A distinctive ugliness

Olonial memory in belgium

Pedro Monaville

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Abstract

    And indeed, to this day one sees in Belgium a distinctive ugliness, dating from the time when the Congo colony was exploited without restraint and manifested in the macabre atmosphere of certain salons and the strikingly stunted growth of the population, such as one rarely comes across elsewhere. At all events, I well recall that on my first visit to Brussels in December 1964 I encountered more hunchbacks and lunatics than normally in a whole year. Is Belgium an anomaly among European nation-states? Claims about the artificiality of Belgium are as old as the Belgian state itself. These claims have been revived since the 1970s and the centrifugal sequence that has transformed Belgian constitutional apparatus in the direction of confederalism and increased the gap between the country's main linguistic constituencies - the Dutch-speaking inhabitants of Flanders and the French-speaking inhabitants of Wallonia and of Brussels (a city itself enclosed inside the Flemish territory). Several historians, most recently Martin Conway, have argued against the so-called inherent artificiality of the Belgian state, showing instead the contingent character of sub-national separatism and the historical entrenchment of Belgian national feelings. Other scholars have underlined the exemplary dynamic of decentralization and regional autonomy in Belgium as emblematic of state transformations in the context of European integration. Yet, participants in the debates around Belgian exceptionalism have ignored the history and legacy of Belgian imperialism in Africa. What is the relevance of Belgium's colonial past in Central Africa for understanding its current identity and institutional crisis? Historians have commented on the causal connection between decolonization and Belgium's investment in European integration, but they have usually only hinted at the near simultaneity of imperial retreat and national unraveling as mere coincidence or anecdote. It is indeed challenging to clearly highlight effective connections between the two processes. The institutional, cultural, and economic specificities of Belgian Congo, its relative autonomy with regard to the core of the state apparatus and its relative ignorance by the Belgian public, have contributed to render colonialism a detachable appendix, a dispensable chapter in Belgian national history.

    Original languageEnglish (US)
    Title of host publicationMemories of Post-Imperial Nations
    PublisherCambridge University Press
    Pages58-75
    Number of pages18
    ISBN (Electronic)9781316182543
    ISBN (Print)9781107102293
    StatePublished - Jan 1 2015

    Fingerprint

    Belgium
    Ugliness
    Historian
    Artificiality
    Colonies
    Autonomy
    Bruxelles
    European Integration
    Macabre
    Simultaneity
    Flanders
    Economics
    Specificity
    Africa
    History
    Belgian Congo
    Separatism
    1970s
    Anomaly
    Colonialism

    ASJC Scopus subject areas

    • Arts and Humanities(all)

    Cite this

    Monaville, P. (2015). A distinctive ugliness: Olonial memory in belgium. In Memories of Post-Imperial Nations (pp. 58-75). Cambridge University Press.

    A distinctive ugliness : Olonial memory in belgium. / Monaville, Pedro.

    Memories of Post-Imperial Nations. Cambridge University Press, 2015. p. 58-75.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Monaville, P 2015, A distinctive ugliness: Olonial memory in belgium. in Memories of Post-Imperial Nations. Cambridge University Press, pp. 58-75.
    Monaville P. A distinctive ugliness: Olonial memory in belgium. In Memories of Post-Imperial Nations. Cambridge University Press. 2015. p. 58-75
    Monaville, Pedro. / A distinctive ugliness : Olonial memory in belgium. Memories of Post-Imperial Nations. Cambridge University Press, 2015. pp. 58-75
    @inbook{bf373d21c1b54e7e8d1646c4cd3a1541,
    title = "A distinctive ugliness: Olonial memory in belgium",
    abstract = "And indeed, to this day one sees in Belgium a distinctive ugliness, dating from the time when the Congo colony was exploited without restraint and manifested in the macabre atmosphere of certain salons and the strikingly stunted growth of the population, such as one rarely comes across elsewhere. At all events, I well recall that on my first visit to Brussels in December 1964 I encountered more hunchbacks and lunatics than normally in a whole year. Is Belgium an anomaly among European nation-states? Claims about the artificiality of Belgium are as old as the Belgian state itself. These claims have been revived since the 1970s and the centrifugal sequence that has transformed Belgian constitutional apparatus in the direction of confederalism and increased the gap between the country's main linguistic constituencies - the Dutch-speaking inhabitants of Flanders and the French-speaking inhabitants of Wallonia and of Brussels (a city itself enclosed inside the Flemish territory). Several historians, most recently Martin Conway, have argued against the so-called inherent artificiality of the Belgian state, showing instead the contingent character of sub-national separatism and the historical entrenchment of Belgian national feelings. Other scholars have underlined the exemplary dynamic of decentralization and regional autonomy in Belgium as emblematic of state transformations in the context of European integration. Yet, participants in the debates around Belgian exceptionalism have ignored the history and legacy of Belgian imperialism in Africa. What is the relevance of Belgium's colonial past in Central Africa for understanding its current identity and institutional crisis? Historians have commented on the causal connection between decolonization and Belgium's investment in European integration, but they have usually only hinted at the near simultaneity of imperial retreat and national unraveling as mere coincidence or anecdote. It is indeed challenging to clearly highlight effective connections between the two processes. The institutional, cultural, and economic specificities of Belgian Congo, its relative autonomy with regard to the core of the state apparatus and its relative ignorance by the Belgian public, have contributed to render colonialism a detachable appendix, a dispensable chapter in Belgian national history.",
    author = "Pedro Monaville",
    year = "2015",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    language = "English (US)",
    isbn = "9781107102293",
    pages = "58--75",
    booktitle = "Memories of Post-Imperial Nations",
    publisher = "Cambridge University Press",

