Beyond "natural-disasters-are-not-natural": The work of state and nature after the 2010 earthquake in Chile

Kevin A. Gould, M. Magdalena Garcia, Jacob Remes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Since the 1970s, human ecologists, geographers, Marxian political economists and others have insisted that there is no such thing as a 'natural' disaster. This assertion opened a space not only for exploring socioeconomic conditions that render marginalized populations vulnerable to natural hazards, but also for the formation of a field, the political ecology of hazards. A few political ecologists further interrogated the idea of a natural disaster, asking how different notions of 'the natural' circulate in post-disaster politics and with what effects. This article extends the latter approach by documenting how interconnected categories of 'nature' and 'state' were mutually constituted by narratives of politicians and elites after Chile's 2010 earthquake and tsunami. Drawing on media reports, we identify three distinct pairings of state/nature: (1) nature as manageable and the state as manager; (2) nature as out of control and the state as a police state; and (3) nature as financial opportunity and the state as prudential. Influenced by socioeconomic and historical factors, these state/nature pairings contradicted and reinforced one another in the disaster's aftermath and were deployed to reinforce top-down-rather than democratic-strategies of post-disaster reconstruction. This case offers an unusual approach to disaster politics by tracing how entwined and power-laden categories of state and nature condition the governance of disaster reconstruction processes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)93-114
Number of pages22
JournalJournal of Political Ecology
Volume23
Issue number1
StatePublished - 2016

Fingerprint

natural disaster
Chile
disaster
earthquake
politics
Chile earthquake 2010
socioeconomic conditions
reconstruction
natural hazard
tsunami
hazard
environmental policy
economist
politician
police
elite
manager
governance
narrative

Keywords

  • 27F
  • Chile
  • Disaster
  • Earthquake
  • Latin America
  • Media disaster
  • Nature
  • Political ecology of hazards
  • Socionature
  • State

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Geography, Planning and Development
  • Ecology
  • Political Science and International Relations

Cite this

Beyond "natural-disasters-are-not-natural" : The work of state and nature after the 2010 earthquake in Chile. / Gould, Kevin A.; Magdalena Garcia, M.; Remes, Jacob.

In: Journal of Political Ecology, Vol. 23, No. 1, 2016, p. 93-114.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b003f80fde5b4c3f9d10806b852dd83e,
title = "Beyond {"}natural-disasters-are-not-natural{"}: The work of state and nature after the 2010 earthquake in Chile",
abstract = "Since the 1970s, human ecologists, geographers, Marxian political economists and others have insisted that there is no such thing as a 'natural' disaster. This assertion opened a space not only for exploring socioeconomic conditions that render marginalized populations vulnerable to natural hazards, but also for the formation of a field, the political ecology of hazards. A few political ecologists further interrogated the idea of a natural disaster, asking how different notions of 'the natural' circulate in post-disaster politics and with what effects. This article extends the latter approach by documenting how interconnected categories of 'nature' and 'state' were mutually constituted by narratives of politicians and elites after Chile's 2010 earthquake and tsunami. Drawing on media reports, we identify three distinct pairings of state/nature: (1) nature as manageable and the state as manager; (2) nature as out of control and the state as a police state; and (3) nature as financial opportunity and the state as prudential. Influenced by socioeconomic and historical factors, these state/nature pairings contradicted and reinforced one another in the disaster's aftermath and were deployed to reinforce top-down-rather than democratic-strategies of post-disaster reconstruction. This case offers an unusual approach to disaster politics by tracing how entwined and power-laden categories of state and nature condition the governance of disaster reconstruction processes.",
keywords = "27F, Chile, Disaster, Earthquake, Latin America, Media disaster, Nature, Political ecology of hazards, Socionature, State",
author = "Gould, {Kevin A.} and {Magdalena Garcia}, M. and Jacob Remes",
year = "2016",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "23",
pages = "93--114",
journal = "Journal of Political Ecology",
issn = "1073-0451",
publisher = "Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Beyond "natural-disasters-are-not-natural"

T2 - The work of state and nature after the 2010 earthquake in Chile

AU - Gould, Kevin A.

AU - Magdalena Garcia, M.

AU - Remes, Jacob

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Since the 1970s, human ecologists, geographers, Marxian political economists and others have insisted that there is no such thing as a 'natural' disaster. This assertion opened a space not only for exploring socioeconomic conditions that render marginalized populations vulnerable to natural hazards, but also for the formation of a field, the political ecology of hazards. A few political ecologists further interrogated the idea of a natural disaster, asking how different notions of 'the natural' circulate in post-disaster politics and with what effects. This article extends the latter approach by documenting how interconnected categories of 'nature' and 'state' were mutually constituted by narratives of politicians and elites after Chile's 2010 earthquake and tsunami. Drawing on media reports, we identify three distinct pairings of state/nature: (1) nature as manageable and the state as manager; (2) nature as out of control and the state as a police state; and (3) nature as financial opportunity and the state as prudential. Influenced by socioeconomic and historical factors, these state/nature pairings contradicted and reinforced one another in the disaster's aftermath and were deployed to reinforce top-down-rather than democratic-strategies of post-disaster reconstruction. This case offers an unusual approach to disaster politics by tracing how entwined and power-laden categories of state and nature condition the governance of disaster reconstruction processes.

AB - Since the 1970s, human ecologists, geographers, Marxian political economists and others have insisted that there is no such thing as a 'natural' disaster. This assertion opened a space not only for exploring socioeconomic conditions that render marginalized populations vulnerable to natural hazards, but also for the formation of a field, the political ecology of hazards. A few political ecologists further interrogated the idea of a natural disaster, asking how different notions of 'the natural' circulate in post-disaster politics and with what effects. This article extends the latter approach by documenting how interconnected categories of 'nature' and 'state' were mutually constituted by narratives of politicians and elites after Chile's 2010 earthquake and tsunami. Drawing on media reports, we identify three distinct pairings of state/nature: (1) nature as manageable and the state as manager; (2) nature as out of control and the state as a police state; and (3) nature as financial opportunity and the state as prudential. Influenced by socioeconomic and historical factors, these state/nature pairings contradicted and reinforced one another in the disaster's aftermath and were deployed to reinforce top-down-rather than democratic-strategies of post-disaster reconstruction. This case offers an unusual approach to disaster politics by tracing how entwined and power-laden categories of state and nature condition the governance of disaster reconstruction processes.

KW - 27F

KW - Chile

KW - Disaster

KW - Earthquake

KW - Latin America

KW - Media disaster

KW - Nature

KW - Political ecology of hazards

KW - Socionature

KW - State

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85011976724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85011976724&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85011976724

VL - 23

SP - 93

EP - 114

JO - Journal of Political Ecology

JF - Journal of Political Ecology

SN - 1073-0451

IS - 1

ER -