot mechanism" discriminates textures by comparing the number of the blackest pixels in each.

AB - Purpose. We studied the perceptual segregation of texture pairs consisting of a grid of uniform, square texture elements, differing only in the distribution of intensities across those elements. If two textures differ in mean intensity ("lightness") or in the variance of intensity ("contrast"), then they are easily segregated. Chubb, Econopouly & Landy (JOSA A, 11, 2350, 1994) demonstrated the existence of a 3rd mechanism B (in addition to mechanisms L and C, coding lightness and contrast respectively) that was solely responsible for the segregation of textures equated for mean and contrast. Here, we determine the sensitivity of B to textures differing in mean or variance, thus fully specifying its (highly nonlinear) contrast response function. Method. Two textures have gray-level histograms H1 and H2 chosen so as to equate both mean and variance so that B alone discriminates them. The magnitude of the difference D=H1-H2 was varied to find a segregation threshold t*D. Then, D was perturbed (e.g., D'=t*D+P) so that the two textures differed in mean or variance, and segregation performance was assessed. Results. Differences in texture mean and in texture variance traded off linearly with changes in D. This implies that even when the textures differ slightly in mean or variance, it is still B alone that discriminates between them. The slopes of the lines relating changes in mean and variance to changes in the amplitude of D reflect the sensitivity of B to texture mean and variance. Combining these findings with our previous results reveals that B is (i) highly sensitive to texture elements of the lowest contrast (near -1), and (ii) has a response that saturates by a contrast of -3/4 (dark gray). That is, this "blackshot mechanism" discriminates textures by comparing the number of the blackest pixels in each.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=4243067182&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=4243067182&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1167/3.9.60

DO - 10.1167/3.9.60

M3 - Article

VL - 3

JO - Journal of vision

JF - Journal of vision

SN - 1534-7362

IS - 9

ER -