    }

    TY - CHAP

    T1 - A distinctive ugliness

    T2 - Olonial memory in belgium

    AU - Monaville, Pedro

    PY - 2015/1/1

    Y1 - 2015/1/1

    N2 - And indeed, to this day one sees in Belgium a distinctive ugliness, dating from the time when the Congo colony was exploited without restraint and manifested in the macabre atmosphere of certain salons and the strikingly stunted growth of the population, such as one rarely comes across elsewhere. At all events, I well recall that on my first visit to Brussels in December 1964 I encountered more hunchbacks and lunatics than normally in a whole year. Is Belgium an anomaly among European nation-states? Claims about the artificiality of Belgium are as old as the Belgian state itself. These claims have been revived since the 1970s and the centrifugal sequence that has transformed Belgian constitutional apparatus in the direction of confederalism and increased the gap between the country's main linguistic constituencies - the Dutch-speaking inhabitants of Flanders and the French-speaking inhabitants of Wallonia and of Brussels (a city itself enclosed inside the Flemish territory). Several historians, most recently Martin Conway, have argued against the so-called inherent artificiality of the Belgian state, showing instead the contingent character of sub-national separatism and the historical entrenchment of Belgian national feelings. Other scholars have underlined the exemplary dynamic of decentralization and regional autonomy in Belgium as emblematic of state transformations in the context of European integration. Yet, participants in the debates around Belgian exceptionalism have ignored the history and legacy of Belgian imperialism in Africa. What is the relevance of Belgium's colonial past in Central Africa for understanding its current identity and institutional crisis? Historians have commented on the causal connection between decolonization and Belgium's investment in European integration, but they have usually only hinted at the near simultaneity of imperial retreat and national unraveling as mere coincidence or anecdote. It is indeed challenging to clearly highlight effective connections between the two processes. The institutional, cultural, and economic specificities of Belgian Congo, its relative autonomy with regard to the core of the state apparatus and its relative ignorance by the Belgian public, have contributed to render colonialism a detachable appendix, a dispensable chapter in Belgian national history.

    AB - And indeed, to this day one sees in Belgium a distinctive ugliness, dating from the time when the Congo colony was exploited without restraint and manifested in the macabre atmosphere of certain salons and the strikingly stunted growth of the population, such as one rarely comes across elsewhere. At all events, I well recall that on my first visit to Brussels in December 1964 I encountered more hunchbacks and lunatics than normally in a whole year. Is Belgium an anomaly among European nation-states? Claims about the artificiality of Belgium are as old as the Belgian state itself. These claims have been revived since the 1970s and the centrifugal sequence that has transformed Belgian constitutional apparatus in the direction of confederalism and increased the gap between the country's main linguistic constituencies - the Dutch-speaking inhabitants of Flanders and the French-speaking inhabitants of Wallonia and of Brussels (a city itself enclosed inside the Flemish territory). Several historians, most recently Martin Conway, have argued against the so-called inherent artificiality of the Belgian state, showing instead the contingent character of sub-national separatism and the historical entrenchment of Belgian national feelings. Other scholars have underlined the exemplary dynamic of decentralization and regional autonomy in Belgium as emblematic of state transformations in the context of European integration. Yet, participants in the debates around Belgian exceptionalism have ignored the history and legacy of Belgian imperialism in Africa. What is the relevance of Belgium's colonial past in Central Africa for understanding its current identity and institutional crisis? Historians have commented on the causal connection between decolonization and Belgium's investment in European integration, but they have usually only hinted at the near simultaneity of imperial retreat and national unraveling as mere coincidence or anecdote. It is indeed challenging to clearly highlight effective connections between the two processes. The institutional, cultural, and economic specificities of Belgian Congo, its relative autonomy with regard to the core of the state apparatus and its relative ignorance by the Belgian public, have contributed to render colonialism a detachable appendix, a dispensable chapter in Belgian national history.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84954215832&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84954215832&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    M3 - Chapter

    SN - 9781107102293

    SP - 58

    EP - 75

    BT - Memories of Post-Imperial Nations

    PB - Cambridge University Press

    ER -