A distinguishing feature of Pongo upper molars and its implications for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth from the Pleistocene of Asia

Alejandra Ortiz, Shara E. Bailey, Miguel Delgado, Clément Zanolli, Fabrice Demeter, Anne Marie Bacon, Thi M.H. Nguyen, Anh T. Nguyen, Yingqi Zhang, Terry Harrison, Jean Jacques Hublin, Matthew M. Skinner

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Objectives: The taxonomic status of isolated hominoid teeth from the Asian Pleistocene has long been controversial due to difficulties distinguishing between pongine and hominin molars given their high degree of morphometrical variation and overlap. Here, we combine nonmetric and geometric morphometric data to document a dental pattern that appears to be taxonomically diagnostic among Pongo. We focus on the protoconule, a cuspule of well-documented evolutionary history, as well as on shape differences of the mesial fovea of the upper molars. Materials and methods: We examined 469 upper molars of eight hominid genera (Australopithecus, Paranthropus, Homo, Meganthropus, Sivapithecus, Pan, Gorilla, and Pongo), including representatives of Homo erectus and extinct and recent Pongo. Analyses were conducted at the enamel-dentine junction to overcome the limitations introduced by dental wear. Results: We found that a moderate or large protoconule is present in ~80% of Pleistocene and extant Pongo. Conversely, a moderate to pronounced protoconule in hominins, Meganthropus, and African great apes occurs in low frequencies (~0–20%). Canonical variate analyses for the mesial fovea show that Pleistocene and extant Pongo cluster together and are clearly differentiated from all other groups, except for Sivapithecus. Discussion: This study suggests that the protoconule and the shape of the mesial fovea in upper molars are useful features for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth. By identifying these new features, our results can contribute to the better understanding of hominoid evolutionary history and biogeography during the Asian Pleistocene. However, we emphasize that the reported features should be used in combination with other diagnostic variables for the most accurate taxonomic assessments.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Pages (from-to)595-612
    Number of pages18
    JournalAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology
    Volume170
    Issue number4
    DOIs
    StatePublished - Dec 1 2019

    Fingerprint

    Pongo
    Hominidae
    Tooth
    diagnostic
    history
    History
    Tooth Wear
    Gorilla gorilla
    Group
    Dentin
    Dental Enamel

    Keywords

    • enamel-dentine junction
    • hominids
    • mesial fovea
    • protoconule
    • taxonomy

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Anatomy
    • Anthropology

    Cite this

    A distinguishing feature of Pongo upper molars and its implications for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth from the Pleistocene of Asia. / Ortiz, Alejandra; Bailey, Shara E.; Delgado, Miguel; Zanolli, Clément; Demeter, Fabrice; Bacon, Anne Marie; Nguyen, Thi M.H.; Nguyen, Anh T.; Zhang, Yingqi; Harrison, Terry; Hublin, Jean Jacques; Skinner, Matthew M.

    In: American Journal of Physical Anthropology, Vol. 170, No. 4, 01.12.2019, p. 595-612.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Ortiz, A, Bailey, SE, Delgado, M, Zanolli, C, Demeter, F, Bacon, AM, Nguyen, TMH, Nguyen, AT, Zhang, Y, Harrison, T, Hublin, JJ & Skinner, MM 2019, 'A distinguishing feature of Pongo upper molars and its implications for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth from the Pleistocene of Asia', American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 170, no. 4, pp. 595-612. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.23928
    Ortiz, Alejandra ; Bailey, Shara E. ; Delgado, Miguel ; Zanolli, Clément ; Demeter, Fabrice ; Bacon, Anne Marie ; Nguyen, Thi M.H. ; Nguyen, Anh T. ; Zhang, Yingqi ; Harrison, Terry ; Hublin, Jean Jacques ; Skinner, Matthew M. / A distinguishing feature of Pongo upper molars and its implications for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth from the Pleistocene of Asia. In: American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 2019 ; Vol. 170, No. 4. pp. 595-612.
    @article{6bd718b981664a6292ac50dc2e0da301,
    title = "A distinguishing feature of Pongo upper molars and its implications for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth from the Pleistocene of Asia",
    abstract = "Objectives: The taxonomic status of isolated hominoid teeth from the Asian Pleistocene has long been controversial due to difficulties distinguishing between pongine and hominin molars given their high degree of morphometrical variation and overlap. Here, we combine nonmetric and geometric morphometric data to document a dental pattern that appears to be taxonomically diagnostic among Pongo. We focus on the protoconule, a cuspule of well-documented evolutionary history, as well as on shape differences of the mesial fovea of the upper molars. Materials and methods: We examined 469 upper molars of eight hominid genera (Australopithecus, Paranthropus, Homo, Meganthropus, Sivapithecus, Pan, Gorilla, and Pongo), including representatives of Homo erectus and extinct and recent Pongo. Analyses were conducted at the enamel-dentine junction to overcome the limitations introduced by dental wear. Results: We found that a moderate or large protoconule is present in ~80{\%} of Pleistocene and extant Pongo. Conversely, a moderate to pronounced protoconule in hominins, Meganthropus, and African great apes occurs in low frequencies (~0–20{\%}). Canonical variate analyses for the mesial fovea show that Pleistocene and extant Pongo cluster together and are clearly differentiated from all other groups, except for Sivapithecus. Discussion: This study suggests that the protoconule and the shape of the mesial fovea in upper molars are useful features for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth. By identifying these new features, our results can contribute to the better understanding of hominoid evolutionary history and biogeography during the Asian Pleistocene. However, we emphasize that the reported features should be used in combination with other diagnostic variables for the most accurate taxonomic assessments.",
    keywords = "enamel-dentine junction, hominids, mesial fovea, protoconule, taxonomy",
    author = "Alejandra Ortiz and Bailey, {Shara E.} and Miguel Delgado and Cl{\'e}ment Zanolli and Fabrice Demeter and Bacon, {Anne Marie} and Nguyen, {Thi M.H.} and Nguyen, {Anh T.} and Yingqi Zhang and Terry Harrison and Hublin, {Jean Jacques} and Skinner, {Matthew M.}",
    year = "2019",
    month = "12",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1002/ajpa.23928",
    language = "English (US)",
    volume = "170",
    pages = "595--612",
    journal = "American Journal of Physical Anthropology",
    issn = "0002-9483",
    publisher = "Wiley-Liss Inc.",
    number = "4",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A distinguishing feature of Pongo upper molars and its implications for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth from the Pleistocene of Asia

