Being a second generation Muslim woman in the French labour market: Understanding the dynamics of (visibility of) religion and gender in labour market access, outcomes and experiences

Jawiria Naseem, Wifag Adnan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This mixed-method article focuses on Muslim women who are second generation – children of immigrants, born and bred in France – by bringing to the fore the intersection of (visibility of) religion and gender in the production of labour market access, outcomes and experiences. The quantitative analysis uses the Trajectories and Origins Survey 2009 and the European Social Survey (2006–2016) to explore how religious affiliation impacts labour market outcomes and how discriminatory practices are perceived. The qualitative analysis builds on semi-structured interviews which bring together, for the first time, women from a well-established minority ethnic group in France – Algerians – and women from a newly-settled group – Pakistanis. In doing so, the analysis offers a conceptual understanding of the ways in which gendered and religious displays shape labour market experiences. We find that ethnicity (based on parental country of birth) is by far the most commonly cited form of experienced and/or perceived discrimination in labour market access. In terms of outcomes, Muslim women are the least likely to gain employment, work the least number of hours and earn the lowest salaries; those who display their religion (through headscarf wearing practice for example) have an even reduced labour market participation rate. Drawing on the interviews analysis, we suggest that certain professional roles and sectors are believed to be accessible for those who are perceived to be French and white only. This racialised understanding of Frenchness produces inequality in the workplace and blocks professional progression for Muslim women, who are French by birth and educated in France. However, despite experiencing a similar racialisation process, the ways in which the women dealt with unequal treatment at work differed according to their ethnicity.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalResearch in Social Stratification and Mobility
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Muslim
labor market
Religion
gender
experience
France
ethnicity
ESS
Algerian
denomination
interview
salary
ethnic group
discrimination
workplace
immigrant
minority
participation
Group

Keywords

  • Discrimination
  • Ethnicity
  • French labour market
  • Gender
  • Islam
  • Racialisation
  • Racism
  • Second generation women

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Social Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

@article{51fe0a39c2de434a9b33c3d60685adc9,
title = "Being a second generation Muslim woman in the French labour market: Understanding the dynamics of (visibility of) religion and gender in labour market access, outcomes and experiences",
abstract = "This mixed-method article focuses on Muslim women who are second generation – children of immigrants, born and bred in France – by bringing to the fore the intersection of (visibility of) religion and gender in the production of labour market access, outcomes and experiences. The quantitative analysis uses the Trajectories and Origins Survey 2009 and the European Social Survey (2006–2016) to explore how religious affiliation impacts labour market outcomes and how discriminatory practices are perceived. The qualitative analysis builds on semi-structured interviews which bring together, for the first time, women from a well-established minority ethnic group in France – Algerians – and women from a newly-settled group – Pakistanis. In doing so, the analysis offers a conceptual understanding of the ways in which gendered and religious displays shape labour market experiences. We find that ethnicity (based on parental country of birth) is by far the most commonly cited form of experienced and/or perceived discrimination in labour market access. In terms of outcomes, Muslim women are the least likely to gain employment, work the least number of hours and earn the lowest salaries; those who display their religion (through headscarf wearing practice for example) have an even reduced labour market participation rate. Drawing on the interviews analysis, we suggest that certain professional roles and sectors are believed to be accessible for those who are perceived to be French and white only. This racialised understanding of Frenchness produces inequality in the workplace and blocks professional progression for Muslim women, who are French by birth and educated in France. However, despite experiencing a similar racialisation process, the ways in which the women dealt with unequal treatment at work differed according to their ethnicity.",
keywords = "Discrimination, Ethnicity, French labour market, Gender, Islam, Racialisation, Racism, Second generation women",
author = "Jawiria Naseem and Wifag Adnan",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.rssm.2019.02.003",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Research in Social Stratification and Mobility",
issn = "0276-5624",
publisher = "JAI Press",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Being a second generation Muslim woman in the French labour market

T2 - Understanding the dynamics of (visibility of) religion and gender in labour market access, outcomes and experiences

AU - Naseem, Jawiria

AU - Adnan, Wifag

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - This mixed-method article focuses on Muslim women who are second generation – children of immigrants, born and bred in France – by bringing to the fore the intersection of (visibility of) religion and gender in the production of labour market access, outcomes and experiences. The quantitative analysis uses the Trajectories and Origins Survey 2009 and the European Social Survey (2006–2016) to explore how religious affiliation impacts labour market outcomes and how discriminatory practices are perceived. The qualitative analysis builds on semi-structured interviews which bring together, for the first time, women from a well-established minority ethnic group in France – Algerians – and women from a newly-settled group – Pakistanis. In doing so, the analysis offers a conceptual understanding of the ways in which gendered and religious displays shape labour market experiences. We find that ethnicity (based on parental country of birth) is by far the most commonly cited form of experienced and/or perceived discrimination in labour market access. In terms of outcomes, Muslim women are the least likely to gain employment, work the least number of hours and earn the lowest salaries; those who display their religion (through headscarf wearing practice for example) have an even reduced labour market participation rate. Drawing on the interviews analysis, we suggest that certain professional roles and sectors are believed to be accessible for those who are perceived to be French and white only. This racialised understanding of Frenchness produces inequality in the workplace and blocks professional progression for Muslim women, who are French by birth and educated in France. However, despite experiencing a similar racialisation process, the ways in which the women dealt with unequal treatment at work differed according to their ethnicity.

AB - This mixed-method article focuses on Muslim women who are second generation – children of immigrants, born and bred in France – by bringing to the fore the intersection of (visibility of) religion and gender in the production of labour market access, outcomes and experiences. The quantitative analysis uses the Trajectories and Origins Survey 2009 and the European Social Survey (2006–2016) to explore how religious affiliation impacts labour market outcomes and how discriminatory practices are perceived. The qualitative analysis builds on semi-structured interviews which bring together, for the first time, women from a well-established minority ethnic group in France – Algerians – and women from a newly-settled group – Pakistanis. In doing so, the analysis offers a conceptual understanding of the ways in which gendered and religious displays shape labour market experiences. We find that ethnicity (based on parental country of birth) is by far the most commonly cited form of experienced and/or perceived discrimination in labour market access. In terms of outcomes, Muslim women are the least likely to gain employment, work the least number of hours and earn the lowest salaries; those who display their religion (through headscarf wearing practice for example) have an even reduced labour market participation rate. Drawing on the interviews analysis, we suggest that certain professional roles and sectors are believed to be accessible for those who are perceived to be French and white only. This racialised understanding of Frenchness produces inequality in the workplace and blocks professional progression for Muslim women, who are French by birth and educated in France. However, despite experiencing a similar racialisation process, the ways in which the women dealt with unequal treatment at work differed according to their ethnicity.

KW - Discrimination

KW - Ethnicity

KW - French labour market

KW - Gender

KW - Islam

KW - Racialisation

KW - Racism

KW - Second generation women

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063503206&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85063503206&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.rssm.2019.02.003

DO - 10.1016/j.rssm.2019.02.003

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85063503206

JO - Research in Social Stratification and Mobility

JF - Research in Social Stratification and Mobility

SN - 0276-5624

ER -