    AU - Ortiz, Alejandra

    AU - Bailey, Shara E.

    AU - Delgado, Miguel

    AU - Zanolli, Clément

    AU - Demeter, Fabrice

    AU - Bacon, Anne Marie

    AU - Nguyen, Thi M.H.

    AU - Nguyen, Anh T.

    AU - Zhang, Yingqi

    AU - Harrison, Terry

    AU - Hublin, Jean Jacques

    AU - Skinner, Matthew M.

    PY - 2019/12/1

    Y1 - 2019/12/1

    N2 - Objectives: The taxonomic status of isolated hominoid teeth from the Asian Pleistocene has long been controversial due to difficulties distinguishing between pongine and hominin molars given their high degree of morphometrical variation and overlap. Here, we combine nonmetric and geometric morphometric data to document a dental pattern that appears to be taxonomically diagnostic among Pongo. We focus on the protoconule, a cuspule of well-documented evolutionary history, as well as on shape differences of the mesial fovea of the upper molars. Materials and methods: We examined 469 upper molars of eight hominid genera (Australopithecus, Paranthropus, Homo, Meganthropus, Sivapithecus, Pan, Gorilla, and Pongo), including representatives of Homo erectus and extinct and recent Pongo. Analyses were conducted at the enamel-dentine junction to overcome the limitations introduced by dental wear. Results: We found that a moderate or large protoconule is present in ~80% of Pleistocene and extant Pongo. Conversely, a moderate to pronounced protoconule in hominins, Meganthropus, and African great apes occurs in low frequencies (~0–20%). Canonical variate analyses for the mesial fovea show that Pleistocene and extant Pongo cluster together and are clearly differentiated from all other groups, except for Sivapithecus. Discussion: This study suggests that the protoconule and the shape of the mesial fovea in upper molars are useful features for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth. By identifying these new features, our results can contribute to the better understanding of hominoid evolutionary history and biogeography during the Asian Pleistocene. However, we emphasize that the reported features should be used in combination with other diagnostic variables for the most accurate taxonomic assessments.

    AB - Objectives: The taxonomic status of isolated hominoid teeth from the Asian Pleistocene has long been controversial due to difficulties distinguishing between pongine and hominin molars given their high degree of morphometrical variation and overlap. Here, we combine nonmetric and geometric morphometric data to document a dental pattern that appears to be taxonomically diagnostic among Pongo. We focus on the protoconule, a cuspule of well-documented evolutionary history, as well as on shape differences of the mesial fovea of the upper molars. Materials and methods: We examined 469 upper molars of eight hominid genera (Australopithecus, Paranthropus, Homo, Meganthropus, Sivapithecus, Pan, Gorilla, and Pongo), including representatives of Homo erectus and extinct and recent Pongo. Analyses were conducted at the enamel-dentine junction to overcome the limitations introduced by dental wear. Results: We found that a moderate or large protoconule is present in ~80% of Pleistocene and extant Pongo. Conversely, a moderate to pronounced protoconule in hominins, Meganthropus, and African great apes occurs in low frequencies (~0–20%). Canonical variate analyses for the mesial fovea show that Pleistocene and extant Pongo cluster together and are clearly differentiated from all other groups, except for Sivapithecus. Discussion: This study suggests that the protoconule and the shape of the mesial fovea in upper molars are useful features for the taxonomic identification of isolated hominid teeth. By identifying these new features, our results can contribute to the better understanding of hominoid evolutionary history and biogeography during the Asian Pleistocene. However, we emphasize that the reported features should be used in combination with other diagnostic variables for the most accurate taxonomic assessments.

    KW - enamel-dentine junction

    KW - hominids

    KW - mesial fovea

    KW - protoconule

    KW - taxonomy

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074605291&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85074605291&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1002/ajpa.23928

    DO - 10.1002/ajpa.23928

    M3 - Article

    C2 - 31651996

    AN - SCOPUS:85074605291

    VL - 170

    SP - 595

    EP - 612

    JO - American Journal of Physical Anthropology

    JF - American Journal of Physical Anthropology

    SN - 0002-9483

    IS - 4

    ER -